Ellen can purchase a certain computer at a local store at th

Ellen can purchase a certain computer at a local store at the price of p dollars and pay a 6 percent sales tax. Alternatively, Ellen can purchase the same computer from a catalog for a total of q dollars, including all taxes and shipping costs. Will it cost more for Ellen to purchase the computer from the local store than from the catalog?

The price from the store = p+0.06p=1.06p.
The price from the catalog = q.

The question asks: is 1.06p>q?

(1) q - p < 50. If q=p, then the answer is YES (1.06p>q) but if q=120 and p=100, then the answer is NO (1.06p<q). Not sufficient.

(2) q = 1,150. The question becomes: is 1.06p>1,150. No info about p. Not sufficient.

(1)+(2) Since q = 1,150, then from (1) we have that 1,150-p<50 --> p>1,100 --> 1.06p>1,100*1.06>1,150. Sufficient.

Answer: C.

Hope it's clear.
_________________

Hi All,

Certain types of DS questions will appear on Test Day to measure the thoroughness of your thinking. You can see from the statistics above this prompt that almost half of the people who attempted it got it wrong. My guess is that most (if not all) of them COULD have gotten it correct, but they just didn't do enough work to PROVE what the correct answer is.

The prompt tells us about two ways that Ellen could purchase a computer:
1) From a store - for $P + 6% tax
2) From a catalog - for a total price of $Q

We're asked if it will cost Ellen MORE to buy the computer from the store than from the catalog. In real simple terms, it's asking "Is 1.06(P) > Q?" This is a YES/NO question.

Fact 1: Q - P < 50

From this, we don't know if Q or P is bigger, but we can still TEST VALUES to prove the inconsistency....

IF...
Q = 50
P = 1
1.06(1) is NOT > 50. The answer to the question is NO.

IF....
Q = 50
P = 53
1.06(53) IS > 50. The answer to the question is YES.
Fact 1 is INSUFFICIENT.

Fact 2: Q = 1150

This tells us nothing about the value of P, so we cannot figure out the value of 1.06(P).
Fact 2 is INSUFFICIENT

Combined, we know....
Q - P < 50
Q = 1150

At this point, many Test Takers would assume that this was insufficient, without gathering ANY proof. It's always interesting when Quant questions include specific numbers - those numbers were CHOSEN for a reason. They are NOT by accident. So it's interesting that Q = 1150 EXACTLY. Maybe there's a reason....maybe there's a pattern here....

Substituting in the value of Q, we have...

1150 - P < 50
1100 < P

Now this provides a lower limit to what P can be, but we MUST factor in the 6% tax too....

At the 'low end', P = just over $1100. With a 6% tax, (.06)(1100) = $66, so 1.06(P), at the minimum = a little more than 1100 + 66 = $1166. Every other possible price for P is GREATER than this. By extension, EVERY possible value of 1.06(P) is greater than Q.
Combined, SUFFICIENT.

Final Answer:

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

For F.S 1, assume p=100,q=120. Thus, the total cost for purchasing from the local store : 100+6% = 106, and here 106<120.
Again, for p=1000,q=1001, the cost from local store = 1000+6% = 1060, and 1060>1001.Insufficient.

From F.S 2, we just know the value of q, no information about p. Insufficient.

Taking both together, we know that 1150-p<50 = p>1100. Thus, the minimum cost by purchasing at the local store, assuming p=1100 = 1100+6% = 1166 and here we clearly see that p>q. Sufficient.
_________________

Or one could rephrase as follows

Is 1.06p>q?

(1) q-p<50
50+p>q

Is 1.06p>50+p?

We don't know

(2) q = 1150

Not enough

(1) and (2)

Is 1.06p>1150?

Is p more than a little less than 1150?

50+p> 1150

So the price 'p' which is obviously positive is greater than 1150

Therefore we have an answer and its gonna be C

Hope its clear

J

guys..

for (1) q - p < 50, can we take q = 100 and p = 110 ? (where q - p = -10 )

________________________
Yes.
_________________

Attached is a visual that should help. For the final step, use estimation. 6 percent of 1000 is 60, so \((>1100) + (>60)\) is always \(> 1,150\).

Hi when you club option 1& 2, you get 1150-p<50. But concluding p>1100 is not correct because we still don't know whether (1150-p) is greater than zero or less than zero. Hence i propose my answer as E. Kindly correct me

Sent from my Lenovo P1ma40 using GMAT Club Forum mobile app

We have to find the difference between 1.06p and 1150.

So, even if you take p=1100, you will get 1.06p = 1166 which is greater than 1150.

Hence, 1.06p will always be greater than q.

Hence C.
_________________

For me it is more intuitive if you consider min/max from the differences

Posted from my mobile device

Posted from my mobile device

Posted from my mobile device

Hello Everyone,
I have a question regarding this post.
for (1) q - p < 50, can we take q = 100 and p = 110 ? (where q - p = -10 )

Hi dawnemily6,

Yes, the prompt never states that Q or P is larger than the other, so with Fact 1 you can certainly TEST a larger value for P.

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

guys.. :D

for (1) q - p < 50, can we take q = 100 and p = 110 ? (where q - p = -10 )

Hi havip,

To answer your immediate question: YES, with the information in Fact 1, the value of P could be greater than the value of Q. Knowing that, were you able to correctly answer the question?

GMAT assassins aren't born, they're made,
Rich

Stem: \(106P>Q?\)

I) \(Q<50+P \implies 106P>50+P \implies 21P>10? \implies Not \ Sufficient\)

II) \(Q=1150 \implies P>1110 \implies Not \ Sufficient\)

I) & II) \(21(1100)>10 \implies Sufficient\)
_________________

Video solution from Quant Reasoning starts at 9:58 here:

Store Price = 1.06p
Catalog Price = q

(1) Value of q and p is unknown. For example, if p=100 q=100, then 100-106=-6, which less than 50 and the answer is yes, but if q=130 and p=100, then 130-106=26, which is less than 50 and the answer is no. INSUFFICIENT.

(2) No information of P. INSUFFICIENT.

Using both information.
1150-p<50
p>1100
1.06p>1100*1.06
10.6p>1166
Sufficient
The Answer is C

PC1=p$+0.06p PC2=q$

Is PC1>PC2?

(1) q-p<50
Nothing about q and p
NOT SUFF

(2) q=1150
NOT SUFF

(1) and (2)
If q=1150 and p=1101
PC1=1167.06
so PC1>PC2
So, if 1101<p<1149
PC1>PC2
SUFF

Answer C

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________