It depends on what type of MC you are talking about, really. Yes, you might be able to break into Deloitte from Tepper, but I doubt they will be recruiting Strategy or Operations consultants there. More than likely you'll end up in Human Capital, IT consulting, or something less prestigious and likewise lower paying.
If your target is MBB, forget about Tepper. Unless you have a serious network connection, you're not getting MBB at Tepper, at least not compared to what you would at Sloan. It really isn't close. Sloan is a prime target for those top firms. Tepper simply isn't.
Second and third tier firms are definitely an option at Tepper, and 90k in debt is definitely a lot to swallow. Especially if youre already swimming in undergrad debt or other kinds.
But I would venture to guess that the average management consultant graduating from Sloan probably makes (with bonuses and benefits) a least $20k more than his/her peer from Tepper in their first year alone. Maybe even more. You could potentially pay back your 90k in loans within 3-4 years if you live on a budget and make a conscious effort to pay down the principal as soon as you graduate. And then you're left with zero debt and a career's worth of higher earning potential.
There are a lot of industries where the place where you got your degree from is irrelevant or matters very little. MC, unfortunately, is not one of those industries. Name brand matters, a LOT.
Go to Sloan.
Posted from GMAT ToolKit