Columbia Profile Evaluation - Tools for B-School Profile Evaluation

Yes, a prep course is a good idea! I highly recommend ManhattanPrep.

It may be a bit early for this, as I am planning to apply via early admissions for the August 2020 entry, and so still need to take the GMAT a few times and round out my profile, but would love feedback. (Also: is there an advantage to applying really, really early—like, as soon as early admissions opens?)

Demographics: U.S. citizen, white male. Would be freshly 26 if entering August 2020.

Education:
[*] BA in Economics and German from a top-five public U.S. university
[*] 3.5 GPA (technically 3.487...) and honors thesis/departmental honors in German

Scores:
[*] Just took my first full-length practice GMAT:
[*] Overall: 700
[*] Verbal: 43
[*] Quantitative: 43
[*] IR: 3 (Ouch)

I think I should be able to improve this a good bit after some preparation and several real GMATs. I am generally good at standardized tests. So... let's call it a 720.

Work Experience:
[*] I am just finishing a two-year rotation program out of undergrad in finance/project management with a large industrial multinational, doing mostly process improvement and data analytics related to financial controlling for heavy industry.
[*] Now returning to one of those rotations to spearhead an initiative to introduce better data analysis (Tableau, Alteryx, etc.) related to factory controlling (absorption, improving pricing, etc.).

If I entered in August 2020, I would have a little over four years of work experience upon entry (around 2.75 upon applying). One of my college internships was in Germany, but not sure that is relevant anymore. Manufacturing isn't hugely represented in the Columbia stats I can find, but hoping maybe that can set me apart (and that the international angle will help).

Involvement:
[*] As I have been moving around every six months since college, I haven't had much of a chance to really lay down roots and do much related to extracurricular. I was involved with some political groups, the German major, and my college paper in undergrad (again, not sure if relevant anymore). I think before I apply, I will get involved in an LGBT chamber of commerce and try to find something service-related.

Goals:
[*] Having seen different businesses in the conglomerate and worked on improvement initiatives, my first pick would be traditional management consulting gigs after MBA.

Thank you so much in advance for the help!

Background: Applying in Fall 2018 for Fall 2019 start date.
Race/nationality: White, US
Sex: Male

Undergrad school/major: University of Pittsburgh, Accounting/Finance
Undergrad GPA: 3.85

GMAT Score: 760 Total, 49Q, 44V, AWA 6, IR 8

Work experience and leadership: 3 years of work experience upon submission of applications in Fall 2018 (4 upon planned matriculation) in Big 4 Public Accounting, Audit. I have completed a rotation in the TAS practice at my firm (specifically due diligence) and will be transferring full-time next Spring (I think this is a big selling point and shows growth in my career as the rotations are very selective in my office/firm).

Community and Others:
Volunteer dog-walker at local animal rescue shelters, helping to prepare and lead a booth at the upcoming Made in America festival in Philly.
Volunteer at LLS, organized multiple charity events and an office-wide team for a stair climb event.
President of Beta Alpha Psi during undergrad.
Undergraduate Teaching Assistant during undergrad
Recipient of scholarship awarded to "Top Achieving Academic Student" during undergrad.
IM Leagues

Certifications: Licensed CPA

Post-Grad Goal of MBA: To secure a position with a BB Investment Bank (specifically M&A/Core IB division), with the ultimate goal of transitioning to Corporate Development for a F100-F500 Company in consumer products. I want to consolidate companies in the industry to create a company that creates innovative products which make a difference in the day-to-day lives of consumers.

Additional: I think my WE/Demographic will lead to an uphill battle but my stats are strong and I think my extra-curriculars are solid. My recs should also be quite strong. I am applying for E

Background and nationality: Indian Male

Undergrad : Manipal University,India ; GPA 6.6/10 - Civil Engineering

Work Ex : 42 months total

A. 13 months as Product Manager in an small e-commerce B2C startup that also has a B2B side.
Key highlight: worked on digitization of airport for the leading airport operator in South-east Asia. The project is to improve revenue opportunities for the airport operators.
B. 26 months in various roles at mid-size e-commerce B2C startup.
Key highlight: Joined in a very junior role but got two promotions within a year and was made the Associate Product Manager (junior-level management) in the team. Have experience of leading a small team and building a small software product from the scratch.
C. 3 months of sales internship in a small e-commerce B2C startup
Key highlight: Was on the field for 3 months talking to the mom & pop stores in Mumbai enabling them to fight the fight with the big e-commerce companies.

Post-MBA goals:
1. Leading business vertical in tech firms such as Google, Amazon or Microsoft
2. Long term: Get into teaching

Key issues with my profile:
1. Completed engineering degree in 5 years instead of 4.
2. Was unemployed for a year after passing from college
3. No extra-curricular whatsoever

Hello blackfish

Columbia and the likes will look at your profile holistically on all the admission factors mentioned here
While your work ex shows potential, it will help understand what sort of GMAT score are you expecting.
Your past acads are on the lower side and completing engineering in 5 years, 1 year employment will further negatively impact. So target a high GMAT of 740+ at least. It will not really compensate for these weaknesses (only your story in the essays can do that).
Coming to extracurricular- you need not have anything formal, what do you do outside work in your free time? If you can showcase a productive activity that helps you grow personally/professionally, then it may help.
Coming to the last part career goals- firstly, be more specific- what sort of business role are you looking at. Plus if your long term goal is academics (say 10 years) then how does an MBA and this business role fit in? These are not the right stepping stones to move into academics. The narrative will look weak and is the most critical element of your application. You could read more on career goals here.
Based on the info, Columbia looks a stretch, but depends on what qualitative info you bring to the table.

Best
Varun Sharma
+919137133507
Free Profile Review
MBAkarma.com
GMAT Score Predictor
info@mbakarma.com

Thanks for the reply.

Forgot to mention my GMAT score

GMAT Score: 740

Q50 / V40 / IR 6

Awaiting the AWA score

I am not actually quiet clear about the long term plan. Honestly, I would say I don't know the **** I would like to do but I do enjoy solving problems. Also, I would like to work in a role that can impact people positively. So, economic empowerment or education is where I would like to build a career.

As far as leading a business vertical in a tech giant is concerned, what I wanted to say was I would like to lead expansions geographically or in a new market. Say for example: Amazon wants to expand internationally and begin operations in Pakistan. That would satiate my need for solving problems and empowering people economically.

Do I have a chance if I only have a 680?

Hi there, and thanks for writing. You have a well-rounded profile, with strong academics, progressive work experience, and good community involvement. I think the key to your application will be executing it with excellence, including: explaining the motivations behind your career goals, being clear why CBS is a fit for you based on its culture, location, and resources within & outside of the classroom, and communicating on your resume and applications the impact you've made within and outside of work. If you'd like to discuss your profile in greater detail, I recommend signing up for a free consultation here: https://www.mbamission.com/consult/?dis ... admissions

Hello,

Do I stand a realistic chance of getting in? My profile:

1.) Indian Female, 24, Muslim
2.) GMAT: 730 (q50, v39, IR-3( I know it's bad!), AWA-6.0)
3.) Undergrad: Engineering , GPA: 4.0 (according to MBA.com conversion table)
4.) Currently working at Dell Technologies, 2 years of work experience after graduating. (Will be 3 yrs before joining the school)

International work experience: YES (was one of the select few to attend the Dell Annual IT Summit at Austin and learnt a lot from the experience)

I joined my team as a software analyst but my manager seeing good management and communication skills in me, encouraged me to take up project management and thus I became a project coordinator for my team within 6 months of joining the company. I worked with my team to do anything possible to help them perform at their highest level. This involves removing any impediments to progress, communicating with other teams for requirements, etc. So, you might say I have managing experience as well. I was a Scrum Master for my team and I have a certification of Certified Scrum Master as well.

5.) Extra-curricular: Vocalist in college band and still sing sometimes at clubs,worked with NGOs to help educate poor muslim girls, blogging, modelling, travelling

I was also the networking lead in the IT Development Program in Dell. I have organised numerous events and led all the members(in numbers of 50-60) of the ITDP program on various occasions.

