ISB Profile Evaluation - Tools for B-School Profile Evaluation

Hi all,
Request you to please evaluate my profile for admission at ISB Hyderabad.

I am a chemical engineer working at an E-SBR (JV of IOCL and TSRC) plant in the operations department. Job responsibilities include managing a shift of around 30 people responsible for production. Job responsibilities require a mix of technical and managerial skills.

High school- 86.8%(CBSE)
12th- 77.8%(CBSE)
B.E chemical engineering- 8.077 CGPA (80.77%) from DSSBUICET Panjab University (central university, selection through AIEEE)
Work ex-4 years experience at a chemical plant.
Gmat score- 680 (V34,Q48)

Extracurricular
1) Level 2 Diploma holder in German language
2) District topper in X CBSE board examinations
3) Head of Marketing team for college fest Cyanide 2011 Generated an amount of Rs 46K from sponsors
namely Kings XI Punjab and Nike.

Regards
Gaurang Seth
sethgaurang@gmail.com

Hello sethgaurang

For reasons mentioned here- ISB will look at your profile holistically and 'qualitatively'.
It will help better to understand your career progression, achievements and positive impact on the business more than just job responsibilities. That is what ISB will be interested in.
Leading people is a good sign, bring our stories where your contributions helped the business (not just technical contribution) such as saving man hours, cutting costs or increasing profitability.
Past Acads are ok, but GMAT is much lower than the ISB average. That means you will need to be stellar in other areas such as work ex- the reason why I emphasize on bringing out the 'quality' side of your work. I will strongly recommend if your can re-take the GMAT and get a 720+.
The knowledge of German is good, though other extracurricular do not come out as very strong (may depend on the overall story you plan to tell). A good extracurricular is where you have a long term and serious relationship along with a meaningful impact on your life (personal or professional) or the life of others.
Coming to the last and biggest piece of the admissions puzzle- Why MBA and Why ISB? What are your career goals and why is an MBA from ISB an absolute necessity to achieve these goals? Unfortunately this info is missing and will decide a lot.
ISB will evaluate your candidature on Acads+Quality of WorkEx+Diversity+Career Goals. You will need a spike in at least 3 out of these 4 factors to stand a fighting chance. Since there isn't a spike in acads currently, your will need to showcase stellar achievements in work, extracurricular and highlight compelling reasons to pursue and MBA.
How well you tie this in your written application will decide the final outcome.
Should you feel the need to discuss this further, let me know.

Best
Varun Sharma
+919137133507
Free Profile Review
MBAkarma.com
GMAT Score Predictor
info@mbakarma.com

Hi sethgaurang,

Over the past few years, we've seen more and more folks from an operations ground apply to ISB. With 4 years of work experience, the competition becomes even more fierce. A few thoughts on your profile:

- Managing a team of 30 is great and make sure to highlight contributions and learnings from your managerial experience

- A GMAT score of 680 will definitely pull you down. While a higher GMAT does not guarantee you admission, lower than class average (of about 710) can diminish your chances of getting through. There is still time before the R1 deadline and we recommend you definitely give GMAT another shot

- Extracurriculars can be huge differentiators and we think these is definitely an area of improvement. You would need something more current and more hands-on to show that you are a well-rounded personality.

- You haven't spoken about your goals and this is often the most important part of the application, esp for essay 2. Spend some time articulating how can ISB help you reach your goals?

Overall, a well-balanced application with an improved GMAT score can see you through.

Hi sethgaurang,

While you have a had a pretty decent academic career and valuable leadership experience at the professional level, your GMAT score falls at least thirty points under the ISB average. As a result, we strongly recommend a GMAT retake and you must aim for a score upwards of 720.

Having said that, the GMAT is only one component of the applications process and you will have to put forth a set of essays that not only speak about your career progression and achievements but also portray a set of career goals, wherein your short-term and long-term career goals are in sync with your existing experience.

If you are able to take care of the above-mentioned points, you will have a good chance of cracking ISB!

We would like to take this opportunity to offer you a detailed profile evaluation. Should you feel the need for the same, feel free to reach out.

All the best!
_________________

Hi sethgaurang, any chance you could re-appear in GMAT, to push that 680 by 20-30 points?

The thing is that 680 is definitely not a show-stopper, but it could help your cause if your current score goes up Gurang. Your work-experience certainly puts you in a diverse pool, but right now I don't get a glimpse on your post-MBA goals.

The goals need to be thought thru and articulated.
--
Regards,
Ashish.
_________________

Hi,

Thanks for all the support and knowledge on this thread.

My profile is as follows:
10th: 90%
12th: 85%
BE(Mechanical): First class with distinction (70%)

Work ex: Amazon(Compliance risk investigator and Trainer)
2 years

Business partner at a food startup handing marketing and operations(1 Year)

What should my GMAT score be?

