It is generally believed that while in some cases government should in

Question

It is generally believed that while in some cases
government should intervene to protect people from
risk—by imposing air safety standards, for example—
in other cases, such as mountain climbing, the onus
  (5)   should be on the individual to protect himself or
herself. In the eyes of the public at large, the demarcation
between the two kinds of cases has mainly to do with
whether the risk in question is incurred voluntarily.
This distinction between voluntary and involuntary
  (10)   risk may in fact be the chief difference between lay
and expert judgments about risk. Policy experts tend
to focus on aggregate lives at stake; laypeople care a
great deal whether a risk is undertaken voluntarily.
However, judgments about whether a risk is
  (15)   “involuntary” often stem from confusion and selective
attention, and the real reason for such judgments
frequently lies in an antecedent judgment of some
other kind. They are thus of little utility in guiding
policy decisions.

(20)   First, it is not easy to determine when a risk is
voluntarily incurred. Although voluntariness may be
entirely absent in the case of an unforeseeable
collision with an asteroid, with most environmental,
occupational, and other social risks, it is not an all-or
  (25)   nothing matter, but rather one of degree. Risks
incurred by airline passengers are typically thought to be
involuntary, since passengers have no control over
whether a plane is going to crash. But they can choose
airlines on the basis of safety records or choose not to
  (30)   fly. In characterizing the risks as involuntary, people
focus on a small part of a complex interaction, not the
decision to fly, but the accident when it occurs.

Second, people often characterize risks as
“voluntary” when they do not approve of the purpose
  (35)   for which people run the risks. It is unlikely that
people would want to pour enormous taxpayer
resources into lowering the risks associated with
skydiving, even if the ratio of dollars spent to lives
saved were quite good. By contrast, people would
  (40)   probably not object to spending enormous resources
on improving the safety of firefighters, even though
the decision to become a firefighter is voluntary. In
short, there is no special magic in notions like
“voluntary” and “involuntary.” Therefore, regulatory
  (45)   policy should be guided by a better understanding of
the factors that underlie judgments about voluntariness.

In general, the government should attempt to save
as many lives as it can, subject to the limited public
and private resources devoted to risk reduction.
  (50)   Departures from this principle should be justified not
by invoking the allegedly voluntary or involuntary
nature of a particular risk, but rather by identifying
the more specific considerations for which notions of
voluntariness serve as proxies.    1 
 1. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

(A) In general, whether people characterize a risk as voluntary or involuntary depends on whether they approve of the purpose for which the risk is taken.
(B) Decisions about government intervention to protect people from risks should be based primarily on how many lives can be saved rather than on whether the risks are considered voluntary.
(C) Though laypeople may object, experts should be the ones to determine whether the risk incurred in a particular action is voluntary or involuntary.
(D) Public-policy decisions related to the protection of society against risk are difficult to make because of the difficulty of distinguishing risks incurred voluntarily from those incurred involuntarily.
(E) People who make judgments about the voluntary or involuntary character of a risk are usually unaware of the complicated motivations that lead people to take risks.

2 
 2. The passage indicates that which one of the following is usually a significant factor in laypeople’s willingness to support public funding for specific risk reduction measures?

(A) an expectation about the ratio of dollars spent to lives saved
(B) deference to expert judgments concerning whether the government should intervene
(C) a belief as to whether the risk is incurred voluntarily or involuntarily
(D) a judgment as to whether the risk puts a great number of lives at stake
(E) a consideration of the total resources available for risk reduction.

3 
 3. According to the passage, which one of the following do laypeople generally consider to involve risk that is not freely assumed?

(A) traveling in outer space
(B) participating in skydiving
(C) serving as a firefighter
(D) traveling in airplanes
(E) climbing mountains

4 
 4. It can be inferred from the passage that the author would be most likely to agree with which one of the following stateme nts?

(A) People should generally not be protected against the risks incurred through activities, such as skydiving, that are dangerous and serve no socially useful purpose.
(B) The fact that plane crash victims chose to fly would usually be deemed by policy experts to be largely irrelevant to decisions about the government’s role in regulating air safety.
(C) Both the probability of occurrence and the probability of resulting death or injury are higher for plane crashes than for any other kind of risk incurred by airline passengers.
(D) For public-policy purposes, a risk should be deemed voluntarily incurred if people are not subject to that risk unless they make a particular choice.
(E) The main category of risk that is usually incurred completely involuntarily is the risk of natural disaster.

5 
 5. The author’s use of the phrase “no special magic” (line 43) is most likely meant primarily to convey that notions like “voluntary” and “involuntary”

(A) do not exhaustively characterize the risks that people commonly face
(B) have been used to intentionally conceal the factors motivating government efforts to protect people from risks
(C) have no meaning beyond their literal, dictionary definitions
(D) are mistakenly believed to be characteristics that inform people’s understanding of the consequences of risk
(E) provide a flawed mechanism for making public policy decisions relating to risk reduction

6 
 6. The passage most strongly supports the inference that the author believes which one of the following?

(A) Whenever an activity involves the risk of loss of human life, the government should intervene to reduce the degree of risk incurred.
(B) Some environmental risks are voluntary to a greater degree than others are.
(C) Policy experts are more likely than laypeople to form an accurate judgment about the voluntariness or involuntariness of an activity.
(D) The government should increase the quantity of resources devoted to protecting people from risk.
(E) Government policies intended to reduce risk are not justified unless they comport with most people’s beliefs

7 
 7. Which one of the following most accurately describes the author’s attitude in the passage?

(A) chagrin at the rampant misunderstanding of the relative risks associated with various activities
(B) concern that policy guided mainly by laypeople’s emphasis on the voluntariness of risk would lead to excessive government regulation
(C) skepticism about the reliability of laypeople’s intuitions as a general guide to deciding government risk-management policy
(D) conviction that the sole criterion that can justify government intervention to reduce risk is the saving of human lives
(E) eagerness to persuade the reader that policy experts’ analysis of risk is distorted by subtle biases

RC Butler 2023  -  Practice Two RC Passages Everyday.   
Passage # 06 Date: 03-Feb-2023
 This question is a part of RC Butler 2023 .  Click here for Details

Source:   LSAT Official PrepTest 70   
 Difficulty Level:   700

vivek920368 · Answer

Can someone help me with the explanation of Q# 6 & 7?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

6. The passage most strongly supports the inference that the author believes which one of the following?

Explanation

The credited response will be the statement that is best supported by evidence within the passage text.

A. No.  This answer choice is too strong. The author advocates policies based on the number of lives saved, but he does not argue that there should be intervention in all instances of the risk of loss of human life.

B.  Yes.   In the second paragraph, the author states that with most environmental risks, “it is not an all-or-nothing matter, but one of degree.”

C. No.  The author argues against voluntariness as a standard for policy making.

D. No.  The author acknowledges the limited resources devoted to risk reduction and does not argue that they should be increased.

E. No.  The author states in the first paragraph that most people make judgments about risk based on the voluntariness of an activity, but the author argues against voluntariness as a standard.

Answer: B

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

7. Which one of the following most accurately describes the author’s attitude in the passage?

Explanation

Use your Bottom Line of the passage to help you to evaluate the choices. The credited response will be compatible with the author’s criticism of voluntariness as a standard for risk mitigation policy.

A. No.  This answer choice is too strong. While the author disagrees with the use of voluntariness, he does not make a claim about whether people misunderstand the amount of risk in an activity.

B. No.  While the author disagrees with the use of voluntariness as a standard, he does not make a claim that it will lead to excessive regulation.

C.  Yes.   While the author disagrees with the use of voluntariness as a standard, he does not make a claim that it will lead to excessive regulation.

D. No.  This answer choice is too strong. The author allows for exceptions from the principle that the number of lives saved should dictate policy and advocates identifying the more specific considerations at play in those exceptional circumstances.

E. No.  The author argues against the method of laypeople, not of policy experts.

Answer: C

Aditya89797 · Answer

Isn't this passage level is more tougher than CAT level ?
want to know

SejalT · Answer

Can someone explain why the option C is correct in answer 7?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation to question #7 https://gmatclub.com/forum/it-is-genera ... l#p3188311 Cheers

ishita0101 · Answer

Can someone help me with an explanation of Q4?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

4. It can be inferred from the passage that the author would be most likely to agree with which one of the following statements?

Difficulty Level:   700

Explanation

The credited response will be the statement that is best supported by evidence within the passage text.

A. No.  The author’s standard for risk-mitigation rests on the number of lives saved rather than on the level of danger or social usefulness of an activity.

B.  Yes.   The author argues against using voluntariness as a standard.

C. No.  This is not discussed in the passage.

D. No.  The author argues against using voluntariness as a standard.

E. No.  The author does not claim that any specific risk is voluntary or involuntary and argues against using voluntariness as a standard.

Answer: B

pratyush3284 · Answer

Can anyone explain Que 3?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

3. According to the passage, which one of the following do laypeople generally consider to involve risk that is not freely assumed?

Difficulty Level:   650-700

Explanation

To answer this question, you need to find where in the passage the author discusses laypeople and involuntary risk. The credited response will be explicitly supported by the passage text.

A. No.  This is not mentioned in the passage.

B. No.  This is mentioned as an example of a  “voluntary”  risk that people would not support.

C. No.  This is mentioned as an example of a  “voluntary”  risk that people would likely be willing to spend resources mitigating.

D.  Yes.   This is explicitly supported by  lines 25–28.

E. No.  This is mentioned as an example of a risk that should be assumed by the individual.

Answer: D

Roop14S · Answer

Hello, can someone post the official answer explanations for this RC?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

This passage came with 7 questions; among them, questions #3, 4, 6, and 7 are already explained. Let me know the question number you want to get explained.

Roop14S · Answer

I was a bit confused on the #5 question, can you please post the solution for that?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

5. The author’s use of the phrase “no special magic” (line 43) is most likely meant primarily to convey that notions like “voluntary” and “involuntary”

Difficulty Level:   650-700

Explanation

The author uses the phrase  “no special magic”  at the end of the fourth paragraph to introduce his conclusion that voluntariness should not be the standard by which regulatory policy is guided because of the flaws both in determining voluntariness and in the kinds of risks that should be mitigated.

A. No.  The author disagrees with the terms both because they are ambiguous and because they do not provide a good guide.

B. No.  This answer choice is too strong. The author does not claim any intentional concealment.

C. No.  The author disagrees with the terms because they are too ambiguous.

D. No.  The author does not relate the terms to the consequences of risk; rather they are discussed as types of risk.

E.  Yes.   This captures the author’s discussion at the end of the fourth paragraph.

Answer: E

Raman109 · Answer

3. According to the passage, which one of the following do laypeople generally consider to involve risk that is not freely assumed?
(C) serving as a firefighter - this is considered voluntary in the passage. 
(D) traveling in airplanes - Yes

Nikkz99 · Answer

But as per the question  choice A which is "too strong" should be the correct option, right?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

No! Option (B) is correct; Option (A) is incorrect.

Dreamer780 · Answer

Hi  Sajjad1994 , possible to provide explanation for question 1?
Thank you!

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

1. Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

Explanation

Use your Bottom Line of the passage to help you to evaluate the choices. The correct answer will discuss Katherine Dunham’s contributions to modern dance.

A. No.  The passage focuses on Dunham’s contributions to dance rather than to anthropology.

B. No.  This answer choice is too narrow. While true, this answer choice omits the necessary discussion of Dunham’s larger contributions.

C. No.  The passage does not discuss political concerns.

D. No.  This answer choice is too narrow. While Dunham’s research centered on the origins of Caribbean dance forms in African culture, that is only one part of the passage.

E.  Yes.   This answer is an accurate paraphrase of the Bottom Line.

Answer: E

It is generally believed that while in some cases government should in

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

It is generally believed that while in some cases government should in

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards