AjiteshArun wrote:
dave13 wrote:
I really appreciate presence of all experts on gmatclub, but I totally agree with dcummins that it is really confusing and in some cases professionally unethical in my opinion. Moreover when user tags an expert it means that that user wishes to have explanation from that particular expert and not from another expert. the reason for this is - users choose the best experts for them
And if other users still would have questions after explanation was posted, they would definately ask questions by postig them. I think it is unprofessional for example in the case below
https://gmatclub.com/forum/increased-po ... l#p2263151 the tag was directed at generis but other expert who was not mentioned in the post replied to it on the same day when question was posted intead of generis ...
Exceptions could be when the pending questions remain unanswered by that particular expert after some time and other users or experts, in other words kind people, reply it after some time - which are always welcomed
have a great weekend eveyone
Cheers,
Dave
Hi
dave13,
The "other expert" bit wasn't exactly an example of extreme subtlety, so I'll respond to your post. You know, so that the "other expert" can have a say.
This is a public forum, and a public thread. Throwing words like
"unethical" and
"unprofessional" around in your original and edited responses (and no, editing your response before I could reply doesn't make it "okay" to use the word "unethical" in the first place) is not particularly nice. You're still welcome to do it though. After all, public forum, public thread.
My view is that my response did not prevent anyone from responding to a post. Nor did it prevent anyone from reading anyone else's response. Once the person who posted pointed out that he or she did not appreciate it, I did what I could, even though I did not really have to, and even though I do not agree with his or her position that no one else can respond to a post once someone else has been tagged in it.
Feel free to let me know why you feel my responses are morally incorrect, although I suggest you do so over PM (or report my posts directly to a moderator), as the last few posts are completely off-topic.
And yes, have a great weekend!
Ajitesh
To Whom It May Concern
your post above revolves mostly around the "unethical"
Do you know that when you try finding faults with the words of opponent, you admit that you dont have substantive arguments.
As for unethical, yes actually i wrote initially professionally unethical but then changed simply onto "unprofessional" because "unethical" and "unprofessional"
are synonyms, so i preferred simply to use one word "unproffessional" instead of two, plus it is not wordy
I do not throw words, I draw conclusions from what you wrote
And
dcummins pointed out that when one experts post is followed by another expert`s, this is confusing, so i totally agree with dcummins
That being said its unprofessional because you not only prevent other experts who are much more conscious than you, from posting explanations
but you also dont don`t consider interests of regular users who tag (in this case)
generis, and wanted explanations from generis, and not from you,
so you rather show what you "can".
As for "no one else can respond to a post once someone else has been tagged in it."
Again its not about "can" its about considering interests of regular user who prefers one expert over another (put up with it , like it or not
) so thats why we (users) tag. C`est la vie.
I hope you will understand some day (hopefully soon
) that acting so is
professionaly unethical :grin:
I like open discussion, and if you suggest me to pm you, then why didnt you initially PM duumicus, but replied to him/her in this thread.
No need to thank me for this post, just give me kudos for this post
Can you ? yes, you can. is it unethical ? who knows
don't think hard
Cheers,
Dave
p.s.
Attachments
SCR_unethical_synonyms.png [ 92.2 KiB | Viewed 4047 times ]