GMAT Club Forum
https://gmatclub.com:443/forum/

If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti
https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-denotes-one-of-the-four-arithmetic-operations-addition-subtracti-105472.html
Page 1 of 1

Author:  MrEasy [ 03 Feb 2010, 18:08 ]
Post subject:  If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

Author:  Bunuel [ 28 Nov 2010, 14:05 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?
(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

The key here is the bold part of the statements, which tells us that statements MUST be true for all integers.

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n --> # may denote both addition and subtraction (as n+0=n and n-0=n is true for all integers n), which gives two different values for 1 # 2. Not sufficient.

(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n --> # may denote only subtraction to be true for ALL integers (n-n=0 is true for all integers n), though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #. So 1 # 2 = 1 - 2 = -1. Sufficient.

Answer: B.

Hope it's clear.

Author:  gettinit [ 28 Nov 2010, 14:49 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Bunuel wrote:
If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?
(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

The key here is the bold part of the statements, which tells us that statements MUST be true for all integers.

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n --> # may denote both addition and subtraction (as n+0=n and n-0=n is true for all integers n), which gives two different values for 1 # 2. Not sufficient.

(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n --> # may denote only subtraction to be true for ALL integers (n-n=0 is true for all integers n), though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #. So 1 # 2 = 1 - 2 = -1. Sufficient.

Answer: B.

Hope it's clear.


Bunuel so on stmt 2 does this mean since the stmt says all integers N the rule has to apply to all zeros not just 0? Therefore only subtraction can be true? Thanks

Author:  Bunuel [ 28 Nov 2010, 14:55 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

gettinit wrote:
Bunuel wrote:
If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?
(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

The key here is the bold part of the statements, which tells us that statements MUST be true for all integers.

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n --> # may denote both addition and subtraction (as n+0=n and n-0=n is true for all integers n), which gives two different values for 1 # 2. Not sufficient.

(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n --> # may denote only subtraction to be true for ALL integers (n-n=0 is true for all integers n), though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #. So 1 # 2 = 1 - 2 = -1. Sufficient.

Answer: B.

Hope it's clear.


Bunuel so on stmt 2 does this mean since the stmt says all integers N the rule has to apply to all zeros not just 0? Therefore only subtraction can be true? Thanks


I'm not sure understoond your question.

Anyway, "n # n = 0 for all integers n", means that n # n = 0 must be true (for some operation denoted by #) no matter what integers you substitute for n.

Author:  MisterEko [ 28 Nov 2010, 15:04 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Pretty clear now that you explain it. Wonder why it is so troublesome for us to comprehend it?

Author:  petrifiedbutstanding [ 13 Aug 2011, 06:53 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Bunuel! It was the most obvious thing that we missed!

Thank you!!!

Author:  kpali [ 22 Jun 2013, 02:32 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

MisterEko wrote:
If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

Not sure how the answer is B?

If N is 0 (which is a possibility, isn't it?), then the operation can be either +,- or x, which would yield different results for the stated operation.

Appreciate the help, and sorry if this has been posted before, it was hard to search for the question since the operation sign is weird.


Question, we need not calculate 1#2, but just find out the operator for #=?

1) n # 0 = n for all integers n

This is valid for the operators +, - => Cant narrow to one =>Not Suff

(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

This is valid for - operator => Sufficient.

B

Author:  SD007 [ 29 Oct 2015, 15:01 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Bunuel wrote:
MrEasy wrote:
Though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #.

So the answer is B.

Hope it's clear.


Hi Bunnel,

Can you please elaborate why the answer should not be E ? In my opinion in the statement two if the value of n=0 then the sign could be any and if the value of n is not equalt to 0 then the sign is subtraction. So clearly we have two answers hence the statement should be insufficient.

Please correct me what am I missing ?

Thanks

Author:  ENGRTOMBA2018 [ 29 Oct 2015, 15:10 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

SD007 wrote:
Bunuel wrote:
MrEasy wrote:
Though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #.

So the answer is B.

Hope it's clear.


Hi Bunnel,

Can you please elaborate why the answer should not be E ? In my opinion in the statement two if the value of n=0 then the sign could be any and if the value of n is not equalt to 0 then the sign is subtraction. So clearly we have two answers hence the statement should be insufficient.

Please correct me what am I missing ?

Thanks


Let me try to answer. The question mentions that the "#" symbol should denote an operation satisfied for ALL integers and not just 1.

You are restricting the interpretation of statement 2 by only assuming that n=0 is the only value. This is not true. Whatever operation you choose, must be applicable for ALL integers.

Per statement 2, n#n=0 ---> only n-n = 0 is the applicable solution. n+n=2n , n*n=n^2, n/n=1. Thus the only case possible is the # = subtraction.

Hope this helps.

Author:  robu [ 17 Mar 2016, 03:30 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Bunuel wrote:
MrEasy wrote:
Guys I have a question, in the GMAT prep I came across this question (See attachment).

I wonder, does it not make a difference when someone assumes that n could be 0 as it is not explicitly stated in the question that it is not?


If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?
(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

The key here is the bold part of the statement, which tells us that statements MUST be true for all integers. I guess your concern is about the statement (2):

n # n = 0 --> means # can denote only subtraction to be true for ALL integers. Though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #.

So the answer is B.

Hope it's clear.


why the option D is not the answer. please explain. I think in stmt 1 the operation can be addition?

Author:  Bunuel [ 17 Mar 2016, 03:50 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

robu wrote:
Bunuel wrote:
MrEasy wrote:
Guys I have a question, in the GMAT prep I came across this question (See attachment).

I wonder, does it not make a difference when someone assumes that n could be 0 as it is not explicitly stated in the question that it is not?


If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?
(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n

The key here is the bold part of the statement, which tells us that statements MUST be true for all integers. I guess your concern is about the statement (2):

n # n = 0 --> means # can denote only subtraction to be true for ALL integers. Though if n=0 it can denote addition and multiplication as well but one value of n can not determine #.

So the answer is B.

Hope it's clear.


why the option D is not the answer. please explain. I think in stmt 1 the operation can be addition?


It can be addition as well as subtraction. So, 1 # 2 can be 1 + 2 = 3 as well as 1 - 2 = -1.

Author:  dabaobao [ 16 Sep 2019, 03:25 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

MrEasy wrote:
If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, what is the value of 1 # 2?

(1) n # 0 = n for all integers n
(2) n # n = 0 for all integers n


If +, 1+2 = 3
If - , 1 -2 = -1
If *, 1 * 2 = 2
If /, 1/2 = 1/2

1) # could be + or -. Not Sufficient
2) # has to be -. Sufficient.

ANSWER: B

Author:  bumpbot [ 19 Jul 2022, 19:40 ]
Post subject:  Re: If # denotes one of the four arithmetic operations addition, subtracti

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC - 8 hours
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/