imhimanshu
Which of the following best completes the passage below.
When purchasing a new automobile, consumers are generally wary of car salespeople, a group that bears a reputation for dishonesty. To combat this problem, the CEO of Hoffpeck motors is running an advertising campaign on television and radio in which he personally guarantees that he has certified each of his salespeople as 100% honest. This strategy may fail to achieve its desired results, however, because.......
A. Consumers pay less attention to television and radio advertising campaigns than they did before the widespread use of the internet
B. Consumers favor compact cars over SUV's and HOffpeck motors has failed to align its vehicle offerings with this changing market.
C. Consumers are likely to view the CEO of Hoffpeck motors as dishonest, himself, in light of his presence in a campaign to sell cars
D. Consumers view prominent business people as more trustworthy than salespeople
E. Consumers rank affordability and style ahead of showroom experience as the primary factors in their decisions to purchase new cars.
My Take-
Strategy is - Running a campaign on television and radio
Expected result- To overcome from the image of dishonest salespeople
Question type - Weaken
So, we need to find a premise(alternative explanation) for the question-
Why running a campaign on television and radio will not help in overcoming the image of dishonest people.
Explanation says- A is Out of Scope. Isn't A suggests that it may not be a viable strategy to promote the plan on Radio as people no longer pay attention towards radio advertisements because of internet. So, plan is likely to be failed. Also, Choice A does present new information.
Also, I found the language of C to be strong and Out of scope(phrase - in light of his presence in a campaign to sell cars)
Can someone explain Why A is wrong.
Lets break down the argument -
1. Car salespeople have a reputation for being dishonest and customers are aware of this.
2. A CEO of a car company wants to change this perception/tackle this problem, at-least for his own company.
3. For doing that, he is running certain advertisement campaigns in which he personally guarantees that all his salespeople are 100% honest.
Conclusion - This strategy may fail to achieve its desired result.
Lets look at the options keeping only this in mind and NOTHING ELSE. What could be the reason that this strategy won't achieve the desired result?
A - Consumers pay less attention to television and radio advertising campaigns than they did before the widespread use of the internet - This option compares the effectiveness of television and radio advertising campaigns now vs before the popularity of internet. How does that help us? - Do we know for certain that CEO's plan won't work? - We don't. Even if the effectiveness has reduced some people are still looking at these advertisements and may end up believing the CEO.
B - Consumers favor compact cars over SUV's and HOffpeck motors has failed to align its vehicle offerings with this changing market - This options says that consumers prefer SUVs and Hoffpeck's offering of cars may not appeal to people. How does this help us? - Does this option say anything at all about the new advertisement campaigns around the honesty/dishonesty? - No. Irrelevant.
C - Consumers are likely to view the CEO of Hoffpeck motors as dishonest, himself, in light of his presence in a campaign to sell cars - This option says that consumers will also assume that the CEO is dishonest, due to this new campaign. This gives us a very solid reason as to why the campaign won't work. Lets keep C and move on.
D - Consumers view prominent business people as more trustworthy than salespeople - This would mean that the campaign would be effective and its the opposite of what we want.
E - Consumers rank affordability and style ahead of showroom experience as the primary factors in their decisions to purchase new cars. How does this help us? - Does this option say anything at all about the new advertisement campaigns around the honesty/dishonesty? - No. Irrelevant.