pikolo2510 wrote:
Hey
GMATNinjaCan you share your thoughts on this question?
Acc. to all the explanations above, the idiom used is "cite as X Y". But in the question the idiom is in the form "cite as Y X". I don't want to be too rigid over here but I'm a little confused with the convoluted form of this question.
I'm not sure that you're going to like my answer much,
pikolo2510!
So I think we're all accustomed to seeing the construction “cite x as y,” but in the correct answer you see the construction, “cite as y x,” which might sound a bit strange to you. Frankly, it does SOUND strange. But it's not wrong: it's perfectly logical to say that somebody "cites the concern... as an obstacle to passage" or to say that somebody "cites as an obstacle... the concern..." Either way, the meaning is fine.
Here’s the bigger takeaway:
relying primarily on your ear to eliminate wrong answer choices is supremely dangerous. So instead of agonizing over what the proper idiomatic construction is –
or painstakingly memorizing long lists of the 25,000 idioms in English - focus on finding concrete logic or grammar errors in four of the answer choices. If you can, the remaining option with the goofy idiom is your goofy correct answer.
Put another way, the key question isn't "why is the idiom in C correct?" It's "why are A, B, D, and E wrong?" (Hint: all four are illogical.)
I hope this helps a bit!
Is option (C) a run on sentence? Do we need a conjunction joining "concern"?