Same stuff - the software marks D as the right answer! I answered E, which is the best option IMO. The option E is not mentioned in the passage, since the only thing that is related to the topic is that "Even when demonstrator hens reacted with obvious disgust to a specific food". IMO this is far from option D, since doesn't mention the reaction to NEW food.

The passage is from GMATPrep exam pack.

The OA is D only and not E.

Can anyone please explain the reasoning ?

Thanks

1)
A. techniques used in certain experiments on social learning in birds
There is a lot of discussion of experiments, but notice, the results are discussed more than are the techniques.
B. reasons for the differences between social learning in birds and in mammals
Only that they "may be fundamentally different" is mentioned. There is no discussion of the reasons for any differences. This answer could trap someone who is just going with what sounds right. Mammals and birds are mentioned and reasons for differences in social learning among birds are mentioned. So as usual you have to be careful and really notice what is being said and what is not being said in order to get this question right.
C. question of how social learning manifests itself in birds
There is extensive discussion of this topic. Different kinds of birds and their particular types of social learning are discussed. In fact, the passage is mostly about a particular question, the question of whether birds can, like mammals, "can develop preferences for palatable food through social learning." While this answer choice does not say that exactly, it is the choice closest to what the passage is about.
D. basis for a widespread belief about a difference in behavior between birds and mammals
The basis, some experiments, for the belief that mammals and birds learn different things from each other about food is discussed, but much more is going on.
E. possible reasons why birds may or may not learn from each other in a particular
way. This is only briefly discussed in the part about chickens.
The correct answer is C.
2)
A. Only a small number of observer hens appeared to learn to avoid food that was
demonstrated by other hens to be noxious. - Incorrect. It is not shown that even a small number of observer hens appeared to learn to avoid food.
B. Observer hens ingested food preferentially only after numerous instances of
witnessing demonstrator hens preferentially ingest that type of food. - Incorrect. Nothing like this is indicated in the passage.
C. Observer hens appeared unable to recognize when demonstrator hens found a
particular food especially palatable. - Incorrect. Again, nothing like this is indicated. In fact, the passage does not indicate any difficulty in recognition by observer hens.
D. Demonstrator hens reacted adversely to ingesting certain novel foods. - Correct. Refer to the following lines. Even when demonstrator hens reacted with obvious disgust to a specific food, via vigorous head shaking and bill wiping
E. Demonstrator hens altered their behavior less obviously in response to noxious
foods than in response to highly palatable foods. - Incorrect. Quite the contrary. It is shown that demonstrator hens nade their body language very clear when given noxious food.
Answer:
3)It can be inferred…
"Sherwin’s research team speculated that ecological or social constraints during the evolution of this species might have resulted in there being little benefit from the social learning of unpalatability "
AND
"These results confirmed that avian species can develop preferences for palatable food through social learning"
Option (E) clearly describes the above two excerpts and is therefore correct.
_________________

Thanks & Regards,
Anaira Mitch

Hi Anaira,

I would just like to highlight that option E is specifically taking about alteration of behavior in response to noxious foods Vs. highly palatable foods, the reason you are giving is that their reaction was more obvious.

The only reason why E is not the answer is that no where in the passage, has the comparison of the *Degree of alteration in response to noxious vs. palatable* food been done.

I was troubled a lot by this question.

GMATNinjaTwo Could you help with Q1?

1. The primary purpose of the passage is to discuss the

(A) techniques used in certain experiments on social learning in birds
(B) reasons for the differences between social learning in birds and in mammals
(C) question of how social learning manifests itself in birds
(D) basis for a widespread belief about a difference in behavior between birds and mammals
(E) possible reasons why birds may or may not learn from each other in a particular way
_________________

"Be challenged at EVERY MOMENT."

“Strength doesn’t come from what you can do. It comes from overcoming the things you once thought you couldn’t.”

"Each stage of the journey is crucial to attaining new heights of knowledge."

Rules for posting in verbal forum | Please DO NOT post short answer in your post!

Advanced Search : https://gmatclub.com/forum/advanced-search/

E: Demonstrator hens altered their behavior less obviously in response to noxious foods than in response to highly palatable foods.

the above behavior is shown by observer hen and not the demonstrator hen hence E is wrong.

But Sherwin's recent experiments with domestic hens do not support the notion that avian social learning necessarily facilitates aversion to novel foods that are noxious or toxic.
Even when demonstrator hens reacted with obvious disgust to a specific food,
there was no evidence that observers subsequently avoided eating that food.

Demonstrator hens reacted adversely to ingesting certain novel foods. hence D is the answer

regardng the question#1: we are asked the primary purpose of the passage, and OA =C / but the passage talks about mammals as well

Time: 8:15
Result: 2 out of 3 incorrect (B, E, E)
Question:
I don't find the passage particularly hard to understand but the questions are confusing and challenging. Does anyone else feel the same way? What's the best way to tackle problems like this?

HI GMATNinja , mikemcgarry , egmat , sayantanc2k, RonPurewal , DmitryFarber , MagooshExpert (Carolyn), ccooley , GMATNinjaTwo , SarahPurewal , EMPOWERgmatVerbal




Why is A wrong? Is it not Social learning is introduced and how Avians are followed?





POE please




Can you Please explain why is C Wrong?
_________________

आत्मनॊ मोक्षार्थम् जगद्धिताय च

Resource: GMATPrep RCs With Solution

Thank you so much MagooshExpert (Carolyn)...

It really makes sense now
_________________

आत्मनॊ मोक्षार्थम् जगद्धिताय च

Resource: GMATPrep RCs With Solution