Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:
Most citizens are very conscientious about observing a law [#permalink]
22 Aug 2006, 09:15
0% (00:00) correct
0% (00:00) wrong based on 2 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Most citizens are very conscientious about observing a law when they can see the reason behind it. For instance, there has been very little need to actively enforce the recently-implemented law that increased the penalty for motorists caught leaving a gas station without paying for gas they had pumped into their vehicles. This is because citizens are very conscientious of the high cost of gasoline and they know that stealing gas will only further increase the price of gasoline for everyone.
Which of the following statements would the author of this passage be most likely to believe?
(A) The increased penalty alone is a significant motivation for most citizens to obey the law.
(B) There are still too many inconsiderate citizens in the local community.
(C) High gasoline prices can be brought down if everyone does his or her part and pays for the gasoline they use at the pumps.
(D) Society should make an effort to teach citizens the reasons for its laws.
(E) People would be more likely to speed on a stretch of deserted highway than to not pay for gasoline.
My answer is A
B,C&E definitely out.
D is too strong, the author never stated his preference for a conscientious society, he was just stating a cause and effect situation.
Therefore, A. because he disregards other factors that might affect the result
CR Gist: If people know the reasons for the laws, they are more likely to follow them.
A can come close, but it says "increased penalty alone is sufficient to make people follow the law"... this is not the view the argument has. The argument has the view that if people know the reasons behind the laws they will follow them and the high-penalty laws do not need to be actively enforced.
OA is D. Choice D is correct because it neatly summarizes the main theme of the passage. We can instantly eliminate answer choice A because the passage never states how the increased penalty affects citizens. Choice B is too extreme, and overly negative. (Such answer choices are rarely correct on the GMAT.) Besides, the overall theme of the passage is positive; the negative tone of choice B is out of keeping with it. Answer choice C is incorrect because the author stated only that adherence to the law would prevent the price of gasoline from rising further. He never said that this action would lower gas prices.
i change my answer from A to D.
I can't believe I was so careless. The passage clearly states "little need to actively enforce the recently-implemented law that increased the penalty" Therefore,"The increased penalty alone is a significant motivation for most citizens to obey the law." contradicts the author's view.
I completely took out D at first, because it came on too strong. But by POE, I think it best fits the passage.
Thanks haas_mba07 for the clarification