Hi Shabari, with the limited information that you've given, would suggest you aim for 700+.

Obviously, the higher, the better, the lower, the bitter .
--
Regards,
ISBeacon
This year's ISB Essay Analysis
_________________

Hi ,
Please evaluate my below profile:

10th: 92.8%
12th: 84.16%
B.E (Information Science): 9.51/ 10 GPA (2nd Rank holder for the Class)
Work Experience: 4 years as Software QA Engineer
Gave GRE 2 years back and got : 300 ( Q: 158 V: 142)
Have participated in many NGO activities from corporate Citizenship

I know my GRE marks is way low. I’m confused should I retake GRE itself or prepare for GMAT and give a try for GMAT.

Can you please suggest me on what should I choose among GRE or gmat and how much I need in those exams for high admission chances.





Sent from my iPhone using GMAT Club Forum mobile app

Hello ShabariSS

I wish there was a simple answer to this, but there isn't.
ISB will look at your profile holistically on 6 admission factors (read here)
The info you have provided covers just your stats and 'quantitative' part of the profile.
ISB is more interested in the 'qualitative' side. Quality of Work Ex, Career Progression, Achievements, Diversity and Post MBA goals that are realistic and fit your profile.
With the current info best I can recommend is 720+. However remember the quality of your profile will decide whether a 650 is enough or even a 750 is too low.

Best
Varun Sharma
+919137133507
Free Profile Review
MBAkarma.com
GMAT Score Predictor
info@mbakarma.com

Hello BhargavaB

Both exams are accepted. Since you have already prepared for the GRE and are confident of taking this score up considerably, then take the GRE.
Or you could take a few GMAT mock tests (click here for one) and see if you find the GMAT easier/comfortable for your style. If yes, then go ahead with the GMAT.
But remember to put in equal effort on building your written application, as ultimately that is the deciding factor. No score is too high for an admission- you can read more here

Best
Varun Sharma
+919137133507
Free Profile Review
MBAkarma.com
GMAT Score Predictor
info@mbakarma.com

Hi ShabariSS,

Your post does not provide us enough details on your role, career progress, achievements, and post-MBA goals. Nonetheless, with the information that we do have, we would recommend that you aim for a score upwards of 720! The higher, the better.

All the best!
_________________

Hi BhargavaB,

Thanks for your query.

Both tests are equally accepted by ISB but we would imagine that considering you have already prepared for GRE and are more conversant with the structure of the test, the GRE would work better for you Nonetheless, you could always take a GMAT Mock to gauge your comfort level

Needless to say, whichever test you do decide to take, you will need to spare time to put forth a stellar set of essays as well, as ISB evaluates applications in a holistic manner.

Hope this helped!

All the best!
_________________

Hi everyone,

Can someone please review my profile.

Currently i'm working in an instrumentation company with 4 years of experience ( 1.5 years of international experience )
10th-79.84
12th-80.83
Grad(B.E)-8.91/10

what should be my target score for ISB?

Thanks in advance!

Hi BhargavaB,

Since you come from the IT background, please keep in mind that the competition is higher and you would want to pull out all the stops in your candidature to make a great impression.

Average GMAT scores are around 710 and GRE scores are around 324. A score of 300 is definitely on the lower side. Whether you take the GMAT or GRE, it is purely your choice. Since it has been 2 years since you have taken the GRE, you can try giving a mock test for GRE and GMAT each and then decide which one suits you more.

Remember to aim for at least class average, and the higher the better.

Feel free to reach out for personalized guidance and a detailed profile evaluation.

My friend too little information to advice a score.
ISB is not a school that will look at a laundry list of your stats (Grades, Years of Work Ex, GMAT) and grant you an admission.
A profile is much more than these bullet points (you begin your research here)
What is your nature of work, career progression, achievements and business impact?
What are your diversity factors?
What sort of extracurricular activities have you been involved in?
What are your career goals?
Answers to these make up your profile.
Depending on the strength of your profile, a minimum GMAT may be recommended.
With the current info I would suggest a 730+, but one would need to know more.

Do well.

Best
Varun Sharma
+919137133507
Free Profile Review
MBAkarma.com
GMAT Score Predictor
info@mbakarma.com

Thank you for taking the time out for evaluating my profile. I really appreciate it!

I plan on applying in a year or so! I would like to know what school I would be a good fit for.

Profile:
GMAT: 650 (Q48, V31) I think I could get 680 by the time that I apply
Black/Male/24 years (26 at matriculation)
EDUCATION: Bachelors in Computer Engineering minor Business administration GPA: 3.00/4.00
Patents Owned: 1

LOW GPA:
My 3.00 GPA was due to a serious car accident the summer before my sophomore year in which my best friend and I were T-boned by a semi-truck. I was forced to drink through a straw for 25 days due to my several injuries. I became depressed which resulted in my poor academic performance. Luckily, I was able to focus my time away from sports and realize my passion for business. I consider my GPA recovery to be one of my greatest accomplishments because I proved to myself that I have the grit to overcome adversity.

