mbsingh wrote:
VeritasPrepKarishma wrote:
Please specify exactly how you interpreted the question and solved it. Note that the average depends on the exact value of each element in the set. Just saying 50% are 4 or less would not be sufficient. You would need to know how many are 4, how many are 3, how many are 2 and how many are 1.
I read the question as -
At a hospital, babies are born every day for a certain number of days. If 6 or more babies were born for 20% of the total number of days, is the
average number of babies born less than 4?
1) On 75% of the days that less than 6 babies were born, the number of babies born each day was less than 4.
2) On 50% of the days that 4 or more babies were born, the number of babies born each day was 6 or more.
Say there are 100 days. 6 or more babies were born on 20 days. Note that the number of babies born on these 20 days could be any number greater than 6 such as 20 or 50 or 120 etc. The minimum number of babies on these 20 days would be 120. There is no limit to the maximum number.
1) On 75% of the days that less than 6 babies were born, the number of babies born each day was less than 4.
On 80 days, less than 6 babies were born. Of these, 75% is 60 days. On 60 days, less than 4 babies were born. So on 60 days, you have minimum 60 babies born and maximum 180 babies born.
On the leftover 20 days, 4 or 5 babies were born so 80 or 100 babies.
The minimum average is (120 + 60 + 80)/ 100 = 2.6
The maximum average could be anything.
Not sufficient.
2) On 50% of the days that 4 or more babies were born, the number of babies born each day was 6 or more.
The 20 days when 6 or more babies were born make up 50% of the days when 4 or more babies were born. So for 20 days, 4 or 5 babies were born i.e. 80 or 100 babies
For 60 days, 1/2/3 babies were born. So on 60 days, you have minimum 60 babies born and maximum 180 babies born.
The minimum average is (120 + 60 + 80)/ 100 = 2.6
The maximum average could be anything.
Not sufficient.
Note that both statements give you the same information. So if they are not sufficient independently, they are not sufficient together.
Answer of this modified question would be (E)