thomasedzhang
Pakman33
thomasedzhang
Got denied without interview after two weeks application submitted
GMAT 640 (my weakest point)
Undergraduate Industrial Engineering GPA 3.4/4 from Beijing, China
Graduate Quality Systems Engineering GPA 4/4.3, Montreal
Work experience 5.5 years in China, South Korea and Canada
Mostly in project management section, now as R&D Project Manager
PMP Holder
Some political volunteer work, school volunteer work in Montreal
Applied to U of T, Mcgill and Ivey
Was thinking of US and Europe before, but thinking of immigration and work permit issues in both countries, think Canada still better
Applied all on Nov 1st, got invite for interview for Mcgill 3rd week of Nov, but I travelled outside of Canada for work for three weeks, so I only got my interview done on Dec 17th
Got invite from U of T 2nd week of Dec, then had skype interview on the same date Dec 17th
Got offer from U of T Dec 19th, only two days after interview, got offer from McGill on Dec 21st
Decisions are all both pretty fast, I think they are all approaching end of year, so both schools want to close the deal before
Good luck to all.
Congratulations on the admits from Rotman & Desautels !
Which one are you ultimately going to pick? And what was your preference between the three?
Posted from my mobile deviceStill thinking about it. Not 100% sure. I mean I like the job opportunity in Toronto and its higher ranking no matter of the B-school, but generally the whole school also. But living expense there is really high, and competition is too high also. The 350 cohort makes me doubt about if I can really get a chance to know my fellows and my faculty well or get personalized support.
Mcgill is good, general ranking, the quality of life in Montreal, the small class size, only 80 students in total. Lower cost in terms of tuition and living expanse.
How about you?
I think given the choice I would attend Rotman over McGill.
In Montréal and Québec, HEC has a larger network and I find attracts more attention from local offices (primarily from the French MBA-Candidates).
McGill places much better in the rest of Canada, on par with Rotman.
McGill does have a strong brand if you plan on working overseas but based on the above; you seem to prefer staying in Canada.
I guess the question I would ask is where do you want to work in Canada after the MBA?
If the answer is Montréal, then evaluate how well you speak French because it will be crucial to how you place post-MBA. (I've lived in Montréal for nearly 20 years;
French is crucial for upper-management)
If the answer is Toronto/Ontario; then understand that you will still be competing with the 350 Candidates from Rotman (+ Ivey & Queen's) but picking McGill would put you at the disadvantage of being in a different City/Province.
Ultimately, I think Rotman is 1A/1B with Ivey, and having arguably the best MBA in the country which is associated with an internationally elite institution (U of T) is the better choice.
Anyway you slice it; you have admits from the 2 of the Top 4 MBA's in the country.
Assess your situations and future goals and you'll be more than fine with either choice.
I'm applying for the class of 2021 at Ivey, McGill (2022) and HEC Montréal.
Feel free to PM me with any questions.