Author 
Message 
Director
Joined: 01 Aug 2008
Posts: 732

1
This post received KUDOS
2
This post was BOOKMARKED
If \(x \gt 1\) and \(y \gt 1\) , is \(x \gt y\) ? 1. \(\sqrt{x} \gt y\) 2. \(\sqrt{y} \lt x\) Source: GMAT Club Tests  hardest GMAT questions I was thinking that we have to come up either 'Yes' or 'No' to the question so I picked choice 4 (each alone can be sufficient) but answer is different. by using choice (1) I can say 'Yes' and by using choice(2) I can say 'No' Can you guys explain this?



Manager
Joined: 23 Aug 2008
Posts: 63

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Oct 2008, 08:25
1
This post received KUDOS
I'm getting choice A. B is not sufficient, answer could be "yes" or "no".
I plugged in numbers, maybe there's a more scientific way though.
just working on condition (2) [since there's no issue on condition 1 for both of us, right?]
Example 1: (root y)=2, x=9 according to the condition, root y < x TRUE, and x>y = TRUE
Example 2: (root y)=2, x=4 according to the condition, root y < x TRUE, and x>y = FALSE
So (2) is insufficient



SVP
Joined: 05 Jul 2006
Posts: 1747

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Oct 2008, 09:18
[quote="ugimba"]if x >1 and y > 1 , is x>y ?
1) root x > y 2) root y < x
X>Y^2 ..........SUFF
FROM 2
Y<X^2........INSUFF
a



Manager
Joined: 20 Mar 2008
Posts: 158
Location: USA

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
27 Oct 2008, 10:18
QS clearly says X & Y are >1.
1) root x > y
There will be values >1 such that Root x> Y and x is not greater than Y. Thus A is the answer.
2) root y < x
Root y< x ... we don't know whether x is greater or lesser than y. Y=4 x=3 root(y)=root(4)=2 <3
The key is, we need to consider each statement separately and see where we stand per that statement before combining both. Hope this helps.



SVP
Joined: 29 Aug 2007
Posts: 2473

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Oct 2008, 21:45
ugimba wrote: if x >1 and y > 1 , is x>y ? 1) root x > y 2) root y < x I was thinking that we have to come up either 'Yes' or 'No' to the question so I picked choice 4 (each alone can be sufficient) but answer is different.
by using choice (1) I can say 'Yes' and by using choice(2) I can say 'No'
Can you guys explain this? 1: yes we can say that cuz x and y both are > 1. so if sqrt(x) > y, x >1. 2: yes or no both i.e we cannot say anything certainly because y could be greater or smaller than x. suppose if y is 4 and x is 3, x is not > y. If y is 2 and x is 3, yes x>y. so st. 2 is nsf. So it is A or 1.
_________________
Verbal: http://gmatclub.com/forum/newtotheverbalforumpleasereadthisfirst77546.html Math: http://gmatclub.com/forum/newtothemathforumpleasereadthisfirst77764.html Gmat: http://gmatclub.com/forum/everythingyouneedtoprepareforthegmatrevised77983.html
GT



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2008
Posts: 185

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Aug 2009, 11:06
if x >1 and y > 1 , is x>y ?
1) \sqrt{x} > y
SUFFICIENT. Since \sqrt{x} > y. This can be rewritten as x > (y^2). And in the range y > 1, (y^2) > y always . Hence x > (y^2) > y.
2) \sqrt{y} < x INSUFFICIENT. Since \sqrt{y} < x. This can be rewritten as y < (x^2). For the range x > 1 and y > 1, by choosing values say
x = 2, y = 3. We have, x^2 = 2^2 = 4 which is greater than y but x = 2 is lesser than y. hence (x^2) > y but x < y.
another set of values say x = 4, y = 3.We have, x^2 = 4^2 = 16 which is greater than y and x = 4 is also greater than y. hence (x^2) > y and x > y.
Hence A.



Intern
Joined: 05 Jan 2010
Posts: 21

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Jan 2010, 12:42
If (x > 1) and (y > 1) are true then which of the statement(s) would or wouldn't make (x > y) correct?
1) (root x > y) SUFFICIENT, the square root is always smaller than the original # so if the square is greater than the original number has to be greater as well. Basically, if root x (which is smaller than actual x) is greater than y.... than actual x is going to be greater as well
2) (root y < x) INSUFFICIENT, this would not work in every situation. One situation where it would work is if y = 2 and x = 5. One situation where it wouldn't is if y = 144 (root y = 12) and x = 16. So, since it doesn't work in every situation it can't make (x > y) correct.
thx!



Intern
Joined: 11 Nov 2009
Posts: 1

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Jan 2010, 00:31
guys, did you try fractions for x and y > 1 . example: x=3/2 and y=2 if you try first condition: root(3/2)=1.22>2 but 3/2 is not > 2 while root(9)=3>2 and it's true that x=9>y=2 so we have true and false answers==>A is insufficient???!!!



Intern
Joined: 26 Jan 2010
Posts: 16
Location: UK
Schools: HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL ONLY

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Jan 2010, 20:26
maheritani wrote: guys, did you try fractions for x and y > 1 . example: x=3/2 and y=2 if you try first condition: root(3/2)=1.22>2 but 3/2 is not > 2 while root(9)=3>2 and it's true that x=9>y=2 so we have true and false answers==>A is insufficient???!!! Statement 1 has more to do with the number property: If the sq root of a certain number(X) is more than the other number ( Y) , thus X will be > than Y Hope it helps
_________________
TimurGMAT CRASHER



Manager
Joined: 23 Oct 2010
Posts: 84
Location: India

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
26 Nov 2010, 06:06
A.
S1 states \sqrt{x} > y > sqrt of x is positive and is greater than 1 > squaring both sides x > y^2 for y> 1 y^2 is always greater than y hence x > y
S2 let y = 1.21 sqrt of y = 1.1 x can be either 1.5 or 1.20 if x is 1.5 the condition holds true however it does not hold true if x is 1.20



Manager
Status: Trying to get into the illustrious 700 club!
Joined: 18 Oct 2010
Posts: 78

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Nov 2010, 15:32
ugimba wrote: If \(x \gt 1\) and \(y \gt 1\) , is \(x \gt y\) ? 1. \(\sqrt{x} \gt y\) 2. \(\sqrt{y} \lt x\) Source: GMAT Club Tests  hardest GMAT questions I was thinking that we have to come up either 'Yes' or 'No' to the question so I picked choice 4 (each alone can be sufficient) but answer is different. by using choice (1) I can say 'Yes' and by using choice(2) I can say 'No' Can you guys explain this? I did the SAME thing ugimba.
Here is how I solved it the second time around...
We knows statement 1 = YES all the way through so it is sufficient
Let's look at statement 2.
If y = 4 the square root of y will be 2. x has to be bigger than 2 so we can choose 3 to be x. Going up to the top we plug the numbers into the equation x>y (3>4) NO
However, to disprove this we need to think of an instance where x is larger than y. Let's try the same setup with y=4. The square root of 4 is 2. X has to be bigger than 2. BUT this time instead of choosing 3 let's choose 7 (really any number greater than 4 will do).
Taking this information we plug into the top equation x>y (7>4) YES
Making statement 2 INSUFFICIENT. Therefore A is the answer.
_________________
I'm trying to not just answer the problem but to explain how I came up with my answer. If I am incorrect or you have a better method please PM me your thoughts. Thanks!



Joined: 31 Dec 1969
Location: Russian Federation
Concentration: Entrepreneurship, International Business
GMAT 3: 740 Q40 V50 GMAT 4: 700 Q48 V38 GMAT 5: 710 Q45 V41 GMAT 6: 680 Q47 V36 GMAT 9: 740 Q49 V42 GMAT 11: 500 Q47 V33 GMAT 14: 760 Q49 V44
WE: Supply Chain Management (Energy and Utilities)

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Dec 2010, 03:11
maheritani wrote: guys, did you try fractions for x and y > 1 . example: x=3/2 and y=2 if you try first condition: root(3/2)=1.22>2 but 3/2 is not > 2 while root(9)=3>2 and it's true that x=9>y=2 so we have true and false answers==>A is insufficient???!!! There is a mistake in your reasoning: root(3/2)<2 and not >2. 3/2 and 2 is not a good example. You can try any variable >1, it works. So A is sufficient. For statement 2, we just need to take x=2 and Y=2 / x=4 and y=2 to see that this statement is not sufficient. => root(2)<4 and 2<4 so "yes" => root(2)<2 but 2=2 so "no" Answer A



Senior Manager
Joined: 19 Oct 2010
Posts: 261
Location: India
GPA: 3

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Jan 2011, 09:29
A! Example stmt2: y=36; x=7 sqrt36=6<7; But y>x, therefore insufficient.
_________________
petrifiedbutstanding



Director
Joined: 01 Feb 2011
Posts: 755

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Jun 2011, 15:50
1. Sufficient
As \sqrt{x} > y , x must be greater than y.
2. Not sufficient
\sqrt{y}<x => x >\sqrt{y}
lets say y=4 =>x>2 if x=3 and y=4 x<y no if x=5 and y=4 x>y yes
Answer is A.



