Machiavellianism, rooted in the political philosophy of

Question

Machiavellianism, rooted in the political philosophy of Niccolò Machiavelli, is often associated with realism in governance. Scholars suggest that Machiavelli’s ideas offer a distinct framework for state building aimed at the maintenance of governments. He departs from traditional doctrines, advocating for an original approach to leadership. According to Machiavelli, while the nobility are difficult to appease, common people are more easily won over. Regardless of how a government is founded, gaining the favor of the populace is essential.

In times of crisis, the support of the people becomes critical for a ruler’s survival. Though Machiavelli cautions against overestimating the loyalty of the masses, a well-prepared leader is less likely to face betrayal. A wise ruler ensures that citizens are dependent on him, fostering loyalty through reliance on his authority. Machiavelli argues that the general populace, being distant from power, poses less threat to a ruler than the nobility.

By securing the allegiance of the masses, a ruler can neutralize the influence of the elites. He further advises leaders to convince the common people that the nobility or middle class is the source of their discontent. This strategy diverts dissatisfaction away from the ruler, allowing him to maintain control. Ultimately, Machiavelli’s framework emphasizes the importance of manipulating public perception and leveraging social hierarchies to secure a ruler’s power.   1

Q1. According to the passage, which of the following statements best describes Machiavelli’s perspective on the relationship between a ruler and the common people?

A. A ruler should avoid relying heavily on the common people because their loyalty can easily shift in times of crisis.
B. The support of the common people is less important than maintaining control over the nobility.
C. A ruler can reduce the influence of the nobility by securing the loyalty of the common people.
D. Common people, due to their distance from power, are less likely to be a threat but are more difficult to manipulate.
E. The middle class is the primary source of a ruler’s power and stability.

2 
 Q2. Which of the following best describes the organization of the passage?

A. The passage introduces Machiavelli’s political philosophy and then discusses its practical application for rulers.
B. The passage presents Machiavelli’s views on power, details his strategy for managing different social classes, and concludes with a discussion on maintaining control.
C. The passage begins by explaining Machiavelli’s philosophy, transitions into analyzing the common people’s role, and ends with a critique of the nobility.
D. The passage outlines Machiavelli’s ideas on leadership, explores the challenges of ruling, and concludes with advice on handling power struggles.
E. The passage starts with Machiavelli’s political theories, contrasts them with traditional views, and finishes by advising rulers on manipulating public perception.

3 
 Q3. The primary purpose of the passage is to:

A. Contrast traditional political doctrines with Machiavelli’s unconventional ideas on statecraft.
B. Examine the difficulties rulers encounter in managing the nobility and the general populace.
C. Explore the lasting impact of Machiavelli’s theories on contemporary political thought.
D. Highlight Machiavelli’s leadership strategies, emphasizing the manipulation of public perception to sustain authority.
E. Illustrate Machiavelli’s perspective on governance and outline how his principles can be utilized by rulers to consolidate power.

4 
 Q4. Based on the passage, which of the following can most reasonably be inferred about Machiavelli’s view of the nobility?

A. The nobility is more loyal to the ruler than the common people but requires constant appeasement.
B. The nobility poses a greater threat to a ruler’s power than the common people and is harder to control.
C. The nobility can be essential allies for a ruler, provided they are given sufficient authority and autonomy.
D. The nobility can be easily manipulated if their wealth and titles are preserved.
E. The nobility is indifferent to the ruler’s authority as long as their privileges are maintained.

catinabox · Answer

Here are the official solutions.

Q1. According to the passage, which of the following statements best describes Machiavelli’s perspective on the relationship between a ruler and the common people?

Correct Answer:
C. A ruler can reduce the influence of the nobility by securing the loyalty of the common people. 
• This accurately reflects the passage’s explanation that by gaining the allegiance of the masses, a ruler can neutralize the power of the nobility.

Incorrect Answers: 
A. A ruler should avoid relying too heavily on the common people because their loyalty can easily shift in times of crisis.
• This is incorrect because, while the passage mentions that a ruler should not overestimate the loyalty of the common people, it emphasizes the importance of their support in times of crisis, not the avoidance of reliance.
B. The support of the common people is less important than maintaining control over the nobility.
• This contradicts the passage, which suggests that the common people’s support is crucial for a ruler’s survival and can be used to reduce the influence of the nobility.
D. Common people, due to their distance from power, are less likely to be a threat but are more difficult to manipulate.
• This is incorrect because the passage implies that common people are less of a threat and are more easily won over than the nobility, suggesting they are not more difficult to manipulate.
E. Machiavelli suggests that the middle class is the primary source of a ruler’s power and stability.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not emphasize the middle class as the main source of power; instead, it focuses on the common people’s allegiance and how a ruler can divert their dissatisfaction towards the nobility or middle class.

Q2. Which of the following best describes the organization of the passage?

Correct Answer:
A.   The passage introduces Machiavelli’s political philosophy and then discusses its practical application for rulers. 
• This option best captures the passage’s structure, which begins with an introduction to Machiavelli’s ideas and then moves into a discussion on how rulers can apply these ideas in practice.

Incorrect Answers: 
B. The passage presents Machiavelli’s views on power, details his strategy for managing different social classes, and concludes with a discussion on maintaining control.
• This option is close but slightly incorrect because it implies a more segmented approach, whereas the passage integrates these elements without such clear divisions. The passage only provides ideas to control the common people without any advice to control other social classes.
C. The passage begins by explaining Machiavelli’s philosophy, transitions into analyzing the common people’s role, and ends with a critique of the nobility.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not critique the nobility; it focuses on how to manage them.
D. The passage outlines Machiavelli’s ideas on leadership, explores the challenges of ruling, and concludes with advice on handling power struggles.
• This option misrepresents the passage by suggesting a broader discussion of challenges and power struggles, which is not the main focus.
E. The passage starts with Machiavelli’s political theories, contrasts them with traditional views, and finishes by advising rulers on manipulating public perception.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not explicitly contrast Machiavelli’s ideas with traditional views; it simply outlines his philosophy and its applications.

Q3. The primary purpose of the passage is to:

Correct Answer:
E. Illustrate Machiavelli’s perspective on governance and outline how his principles can be utilized by rulers to consolidate power. 
• This option effectively captures the passage’s primary goal, which is to present Machiavelli’s views on governance and explain how these ideas can be applied by rulers to secure and maintain their power.

Incorrect Answers: 
A. Contrast traditional political doctrines with Machiavelli’s unconventional ideas on statecraft.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not focus on contrasting traditional doctrines with Machiavelli’s ideas; it is centered on explaining his philosophy and its applications.
B. Examine the difficulties rulers encounter in managing the nobility and the general populace.
• This is incorrect because the passage doesn’t primarily analyze difficulties; instead, it offers Machiavelli’s strategies for managing these groups effectively.
C. Explore the lasting impact of Machiavelli’s theories on contemporary political thought.
• This option is incorrect because the passage does not discuss the historical or lasting impact of Machiavelli’s theories on modern politics.
D. Highlight Machiavelli’s leadership strategies, emphasizing the manipulation of public perception to sustain authority.
• This option is too narrow, as it focuses only on public perception, while the passage also discusses other aspects of Machiavelli’s approach to governance and power consolidation.

Q4. Based on the passage, which of the following can most reasonably be inferred about Machiavelli’s view of the nobility?

Correct Answer: 
 B. The nobility poses a greater threat to a ruler’s power than the common people and is harder to control. 
• This option accurately reflects the passage's implication that the nobility are more difficult to satisfy and pose a more significant threat to a ruler’s authority compared to the common people.

Incorrect Answers: 
A. The nobility is more loyal to the ruler than the common people but requires constant appeasement.
• This is incorrect because the passage suggests that the nobility are less loyal and more challenging to manage than the common people.
C. The nobility can be essential allies for a ruler, provided they are given sufficient authority and autonomy.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not portray the nobility as essential allies; instead, it suggests they are a group to be controlled and managed carefully.
D. The nobility can be easily manipulated if their wealth and titles are preserved.
• This is incorrect because the passage does not suggest that the nobility can be easily manipulated; in fact, it implies that they are difficult to control.
E. The nobility is indifferent to the ruler’s authority as long as their privileges are maintained.
• This is incorrect because the passage indicates that the nobility are not indifferent and that their influence must be carefully managed, as they pose a significant threat to the ruler’s power.

siddhantvarma · Answer

Hi experts. I'm unable to understand how A is the correct answer for Question 2.

According to me, the answer should be B. The passage begins by explaining Machiavelli's philosophy regarding the importance of power (Paragraph 1), then explores his strategies for managing the common people versus the nobility (Paragraph 2), and concludes with an explanation of how rulers can maintain control by manipulating social dynamics and public perception (Paragraph 3). This description accurately matches the passage structure.

Thus, Choice B accurately captures the passage's organization, reflecting how Machiavelli's views are presented, developed, and concluded.

I agree with A that the passage does introduce Machiavelli's political philosophy, but it does not explicitly shift into a discussion of practical applications. In my view, it merely expands on its principles/strategies around Leadership and maintaining control.

Can someone please help here and understand how A is correct and where I'm going wrong with my thought process?

DmitryFarber · Answer

siddhantvarma

This isn't a wonderful question, but there are still good reasons to cut B. Before we get there, though, it's worth noting that A is very vague. This is often a promising trait in an answer choice. The less it says, the harder it is to be wrong! Does the passage introduce M's philosophy? Sure! It runs through a few disconnected points about what Machiavellianism offers and how it is perceived. Does it then talk about practical application? Absolutely--it gets into detail about how to gain and maintain power, according to the theory. That's pretty practical, even if it's not a step-by-step guide.

If you dig into B, you can show that the first two items never clearly occur. First, what are M's views on power? Is that just the whole passage? There's no point at which we're told what he thinks power is, how it ought to be used, etc. The whole text may be related to gaining and keeping power, but we don't get to see what M's view on power is. There's certainly nothing in p1 about "the importance of power." In fact, power is never mentioned! As for "managing different social classes," it's just as the official explanation says. The text only talks about winning over the "common people." Other groups are mentioned in the context of portraying them as adversaries, but no advice is given on managing them.

In short, when an answer gives very specific details, be cautious. The exact wording doesn't need to appear, but there does need to be something explicit in the passage that you can't point to as doing exactly what the answer says. Be careful that you're not being too charitable in making these matches, as in "yeah, that's kind of like what they said." On the other hand, when an answer is very vague, you just have to ask whether that vague description does in fact cover the scope of what was said. If it does, then the answer works.

siddhantvarma · Answer

DmitryFarber  Thanks! This makes a lot of sense. 
You're right that B can be eliminated because the first paragraph doesn't discuss power but rather M's views on governance. Managing different social classes is also not mentioned in the second paragraph. I'm still not very convinced how A "discusses its practical application for rulers". It feels more like an inference to me, but now that I can confidently eliminate B, A seems to be the best answer choice.

DmitryFarber · Answer

siddhantvarma

What is wrong something "sounding like an inference"? An inference is something we can logically conclude from reading the text, so it's fair game. Or do you mean, "they don't do this in the text, but someone could figure it out on their own"?

In any case, the text gives several examples of practical results of M's suggested strategy, such as "by securing . . . a ruler can neutralize" and "this strategy diverts dissatisfaction away from the ruler."

Machiavellianism, rooted in the political philosophy of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

­Machiavellianism, rooted in the political philosophy of

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

Machiavellianism, rooted in the political philosophy of