Bunuel wrote:
Crimes in which handguns are used are more likely than other crimes to result in fatalities. However, the majority of crimes in which handguns are used do not result in fatalities. Therefore, there is no need to enact laws that address crimes involving handguns as distinct from other crimes.
The pattern of flawed reasoning displayed in the argument above most closely resembles that in which one of the following?
(A) Overweight people are at higher risk of developing heart disease than other people. However, more than half of all overweight people never develop heart disease. Hence it is unnecessary for physicians to be more careful to emphasize the danger of heart disease to their overweight patients than to their other patients.
(B) Many people swim daily in order to stay physically fit. Yet people who swim daily increase their risk of developing ear infections. Hence people who want to remain in good health are better off not following fitness programs that include swimming daily.
(C) Most physicians recommend a balanced diet for those who want to remain in good health. Yet many people find that nontraditional dietary regiments such as extended fasting do their health no serious harm. Therefore, there is no need for everyone to avoid nontraditional dietary regiments.
(D) Food rich in cholesterol and fat pose a serious health threat to most people. However, many people are reluctant to give up eating foods that they greatly enjoy. Therefore, people who refuse to give up rich foods need to spend more time exercising than do other people.
(E) Many serious health problems are the result of dietary disorders. Yet these disorders are often brought about by psychological factors. Hence people suffering from serious health problems should undergo psychological evaluation.
OFFICIAL EXPLANATION
(A) Yes. The problem with the argument is that as much as 49 percent of crimes involving handguns could result in fatalities yet still be less than a majority. Similarly, the problem with this answer-choice is that as many as 49 percent of overweight people could develop heart disease yet still be less than half.
(B) No. The problem with the argument is that as much as 49 percent of crimes involving handguns could result in fatalities yet still be less than a majority. However, this answer-choice is not discussing the percentage or faction of people who are better off not following fitness programs that include swimming daily.
(C) No. The problem with the argument is that as much as 49 percent of crimes involving handguns could result in fatalities yet still be less than a majority. However, this answer-choice is not discussing the percentage or faction of people who need not avoid nontraditional dietary regimens.
(D) No. The problem with the argument is that as much as 49 percent of crimes involving handguns could result in fatalities yet still be less than a majority. However, this answer-choice is not discussing the percentage or faction of people who need to spend more time exercising.
(E) No. The problem with the argument is that as much as 49 percent of crimes involving handguns could result in fatalities yet still be less than a majority. However, this answer-choice is not discussing the percentage or faction of people who should undergo psychological evaluation.
_________________