EXPERIENCE:
I started two startups in college. The first business I competed in several pitch competition for. I won $6000 at a pitch competition at citywide event, place top 3 in South Carolina a won $10,000 in prizes, and place top 40 out of 25,000 globally. For the second business I went from winning the best engineering senior design project to being accepted into a startup incubator (3% acceptance rate). I raised $130,000 at over $1,000,000 valuation through the incubator, investors, and kickstarter. I also built my team to 7 people and have presented to President Jimmy Carter along with Fortune 100 and business executives.

Also shortly after I graduated I was a leader for Georgia's largest startup and helped 500 businesses get started all in one day. I trained, certified and oversaw 20+ consultants for the event. This was all ran through a nonprofit.

Currently I am being contracted by one of arms forces (Army, Navy or Air Force) to lead their product intuitive for 2 major releasing soon. I basically the final say on what features are implemented and make sure the project is on track. I also have a machine learning project that I am developing on the side that I think has real potential.

I also trade stocks in my spare time. This is how I helped pay off my student loans. I have turned $13,000 in $35,000 with probably around 600 trades. I plan to save to $70k to pay for grad school. I am not sure if schools will even care that I can do this at all.

EXTRA CURRICULAR:
I mentor several people and help them with their startups. I have help people successfully raise capital and win pitch competitions.

I also taught a class to teach freshman how to adjust to college and mentored about 40 students over 2 years. This took about 15 hours a week.

LONG TERM GOAL:
Long term I would like start another company with someone I meet in business school and consult college students on startup as a way for me to give back. Then I would like to consult Fortune 500 companies for a few years while teaching 1-2 credit course on entrepreneurship at reputable college as a hobby. I really enjoy helping and teaching but I want to have a formal background on top of everything I have done on my own. I plan on starting a "gifted" high school in 15 or so years. Finally I would like to get into venture capital or at the very least be an angel investor.

I would like to apply to Emory, Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, Duke & Yale. I can get great LOR, anywhere from a previous associate dean of MBA program at one of those 5 schools to my co-founder and several other mentors. I don’t know how well I fair against competition at these schools. Is my profile even unique? Can you let me know my chances at each? What else should I do to make me look better for the future since I still have time. Also please recommend other schools if you think that I could be a better fit for.

Thanks in advance!!

Hi ShabariSS


Startup experience is always valued at ISB. Amazon is a good brand to have as well. We'd need more information to make a detailed profile evaluation but a few observations for you to hit the ground running:

- It definitely helps that you have good acads so far. ISB Class Average for GMAT is usually around 710, so that should be a good score to aim for, and of course, the higher the better.
- A key point in your application is going to be your goals and how what you have learned from your Amazon/Startup experience and how an MBA will help you reach your goals.
- We don't see extracurriculars mentioned in your profile, but please remember that these are going to be an essential component in demonstrating a well-rounded personality.

Feel free to reach out for a detailed and personalized review.

Startup experience is always valued at ISB. Amazon is a good brand to have as well. We'd need more information to make a detailed profile evaluation but a few observations for you to hit the ground running:

- It definitely helps that you have good acads so far. ISB Class Average for GMAT is usually around 710, so that should be a good score to aim for, and of course, the higher the better.
- A key point in your application is going to be your goals and how what you have learned from your Amazon/Startup experience and how an MBA will help you reach your goals.
- We don't see extracurriculars mentioned in your profile, but please remember that these are going to be an essential component in demonstrating a well-rounded personality.

Feel free to reach out for a detailed and personalized review.

Thank you.
I do not have any other extracurriculars except being the student council president during college, mentoring/training a batch of 7-10 people at work and some volunteering work.
this is out of topic but which online course would you recommend to study?

Hi ShabariSS,

Are you referring to taking up online courses for boosting extracurriculars? In that case, please remember that extracurriculars are essentially activities that you have done at work or beyond work in your regular life, that were NOT part of your job description. For instance, arranging sports day/events at work, playing a sport, having a blog or any other hobby that you diligently pursue and so on. From your profile, mentoring new trainees sounds like a good initiative if you have been doing it consistently, if it wasn't part of your job description and you were able to demonstrate an impact. Volunteering at an NGO is usually the most common extracurricular that applicants write about.

Online courses often add little value to our personalities, so they aren't really valued by the B-school. It doesn't matter what activity you choose. The important part is to be consistent at your extracurricular and be able to demonstrate some sort of an impact or end result.