Author 
Message 
Intern
Joined: 21 Jun 2008
Posts: 31
Schools: Harvard

1
This post received KUDOS
2
This post was BOOKMARKED
Is \(A\) positive? 1. \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all \(x\) 2. \(Ax^2 + 1\) is positive for all \(x\) Source: GMAT Club Tests  hardest GMAT questions S1 is sufficient. x^2  2*x + A = (x  1)^2 + (A  1). For this expression to be always positive A  1 has to be more than 0. A has to be more than 1. S2 is not sufficient. A*x^2 + 1 is positive for all x even if A is 0. The correct answer is A. ***** I believe the solution is incorrect on this question: S1 does not work. For example, use x=10. The equation yields 10^22*10+A>0, so 80+A>0. Than means that A>80, and hence can be negative or positive. S1 says A>x^2+2x, and if you graph the function the answer becomes obvious. S2 does not work, and neither does S1+S2, so the answer should be E.



Intern
Joined: 17 Sep 2008
Posts: 6
Schools: Chicago Booth, Wharton, MIT, Haas

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Sep 2008, 16:53
3
This post received KUDOS
I think you've misunderstood S1. It says that x^2  2*x + A > 0 *for all x*
while x=10 gives you the constraint A>80, it doesn't mean A can equal 79, because then the above statement would not be true for x=9 since 9^2  2*9  79 = 16.
Also, if you plot the graph, y = x^2+2x, the maximum value is y=1 at x=1. So A has to be greater than 1 for S1 to hold true for all x.



Intern
Joined: 10 Sep 2008
Posts: 36

Re: m13 q23 for Mmond4 [#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Oct 2008, 15:08
Hello mmond4
I see you already answered a problem I had a question on and still have the same question. Any of the explanations don't make sense to me. If a statement is true for all x...then I assume what that means is that we can put Any value into x and the resulting equation will also end up positive. Also, what ever value you give for X will automatically change the value of A. I can understand if the question states that A's value doesn't change, but why would we just assume that?
Is the sentense implying that, as in most variable equations, A has one set value and what is that set value of A for all values of x? So, we could actually come up with a value for A, going beyond just confirming it's positive? Thanks



CIO
Joined: 02 Oct 2007
Posts: 1218

Re: m13 q23 for Mmond4 [#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Oct 2008, 05:19
Hi, The S1 is given to identify the minimum value of A which makes the \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\). If it's given that \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\), then we must be sure that \(A\) is such that the inequality holds true. mmond4 provided a good explanation how the range for \(A\) can be found. \(A\) must be greater than 1 for the inequality \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) to hold true. If we know that \(A \gt 1\), we can answer the question (\(A\) is positive). mmond4 +1. Hope this helps. dczuchta wrote: Hello mmond4
I see you already answered a problem I had a question on and still have the same question. Any of the explanations don't make sense to me. If a statement is true for all x...then I assume what that means is that we can put Any value into x and the resulting equation will also end up positive. Also, what ever value you give for X will automatically change the value of A. I can understand if the question states that A's value doesn't change, but why would we just assume that?
Is the sentense implying that, as in most variable equations, A has one set value and what is that set value of A for all values of x? So, we could actually come up with a value for A, going beyond just confirming it's positive? Thanks
_________________
Welcome to GMAT Club! Want to solve GMAT questions on the go? GMAT Club iPhone app will help. Please read this before posting in GMAT Club Tests forum Result correlation between real GMAT and GMAT Club Tests Are GMAT Club Test sets ordered in any way? Take 15 free tests with questions from GMAT Club, Knewton, Manhattan GMAT, and Veritas.
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



Intern
Joined: 09 Feb 2009
Posts: 17

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Aug 2009, 11:35
i believe the solution set to this is wrong.
for S1  x^2  2x + A >= 0 for all X. Eg. if X = 1 your solution now becomes: (sub x = 1 into S1) 1 + 2 + A >=0 therefore A can be negative OR positive hence it should be INSUFFICIENT.
S2  Ax^2 + 1 >=0 A can be 0 (nonnegative or positive) or positive  hence insufficient.
Together they don't work either. so E.
What do you guys think??



