There's so much good stuff in this one: we have parallelism, a classic issue between “like” and “such as”, and a funky little comparison issue. For more on parallelism and meaning, check out
this YouTube webinar; if you want more on that funky little comparison issue, then you might want to suffer through
this video instead.
Quote:
A. sources like tar sands, heavy oil, and perhaps even in shale than
The GMAT gave us a nice little gift here: “like” generally isn’t be used to introduce examples on the GMAT – or at the very least, “such as” is preferred over “like” in every official question that gives us the option. For that reason, you could eliminate (A). (Full disclosure: there is an official GMAT question that uses “like” to introduce examples in the correct answer choice. But all five answer choices include “like”, and none offer “such as” as an alternative. So it’s a non-issue in that particular question.)
For whatever it’s worth, there’s also a parallelism issue here: “…sources like
tar sands,
heavy oil,
and perhaps even in shale than…” Whoa, that doesn’t work: “tar sands” and “heavy oil” are nouns, but the parallelism trigger “and” is followed by “
in shale” – a prepositional phrase. So that would be enough to eliminate (A), also.
But wait, there’s more: check out that comparison. “… ten times
as much petroleum exists in [non-conventional sources]
than in conventional reservoirs…”
That’s wrong: we could say that “ten times
as much petroleum exists in [non-conventional sources]
as in conventional reservoirs…” We could also say that “ten times
more petroleum exists in [non-conventional sources]
than in conventional reservoirs…” But “ten times as much… than” is definitely wrong.
So that’s three glorious reasons to eliminate (A).
Quote:
B. sources like tar sands, heavy oil, and perhaps even in shale than are
(B) is exactly the same as (A), other than adding the word “are” at the end of the underlined portion – and that little difference doesn’t do anything to change the three reasons why (A) is wrong. So (B) is wrong for the same three reasons.
And in case you’re wondering about the word “are”: it does nothing productive for us here. The heart of the comparison is the idea that “ten times as much petroleum exists
in [non-conventional sources] as
in conventional reservoirs…” So there’s no good reason to stick the “are” in there: “ten times as much petroleum exists
in [non-conventional sources] as
are in conventional reservoirs…” It might be acceptable to repeat the word “exists” instead of “are”, but even that is unnecessary – and it’s just awkward and a waste of words to stick “are” into the sentence, when we’re really just comparing the phrase “in tar sands, heavy oil, and shale” with “in conventional reservoirs.”
But you could ignore that last paragraph, and have tons of reasons to ditch (B).
Quote:
C. such sources as tar sands, heavy oil, and perhaps even in shale as are
The “such as” is better, but there’s still a parallelism issue here: “…sources like
tar sands,
heavy oil,
and perhaps even in shale than…” Just like in (A), that doesn’t work: “tar sands” and “heavy oil” are nouns, but the parallelism trigger “and” is followed by “
in shale” – a prepositional phrase.
And the use of “are” in the middle of the comparison is still a mild problem, too. See my explanation in (B), above.
So (C) can be eliminated.
Let’s line (D) and (E) up side-by-side to make it easier to see the issue:
Quote:
D. such sources as tar sands, heavy oil, and perhaps even shale as
E. such sources as tar sands, heavy oil, and perhaps even shale than
Yup, this is exactly the same problem as we saw in (A) and (B): because the comparison begins with “ten times
as much”, we need to finish the phrase with “as”, not “than.” See the explanation for (A) if you need more detail on this.
So (E) is out, and (D) is our answer.
_________________
GMAT/GRE/EA tutors @
www.gmatninja.com (
hiring!) |
YouTube |
Articles |
IG Beginners' Guides:
RC |
CR |
SC |
Complete Resource Compilations:
RC |
CR |
SC YouTube LIVE webinars:
all videos by topic +
24-hour marathon for UkraineQuestion Explanation Collections:
RC |
CR |
SC