Alanjackson wrote:
On the DS Course help page, the following link,
(
http://www.gmatclub.com/content/courses ... ive/ds.php) example 6 does not make sense to me. It says:
Example 6. Is the sum of six consecutive integers even?
1. The first integer is odd
2. The average of six integers is odd
Watch out for Yes/No data sufficiency questions; they are the hardest and the most misleading.
Example 6: The answer to this one is D. (1) Statement says that the sum of the integers is odd, which gives a NO answer to our question, but is SUFFICIENT to give an answer, therefore sufficient. (2) Says that the sum is odd, which is sufficient to give a Yes answer. In both cases it was sufficient to answer the question, except in the first case, the answer was NO and in the other, it was YES. Make sure you don't confuse No with insufficient because they are not related here.
(1) appears to be sufficient; however, I can't find an example of (2 -The average of six integers is odd) even existing. Thoughts? Also do people know if in general with DS questions if (1) and (2) can both have distinct answers and still be sufficient? Thanks
Let me start this one off.
My answer is A. However,
Just from the question stem, by definition we know that the sum of 6 consecutive integers will always be odd
So I am not sure how to use the 2 statements since the question stem itself tells us the sum will never be Even
St: 1
First integer is Odd. So,
O+E+O+E+O+E --->O+E is always Odd so the sum is Always Odd.
So I guess it is suff.
We can also try pluggin in value -2, -1, 0, 1, 2, 3 etc.
St.2
Average of 6 consecutive integers is Odd.
We know,
Sum/6 = Odd----> which means Sum = 6*Odd---> Even,
However,
The sum can never be Even. Try plugging in values.
Also the average will never be a integer will be a fraction which when rounded up will be either Odd or Even
For some reason I believe that there is something wrong with the question at least with St.2
B/c we determine from the stem itself that the sum will always be Odd.
So Insuff.