CIO
Joined: 02 Oct 2007
Posts: 1218

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Aug 2009, 13:32
You're misunderstanding S1. It works the other way. The whole expression is positive for ALL \(x\). If you substitute \(x=0\), you'll end up with \(A > 0\) (not \(A \ge 0\) as 0 is neither positive nor negative). This is only possible if \(A\) is positive. viperm5 wrote: i believe the solution set to this is wrong.
for S1  x^2  2x + A >= 0 for all X. Eg. if X = 1 your solution now becomes: (sub x = 1 into S1) 1 + 2 + A >=0 therefore A can be negative OR positive hence it should be INSUFFICIENT.
S2  Ax^2 + 1 >=0 A can be 0 (nonnegative or positive) or positive  hence insufficient.
Together they don't work either. so E.
What do you guys think??
_________________
Welcome to GMAT Club! Want to solve GMAT questions on the go? GMAT Club iPhone app will help. Please read this before posting in GMAT Club Tests forum Result correlation between real GMAT and GMAT Club Tests Are GMAT Club Test sets ordered in any way? Take 15 free tests with questions from GMAT Club, Knewton, Manhattan GMAT, and Veritas.
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



Manager
Joined: 24 Apr 2009
Posts: 93

Re: m13 q23 for Mmond4 [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Aug 2009, 13:45
dzyubam wrote: Hi, The S1 is given to identify the minimum value of A which makes the \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\). If it's given that \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\), then we must be sure that \(A\) is such that the inequality holds true. mmond4 provided a good explanation how the range for \(A\) can be found. \(A\) must be greater than 1 for the inequality \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) to hold true. If we know that \(A \gt 1\), we can answer the question (\(A\) is positive). mmond4 +1. Hope this helps. dczuchta wrote: Hello mmond4
I see you already answered a problem I had a question on and still have the same question. Any of the explanations don't make sense to me. If a statement is true for all x...then I assume what that means is that we can put Any value into x and the resulting equation will also end up positive. Also, what ever value you give for X will automatically change the value of A. I can understand if the question states that A's value doesn't change, but why would we just assume that?
Is the sentense implying that, as in most variable equations, A has one set value and what is that set value of A for all values of x? So, we could actually come up with a value for A, going beyond just confirming it's positive? Thanks [color=#408040][/color] what is x = 3. the equation will be 3^22*3+A > 0 so 96+A>0 => 3+A>0 A>3. let us consider the value of A be 1, then the value of the expression will be 2 i.e. positive. So, A can be negative.. we cannot conclude that A is positive by statement 1 alone..



Intern
Joined: 09 Feb 2009
Posts: 17

Re: m13 q23 for Mmond4 [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2009, 10:11
atomy wrote: dzyubam wrote: Hi, The S1 is given to identify the minimum value of A which makes the \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\). If it's given that \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) for all \(x\), then we must be sure that \(A\) is such that the inequality holds true. mmond4 provided a good explanation how the range for \(A\) can be found. \(A\) must be greater than 1 for the inequality \(x^2  2*x + A \gt 0\) to hold true. If we know that \(A \gt 1\), we can answer the question (\(A\) is positive). mmond4 +1. Hope this helps. dczuchta wrote: Hello mmond4
I see you already answered a problem I had a question on and still have the same question. Any of the explanations don't make sense to me. If a statement is true for all x...then I assume what that means is that we can put Any value into x and the resulting equation will also end up positive. Also, what ever value you give for X will automatically change the value of A. I can understand if the question states that A's value doesn't change, but why would we just assume that?
Is the sentense implying that, as in most variable equations, A has one set value and what is that set value of A for all values of x? So, we could actually come up with a value for A, going beyond just confirming it's positive? Thanks [color=#408040][/color] what is x = 3. the equation will be 3^22*3+A > 0 so 96+A>0 => 3+A>0 A>3. let us consider the value of A be 1, then the value of the expression will be 2 i.e. positive. So, A can be negative.. we cannot conclude that A is positive by statement 1 alone.. thats exactly it Atomy. A is not restricted to ALWAYS be > 0 because x can be ANY number. So for instance you sub in 3, A can be negative OR positive and the equation will still hold true. HENCE S1 is insufficient.



