Five amateur runners are competing with one another during a series of

Question

Five amateur runners are competing with one another during a series of 20 designated 10 km training runs. A prize of $50 will be awarded to the runner with the overall fastest time (the fastest among all of the times in all of the runs), and a prize of $30 to the runner with the individual time that shows the greatest improvement (decrease in time) from that runner's time for the first of the designated runs. The times are shown in the table in minutes and seconds. The times for the first run are shown in boldface.

Run #	Runner A	Runner B	Runner C	Runner D	Runner E
1	‘41:53	‘40:18	‘41:26	‘41:33	‘41:25
2	‘40:08	‘41:49	‘41:19	‘40:46	‘42:02
3	‘44:36	‘42:37	‘39:58	‘40:56	‘41:23
4	‘42:21	‘40:54	‘39:54	‘40:51	‘40:47
5	‘40:47	‘39:10	‘40:39	‘42:46	‘40:51
6	‘41:03	‘39:42	‘40:26	‘41:02	‘39:42
7	‘40:51	‘41:03	‘40:46	‘40:48	‘40:06
8	‘39:58	‘40:52	‘39:12	‘40:19	‘40:28
9	‘43:16	‘40:55	‘39:54	‘40:11	‘40:29
10	‘41:40	‘39:17	‘38:57	‘40:31	‘39:18
11	‘39:42	‘39:31	‘38:31	‘39:45	‘39:52
12	‘40:29	‘39:09	‘38:30	‘40:21	‘40:39
13	‘39:53	‘38:42	‘39:45	‘38:53	‘39:26
14	‘39:38	‘40:39	‘37:29	‘40:09	‘38:43
15	‘41:37	‘38:04	‘38:13	‘39:47	‘39:35
16	‘40:29	‘39:28	‘38:31	‘39:55	‘39:02
17	‘39:04	‘40:01	‘37:52	‘39:02	‘39:56
18	‘39:22	‘38:19	‘39:11	‘38:50	‘38:52
19	‘42:18	‘39:45	‘40:32	‘38:35	‘38:11
20	‘39:01	‘38:02	‘38:24	‘37:56	‘38:28

For each of the following statements, select Yes if the statement is accurate, based on the information provided. Otherwise, select No.

Show Spoiler

Attachment:

GMAT-Club-Forum-s2zm6xpz.png [ 36.16 KiB | Viewed 3276 times ]

Attachment:

GMAT-Club-Forum-bmnkddu2.png [ 99.86 KiB | Viewed 3272 times ]

Yes	No
		Runner D will be awarded the $50 prize.
		Runner A will be awarded the $30 prize.
		Both prizes will be awarded to the same Individual

Submit Answer

Start the Timer above, select the radio buttons, and click "Submit" to add this question to your Error log.

Show Answer

Official Answer

Runner D will be awarded the $50 prize.: No Runner A will be awarded the $30 prize.: No Both prizes will be awarded to the same Individual: Yes

Greg1234 · Answer

1. 50$ prize is awarded to the person with the fastest time.
Runner D's fastest time is 37:56, while Runner C's fastest time is 37:29. So the answer is no.

2. Runner A's time difference between his fastest and his first run is 41:53 - 39:01 = 2:52, while Runner C's time difference between first run and fastest run is 41:26 - 37:29 = 3:57. So the answer is No.

3. Runner C has fastest time, we must check if his improvement is also the best. From the previous question we can see that it is not A. B's beginning time is faster and his fastest time is slower --> less of a difference. D has a 5 second slower first running time but his fastest time is 27 seconds is also slower so the difference is smaller. E has a 1 second faster starting run but none of his runs break the 37 minute mark so his improvement will also be smaller. The answer is Yes.

Bunuel · Answer

Formatted the question and unlocked the topic.  Fish181  could you please check whether the OAs put are correct?

Fish181 · Answer

Hi Bunuel, can confirm. https://gmatclub.com/forum/download/file.php?id=82114 GMAT-Club-Forum-6omkx90e.png

Bunuel · Answer

Great! Thank you very much! GMAT-Club-Forum-cfnrd34u.png

Shrey1 · Answer

Hi  Bunuel

Official answer is the same.

