iMyself wrote:
Hi
AjiteshArun,
I haven't got any response yet. I'm waiting for Jamboree response. Thanks...
I haven't gone through all the other responses, but I'll try to help you out. There are two major points I think we should discuss: (a) the change in meaning and (b) whether
some constructions are impossible.
We'll not leave until the police arrive.and
We'll not leave as long as the police arrive.The first one gives us something after which we can "leave" (an
event or a
time). The second one, however, changes the meaning (it becomes a conditional statement). The second basically says that if the police "arrive", we'll not leave.
We'll not leave as long as the police continue locking innocent people up.This one is possible.
We'll leave as long as the police (also) leave.In this one the "duration" meaning is not possible (this is actually a condition).
Now for the two sentences you are interested in:
(a)
The acrobatic show will begin at 6 p.m. and continue until audience interest lasts.audience interest lasts doesn't give us an "event" or "particular time". Instead, it gives us a "duration". This construction is not possible. I'm still going by sound on this one though. You're welcome to ask for a second opinion.
(b)
iMyself wrote:
I will ask this question in this forum as long as I get the solution.
>>This is very bad-we should not ask any question for several times after getting the proper answer. So, this sentence is not legitimate at all. If I am in my target (I'll boil water until rice is cooked-the target is cooking rice), why do I ask any question again and again? I should not do it, isn’t it?
I will ask this question in this forum as long as I get the solution for better understand.
This is legitimate sentence. Here, better understand indicates WHY I ask this question for several time. This indicates the actual reason for asking this question again and again.
In the original question (the acrobatic show…), the questioner did not mention any specific reason WHY the acrobatic show will continue after getting interest. So, I think, ‘until’ is correct in the original question not ‘as long as'.
also, I want to have attention to all the verbal expert of GMAT CLUB. Please, correct me, if I'm wrong.
Unfortunately, both the sentences are incorrect. Even if we ignore other mistakes, we just can't say
I will ask this question in this forum as long as I get the solution for better understanding.The problem is that we don't want to ask the question as long as we get a solution. We want to ask the question as long as it remains unanswered (again, we're going for the "duration" meaning, not the conditional statement). A shorter example is:
You won't know until you try.Once you try, you'll know.
You won't know as long as you try.If you keep trying, you won't know.