Senior Manager
Joined: 18 Aug 2009
Posts: 299

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Nov 2009, 22:41
agree with dzyubam Got it wrong as well. Difficult and tricky question. And as the OE goes, the key is to get the equation in the form (if I go and meditate in the Tibet mountains for few years, then maybe I'll get it in test conditions ): \(x^2  2*x + A = (x  1)^2 + (A  1)\) First part of the expression is always positive, For the full expression to be positive, A has to be greater than 1. In normal terms, I understood this as \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive where A is constant. So I need to focus on the case when \(x^2  2x\) is NEGATIVE, because then A will HAVE to be a positive and because A is a constant and x varies, A remains positive for other cases too... hence positiveA which is same as OA A



Manager
Joined: 04 Feb 2007
Posts: 85

Re: m13 q23 for Mmond4 [#permalink]
Show Tags
29 Mar 2010, 19:58
viperm5 wrote: viperm5 wrote: viperm5 wrote: Hello mmond4
I see you already answered a problem I had a question on and still have the same question. Any of the explanations don't make sense to me. If a statement is true for all x...then I assume what that means is that we can put Any value into x and the resulting equation will also end up positive. Also, what ever value you give for X will automatically change the value of A. I can understand if the question states that A's value doesn't change, but why would we just assume that?
Is the sentense implying that, as in most variable equations, A has one set value and what is that set value of A for all values of x? So, we could actually come up with a value for A, going beyond just confirming it's positive? Thanks [color=#408040][/color] what is x = 3. the equation will be 3^22*3+A > 0 so 96+A>0 => 3+A>0 A>3. let us consider the value of A be 1, then the value of the expression will be 2 i.e. positive. So, A can be negative.. we cannot conclude that A is positive by statement 1 alone.. thats exactly it Atomy. A is not restricted to ALWAYS be > 0 because x can be ANY number. So for instance you sub in 3, A can be negative OR positive and the equation will still hold true. HENCE S1 is insufficient. Yeah this is tricky and it got me. However since the stimulus states that the expression is positive for all x, it means that it MUST hold for all values together. This is an AND condition rather than an OR. If it didn't include the phrase "for all x" then you can say that for a certain x value, A can have a certain value, thus A can be negative here: If x = 3 then A > 3 OR if x = 10 then A > 80 OR if x = 6 then A > 24, etc... This is what a standard equation says... But since it holds for ALL x, then we have the following condition: If x = 3 then A > 3 AND if x = 10 then A > 80 AND if x = 6 then A > 24, etc... so as the x values change the boundary condition for A keeps changing, i.e. A > 80 AND A > 24 AND A > 3 etc... and ends up holding true for all AND any value of x when A > 0. Hope that clears things up..
_________________
If you like my post, a kudos is always appreciated



Senior Manager
Joined: 01 Feb 2010
Posts: 264

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Apr 2010, 06:31
CrushTheGMAT wrote: Is \(A\) positive? 1. \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all \(x\) 2. \(Ax^2 + 1\) is positive for all \(x\) 1: suppose x = 1, to have \(x^2  2x + A\) positive, A will be +ve but when x = 3, then equation becomes 96+A so A can be 1, 2 and still the equation is +ve hence statement insufficient. 2: for all x other than 0 x^2 will be +ve so \(Ax^2 + 1\) to be +ve A has to +ve for x = 0 we are not sure on value of A, as anything multiplied by 0 is 0. Combining, its sufficient as when x = 0 then from (1) we can say A is +ve and for x > 2 from (2) we can say A is +ve hence C. OA should be wrong.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 39672

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Apr 2010, 06:34
CrushTheGMAT wrote: Is \(A\) positive? 1. \(x^2  2x + A\) is positive for all \(x\) 2. \(Ax^2 + 1\) is positive for all \(x\) Source: GMAT Club Tests  hardest GMAT questions S1 is sufficient. x^2  2*x + A = (x  1)^2 + (A  1). For this expression to be always positive A  1 has to be more than 0. A has to be more than 1. S2 is not sufficient. A*x^2 + 1 is positive for all x even if A is 0. The correct answer is A. ***** I believe the solution is incorrect on this question: S1 does not work. For example, use x=10. The equation yields 10^22*10+A>0, so 80+A>0. Than means that A>80, and hence can be negative or positive. S1 says A>x^2+2x, and if you graph the function the answer becomes obvious. S2 does not work, and neither does S1+S2, so the answer should be E. Question: is \(A>0\)? (1) \(x^22x+A\) is positive for all \(x\): \(f(x)=x^22x+A\) is a function of of upward parabola (as coefficient of \(x^2\) is positive). We are told that it's positive for all \(x\) > \(f(x)=x^22x+A>0\), which means that this function is "above" Xaxis OR in other words parabola has no intersections with Xaxis OR equation \(x^22x+A=0\) has no real roots. Quadratic equation to has no real roots discriminant must be negative > \(D=2^24A=44A<0\) > \(1A<0\) > \(A>1\). Sufficient. (2) \(Ax^2+1\) is positive for all \(x\): \(Ax^2+1>0\) > when \(A\geq0\) this expression is positive for all \(x\). So \(A\) can be zero too. Not sufficient. Answer: A.
_________________
New to the Math Forum? Please read this: All You Need for Quant  PLEASE READ AND FOLLOW: 12 Rules for Posting!!! Resources: GMAT Math Book  Triangles  Polygons  Coordinate Geometry  Factorials  Circles  Number Theory  Remainders; 8. Overlapping Sets  PDF of Math Book; 10. Remainders  GMAT Prep Software Analysis  SEVEN SAMURAI OF 2012 (BEST DISCUSSIONS)  Tricky questions from previous years.
Collection of Questions: PS: 1. Tough and Tricky questions; 2. Hard questions; 3. Hard questions part 2; 4. Standard deviation; 5. Tough Problem Solving Questions With Solutions; 6. Probability and Combinations Questions With Solutions; 7 Tough and tricky exponents and roots questions; 8 12 Easy Pieces (or not?); 9 Bakers' Dozen; 10 Algebra set. ,11 Mixed Questions, 12 Fresh Meat DS: 1. DS tough questions; 2. DS tough questions part 2; 3. DS tough questions part 3; 4. DS Standard deviation; 5. Inequalities; 6. 700+ GMAT Data Sufficiency Questions With Explanations; 7 Tough and tricky exponents and roots questions; 8 The Discreet Charm of the DS; 9 Devil's Dozen!!!; 10 Number Properties set., 11 New DS set.
What are GMAT Club Tests? Extrahard Quant Tests with Brilliant Analytics



Manager
Joined: 15 Sep 2009
Posts: 134

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Apr 2010, 06:42
Lets take statement 2 first
Ax^2 + 1 is positive for all +ve X.
x^2 will be positive irrespective the value of x.So Ax^2 will be + or  based on the value of A.So statement 2 is insuff.
Lets take statement 1 now x^2 2x + A is +ve for +ve x.
Resolving this Q.E we get x = 1+/ sqrt(1A) .This will be positive only when A <1.Putting the value A =0,we will get x=0 but given x is positive.So A has be to ve.So this statement is suff.
I will go with option A.



Intern
Joined: 26 Feb 2009
Posts: 13
Location: Nairobi
Schools: HBS

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Apr 2010, 07:45
Is A positive?
1. x^2  2x + A is positive for all x 2. Ax^2 + 1 is positive for all x
S1. Option 1: assume x = 10 and A = 1, then S1 = 10020+1 = 81 which is +ve Option 2: assume x = 10 and A = 1, then S1 = 100201 = 79 which also holds true i.e. S1 is +ve Insufficient
S2. Option 1: assume x = 1 and A = 1, then S2 = 1+1 = 2 which is +ve Option 2: assume x = 1 and A = 1/2, then S2 = 1/2+1 = 1/2 which also holds true i.e. S2 is +ve Insufficient
S1 & S2 combined Insufficient
E, my two cents worth.



Intern
Joined: 15 Nov 2009
Posts: 16

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Apr 2010, 07:57
For S1, I prefer to use calculus:
y=x^22x+A y'=2X2
so the minimum is
0=2X2 X=1
so
y(1)=1^22+A=1+A
for S1 to be positive A should be greater than 1
For S2 I see that A could take negative values and still be positive:
y=Ax^2+1
Ax^2+1>0 Ax^2>1 A>1/x^2
So, statement 1 is sufficient alone
Regretfully, I'm still using a lot of time to solve the problem.



Manager
Joined: 05 Mar 2010
Posts: 217

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Apr 2010, 01:52
1
This post received KUDOS
This is tricky question It got me initially .......but after careful thinking I decided to go with A Stmt 1  if we take x=0 then A >0 to satisfy the condition because it says the statement is equation is positive for all values of x. SUFFICIENT stmt 2  even if A=0 the statement is positive for all x because of +1 NOT SUFFICIENT
_________________
Success is my Destiny



Intern
Joined: 26 Jun 2010
Posts: 5

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Jul 2010, 17:57
Here is my preposition. Pardon me if it is over ambitious or too pedantic. Why r we evaluating the sign of A for the min value of the expression x^22*x? Should not we be looking at the max value of x^22*x to determine whether A is positive or negative? Therefore,I think S1 is insuff.
Any comments or corrections will be much appreciated.



CIO
Joined: 02 Oct 2007
Posts: 1218

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Jul 2010, 01:54
Does this post answer your question: m13q2370269.html#p518925? Scithian wrote: Here is my preposition. Pardon me if it is over ambitious or too pedantic. Why r we evaluating the sign of A for the min value of the expression x^22*x? Should not we be looking at the max value of x^22*x to determine whether A is positive or negative? Therefore,I think S1 is insuff.
Any comments or corrections will be much appreciated.
_________________
Welcome to GMAT Club! Want to solve GMAT questions on the go? GMAT Club iPhone app will help. Please read this before posting in GMAT Club Tests forum Result correlation between real GMAT and GMAT Club Tests Are GMAT Club Test sets ordered in any way? Take 15 free tests with questions from GMAT Club, Knewton, Manhattan GMAT, and Veritas.
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



Forum Moderator
Status: mission completed!
Joined: 02 Jul 2009
Posts: 1400
GPA: 3.77

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Oct 2010, 12:27
Bunuel's explanations are clear enough. Thanks Dzyubam, do you consider to replace "for all x" to "any X"...
_________________
Audaces fortuna juvat!
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings



CIO
Joined: 02 Oct 2007
Posts: 1218

Re: m13 q23 [#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Oct 2010, 10:03
Sure I can change it, but I don't see a difference. Why is "any X" wording better? Sorry if I'm missing something obvious . Pkit wrote: Bunuel's explanations are clear enough. Thanks
Dzyubam, do you consider to replace "for all x" to "any X"...
_________________
Welcome to GMAT Club! Want to solve GMAT questions on the go? GMAT Club iPhone app will help. Please read this before posting in GMAT Club Tests forum Result correlation between real GMAT and GMAT Club Tests Are GMAT Club Test sets ordered in any way? Take 15 free tests with questions from GMAT Club, Knewton, Manhattan GMAT, and Veritas.
GMAT Club Premium Membership  big benefits and savings







Go to page
1 2
Next
[ 36 posts ]