I am unable to understand how is the answer "Yes" for statement 3 ? Can you please help me understand this.

Yes2GMAT · Answer

Bunuel  Isn't C the fastest and D the best in terms of improvement from Race 1 to Race 21? So, how are both prizes awarded to the same individual?

pinehurst · Answer

1) No.

Filter on each runner A through E and look for the lowest time. Runner C is the fastest at 37:29. Runner D will NOT be awarded the $50 prize for fastest overall time.

2) No.

Filter on each runner A through E and subtract their Run #1 from their fastest time.
- A: 41:52 to 39:01 ---> 2:52 improvement.
- B: 40:18 to 38:02 ---> 2:16 improvement.
- C: 41:26 to 37:29 ---> 3:57 improvement.
- D: 41:33 to 37:56 ---> 3:37 improvement.
- E: 41:25 to 38:11 ---> 3:14 improvement.

Runner A will NOT be awarded the $30 prize for greatest improvement. Runner C has the greatest improvement at 3:57.

3) Yes.

Based on 1 & 2 above, both prizes will be awarded to Runner C.

Dbrunik · Answer

In retrospect this is not a hard question

MartyMurray · Answer

Five amateur runners are competing with one another during a series of 20 designated 10 km training runs. A prize of $50 will be awarded to the runner with the overall fastest time (the fastest among all of the times in all of the runs), and a prize of $30 to the runner with the individual time that shows the greatest improvement (decrease in time) from that runner's time for the first of the designated runs. The times are shown in the table in minutes and seconds. The times for the first run are shown in boldface.

Run #  
  Runner A  
  Runner B  
  Runner C  
  Runner D  
  Runner E  
 
   1  
   ‘41:53   
   ‘40:18   
   ‘41:26   
   ‘41:33   
   ‘41:25   
 
   2  
  ‘40:08  
  ‘41:49  
  ‘41:19  
  ‘40:46  
  ‘42:02  
 
   3  
  ‘44:36  
  ‘42:37  
  ‘39:58  
  ‘40:56  
  ‘41:23  
 
   4  
  ‘42:21  
  ‘40:54  
  ‘39:54  
  ‘40:51  
  ‘40:47  
 
   5  
  ‘40:47  
  ‘39:10  
  ‘40:39  
  ‘42:46  
  ‘40:51  
 
   6  
  ‘41:03  
  ‘39:42  
  ‘40:26  
  ‘41:02  
  ‘39:42  
 
   7  
  ‘40:51  
  ‘41:03  
  ‘40:46  
  ‘40:48  
  ‘40:06  
 
   8  
  ‘39:58  
  ‘40:52  
  ‘39:12  
  ‘40:19  
  ‘40:28  
 
   9  
  ‘43:16  
  ‘40:55  
  ‘39:54  
  ‘40:11  
  ‘40:29  
 
   10  
  ‘41:40  
  ‘39:17  
  ‘38:57  
  ‘40:31  
  ‘39:18  
 
   11  
  ‘39:42  
  ‘39:31  
  ‘38:31  
  ‘39:45  
  ‘39:52  
 
   12  
  ‘40:29  
  ‘39:09  
  ‘38:30  
  ‘40:21  
  ‘40:39  
 
   13  
  ‘39:53  
  ‘38:42  
  ‘39:45  
  ‘38:53  
  ‘39:26  
 
   14  
  ‘39:38  
  ‘40:39  
  ‘37:29  
  ‘40:09  
  ‘38:43  
 
   15  
  ‘41:37  
  ‘38:04  
  ‘38:13  
  ‘39:47  
  ‘39:35  
 
   16  
  ‘40:29  
  ‘39:28  
  ‘38:31  
  ‘39:55  
  ‘39:02  
 
   17  
  ‘39:04  
  ‘40:01  
  ‘37:52  
  ‘39:02  
  ‘39:56  
 
   18  
  ‘39:22  
  ‘38:19  
  ‘39:11  
  ‘38:50  
  ‘38:52  
 
   19  
  ‘42:18  
  ‘39:45  
  ‘40:32  
  ‘38:35  
  ‘38:11  
 
   20  
  ‘39:01  
  ‘38:02  
  ‘38:24  
  ‘37:56  
  ‘38:28

For each of the following statements, select  Yes  if the statement is accurate, based on the information provided. Otherwise, select  No .