Manager
Joined: 21 Nov 2010
Posts: 128

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Dec 2011, 00:27
I tried to work with easier numbers, so I squared both sides and plugged in two numbers. A was only one that had same results.



Manager
Joined: 10 Jan 2011
Posts: 237
Location: India
GMAT Date: 07162012
GPA: 3.4
WE: Consulting (Consulting)

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Dec 2011, 01:52
I am getting answer A, I solved the problem by picking numbers. Is there any other way to solve. On exam day if we get problem like this what should be strategy to solve such problems (sometimes picking numbers may lead to wrong answer)
_________________
Analyze why option A in SC wrong



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 39701

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2012, 06:09
ugimba wrote: If \(x \gt 1\) and \(y \gt 1\) , is \(x \gt y\) ? 1. \(\sqrt{x} \gt y\) 2. \(\sqrt{y} \lt x\) Source: GMAT Club Tests  hardest GMAT questions I was thinking that we have to come up either 'Yes' or 'No' to the question so I picked choice 4 (each alone can be sufficient) but answer is different. by using choice (1) I can say 'Yes' and by using choice(2) I can say 'No' Can you guys explain this? If \(x>1\) and \(y>1\), is \(x> y\)?Notice that we are told that both \(x\) and \(y\) are greater than 1. (1) \(\sqrt{x}>y\) > since both parts of the inequality are nonnegative we can safely apply squaring: \(x>y^2\). Now, as \(x\) and \(y\) are greater than 1 then \(x>y\). Sufficient. Notice that if we were told that \(x>0\) and \(y>0\), instead of \(x>1\) and \(y>1\), then this statement wouldn't be sufficient. For example consider: \(x=\frac{1}{3}\) and \(y=\frac{1}{2}\) > \(x=\frac{1}{3}>\frac{1}{4}=y^2\) but \(x=\frac{1}{3}<\frac{1}{2}=y\). (2) \(\sqrt{y}<x\) > \(y<x^2\). If \(y=2\) and \(x=3\) then the answer to the question is YES, \(x>y\) but if \(y=2\) and \(x=2\) then the answer to the question is NO, since in this case \(x=y\). Not sufficient. Answer: A.
_________________
New to the Math Forum? Please read this: All You Need for Quant  PLEASE READ AND FOLLOW: 12 Rules for Posting!!! Resources: GMAT Math Book  Triangles  Polygons  Coordinate Geometry  Factorials  Circles  Number Theory  Remainders; 8. Overlapping Sets  PDF of Math Book; 10. Remainders  GMAT Prep Software Analysis  SEVEN SAMURAI OF 2012 (BEST DISCUSSIONS)  Tricky questions from previous years.
Collection of Questions: PS: 1. Tough and Tricky questions; 2. Hard questions; 3. Hard questions part 2; 4. Standard deviation; 5. Tough Problem Solving Questions With Solutions; 6. Probability and Combinations Questions With Solutions; 7 Tough and tricky exponents and roots questions; 8 12 Easy Pieces (or not?); 9 Bakers' Dozen; 10 Algebra set. ,11 Mixed Questions, 12 Fresh Meat DS: 1. DS tough questions; 2. DS tough questions part 2; 3. DS tough questions part 3; 4. DS Standard deviation; 5. Inequalities; 6. 700+ GMAT Data Sufficiency Questions With Explanations; 7 Tough and tricky exponents and roots questions; 8 The Discreet Charm of the DS; 9 Devil's Dozen!!!; 10 Number Properties set., 11 New DS set.
What are GMAT Club Tests? Extrahard Quant Tests with Brilliant Analytics



Intern
Joined: 10 Mar 2013
Posts: 10

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Mar 2013, 04:56
2
This post received KUDOS
Condition 1 = sufficient since even if the square root of X is greater than the Y then X will be greater then Y. Plug in for fractions too the answer remains the same.
condition 2 = not sufficient
Take X= 16 Y =100 and X=16 and Y =4
The answers come out to be opposite. So not sufficient
A is the ans



Manager
Status: Work hard in silence, let success make the noise
Joined: 25 Nov 2013
Posts: 160
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, General Management
GMAT 1: 540 Q50 V15 GMAT 2: 640 Q50 V27
GPA: 3.11
WE: Consulting (Computer Software)

Re: m01 Q5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Dec 2013, 11:22
(1) is sufficient. (2) is not sufficient. So, the answer is A.
_________________
Sahil Chaudhary If you find this post helpful, please take a moment to click on the "+1 KUDOS" icon. My IELTS 7.5 Experience From 540 to 640...Done with GMAT!!! http://www.sahilchaudhary007.blogspot.com











