Paras237 wrote:
Except can also be used as a conjunction.
It implies but and except are redundant. So why B is incorrect?
Hello
Paras237,
I will be glad to help you out with one.
When two words having the same meaning is used in a sentence to convey an idea, redundancy error takes place. For example,
1. He
annually participates in a marathon
every year.
2.
Although she is good in English literature,
but she could not score well in the exam.
In both the above-mentioned sentence, we spot redundancy error because
annually and
every year in sentence 1 and
although and
but in sentence 2 mean the same and present the same idea.
However, in the context of this official sentence, use of
but and
except together does not lead to redundancy error because both these words have been used to present two different contrasts as follows.
Contrast 1 = Mauritius was a British colony for almost 200 years,
but the English language was never really spoken on the island.
Contrast 2 =
Except in the domains of administration and teaching, the English language was never really spoken on the island.
As you can see, while
but presents the contrast with regards to English not being spoken in Mauritius despite it being a British colony for two centuries, use of
except tells us that in which areas the language was used.
Remove any of the word from the sentence and you will see that the sentence misses something.
Also,
comma + but is required in the sentence to join the two independent clauses -
Mauritius was a British colony for almost 200 years
the English language was never really
spoken on the island.
Hope this helps.
Thanks.
Shraddha
I have another question about this: why is there a comma behind "teaching"? I know that we need a comma before "but" but I am unable to define the second comma grammatically.