Post MBA goals: Product Marketing Manager in a company I believe in.
Long term goals: Chief Marketing officer , again in a company I believe in.

Please give an honest feedback if I have a shot at getting in. And if not, which schools do you suggest me to apply to?

Thanks a bunch!!
Tasneem

Hi everyone!

I am a female african. Born, raised and studied in Morocco.
GMAT : 700 Q48 V36
Undergrad : "Classes préparatoires" + Engineering school
Global WE ( at matriculation) : 42 months
- 6 months : full-time volunteer ( Local ONG in my hometown)
-16 months : Finance & IT consultant ( IT leader in my country )
- 24 months : Project manager in Risk Management ( Corporate Bank)

I am applying ED and would love to know what are my chances. Do I have to start the other schools apps or wait to hear from CBS ?

Hello - looking for input on my odds and whether I should ED?

Background and nationality: white (middle eastern)
Undergrad Information: top 10 public university, degree in economics
GMAT: 730
GPA: 3.35
Work experience and leadership: 3 years Oil & Gas supply chain rotational program (top 3 O&G firm), 1 year finance analyst smaller company (promotion and pay raise, so changed companies)
Community and others: led mentor programs, launched an iOS app that failed
Post MBA goals: consulting
Anything else: Should I ED??

edited

Hi everyone,

Background:
Korean-American (born in Brooklyn)
Age 27
GMAT 710

Education:
BBA in Risk Management and Insurance from Temple University
Honors Program, Magna Cum Laude, GPA: 3.76

Work Experience: Total 5 years
Job 1 (2 years) - Global Property Underwriter at world's largest publicly traded insurance company. Analyzed and managed risk for complex multinational property portfolios.

Job 2 (3 years) - Co-Founder/CEO of energy efficiency consulting company. Started the company during my sophomore year of college and worked part-time while working at the insurance firm until it grew to the point where I decided to pursue the energy consulting full-time. Worked with property managers, building owners, etc to convert their facilities to up to 70% efficiency. Portfolio annual savings at about $1M.

Extra curriculars - After winning first place at a business pitch competition for Emerging Young Entrepreneurs, joined as an advisor/assistant director of the program focused on fostering and accelerating underrepresented minority owned businesses to work with government and corporate entities.
At the time of application, will be working in Singapore for a network organization connecting non-profit startup ventures to impact investors and government grants.
In college and throughout my insurance role, contributed to a firm that is dedicated to creating opportunities for asian-americans in leadership roles in corporations.

Post MBA Goal - further hone business strategy consulting skills to support global social enterprises in creating sustainable business models. Long-term goal: create a fund that supports social enterprises with the potential for financial returns for investors.

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks,
Chris

Hi Chris,
Your profile is quite strong although the weakness I see is the GMAt score. Is there any chance of a retake or are you submitting with this score?
Your goals seem aligned with your role at the non-profit venture work that you are doing. You will have to make a convincing argument for why these goals make sense. Demonstrate your passion and also your understanding of how CBS can help you achieve your goals.
Very strong recommendations can help overcome a low GMAT score, so select your recommenders wisely and make sure they put in excellent recommendations for you.

Hi mbaMissionNishaT! MBADecoder!
Can you please evaluate my profile?

Age/ Gender/ Nationality: 26/ Male/ Indian

Education: BE Mech with a cgpa of 7.7/10 (non-IIT NIT). recently completed a 30 hr certificate course in finance.

Work Experience: 4.5 years as a mechanical engineer in a private engineering services company. was involved in R&d under a
retired IIT prof. Lead a team of 4 individuals, all of them elder to me.

Extra curriculars: Was active in plays during college. Also some sporadic volunteer activities that involved creating environmental awareness to kids in schools
through plays, organising cultural events for kids from orphanages throughout the city etc. captain of a local futsal team.

GMAT: 720

Post MBA: Corporate Finance

Short term goal is I would like to get a job as financial analyst at the Big 4s, preferably in the valuation depts. continuing and growing up the corporate ladder
would be my long term goal.