Answering this question isn't particularly complicated. Basically, we just have to find a fastest time and find the biggest difference between the runners' first times and fastest times.

At the same time, getting this question correct can be a little tough because, when we sort the table, we can get the impression that we've found the value we need when actually we haven't.

So, one key move we need to make to get this question correct is to sort on each runner individually when we're looking for the runners' fastest times. If we fail to do that, we could get the impression that we're using a runner's fastest time when we're actually using another time.

Runner D will be awarded the $50 prize.

This statement is fairly straightforward to handle. The $50 prize will be awarded to the runner with " the overall fastest time (the fastest among all of the times in all of the runs)."  So, we just have to find the single fastest time in the table and see whether that time belongs to Runner D.

To do so, we sort each runner's column individually from lowest to highest. Sorted, each column shows a runner's fastest time at the top since the lowest number is the runner's fastest time.

Here's what we find at the top of the runners' sorted columns:

Runner A: '39:01

Runner B: ‘38:02

Runner C: ‘37:29

Runner D: ‘37:56

Runner E: ‘38:11

We see that the lowest value of the five is Runner C's fastest time.

So, Runner C, rather than Runner D, will get the $50 prize.

Select  No .

Runner A will be awarded the $30 prize.

To determine whether this statement is true, we'll compare each runner's first time with that runner's fastest time by sorting on Run # to bring up the runner's first time and then sorting on the individual runner to bring up the runner's fastest time.

Checking this statement takes a little more work, but once again, the key to getting this one right is being careful to sort the columns individually to compare each runner's first time with that runner's fastest time.

Also, we don't have to calculate exact differences between first times and fastest times. We can eliminate some runners quickly by estimating roughly and then be more exact if we have to with any that are close.

Finally, if we've read all the statements, we can see that, in checking this statement, we can also check the third statement since, to check the third statement, we have to determine which individual will get the $30 prize.

Here's what we get for the difference between the first and fastest time for each runner:

Runner A: ‘41:53 - '39:01 ≈ 42 - 39 ≈ 3

Runner B: ‘40:18 - ‘38:02 ≈ 2.25

Runner C: ‘41:26 - ‘37:29 ≈ 41.5 - 37.5 ≈ 4

Runner D: ‘41:33 - ‘37:56 ≈ 41.5 - 38 ≈ 3.5

Runner E: ‘41:25 - ‘38:11 ≈ 41.5 - 38.25 ≈ 3.25

We see the Runner C has the biggest difference, and we could have stopped checking at Runner C for this statement, but we needed to check Runner D and Runner E to check the next statement. So, if we've already read the next statement, we can get two statements done together by checking all the runners at once.

In any case, we see that Runner C rather than Runner A improved the most.

Select  No .

Both prizes will be awarded to the same individual.

In checking the above two statements, we've found that Runner C had the fastest time and improved the most.

If we hadn't calculated improvements for Runner D and Runner E when we checked the previous statement, we could have done it now to confirm that Runner C improved the most.

In any case, it's true that both prizes will be awarded to the same individual, Runner C.

Select  Yes .

Answer:   No ,  No ,  Yes

KumarRishav · Answer

In question to win $50, one should be  the fastest among all of the times in all of the runs. There has been time when C is not the fastest. Not in all runs, C is fastest. Then how statement 3 is Yes?

MadhuB · Answer

"A prize of $50 will be awarded to the runner with the overall fastest time (the fastest among all of the times in all of the runs)" -> I thought that 50$ will be given to the runner who is fastest among all the runs => meaning he/she is the winner in each run.  Bunuel   MartyMurray  how can I improve on this comprehension gap.. Is there something I missed?

Five amateur runners are competing with one another during a series of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Graphs and Tables (G&T) Questions

Five amateur runners are competing with one another during a series of

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards