Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track Your Progress

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

It appears that you are browsing the GMAT Club forum unregistered!

Signing up is free, quick, and confidential.
Join other 350,000 members and get the full benefits of GMAT Club

Registration gives you:

Tests

Take 11 tests and quizzes from GMAT Club and leading GMAT prep companies such as Manhattan GMAT,
Knewton, and others. All are free for GMAT Club members.

Applicant Stats

View detailed applicant stats such as GPA, GMAT score, work experience, location, application
status, and more

Books/Downloads

Download thousands of study notes,
question collections, GMAT Club’s
Grammar and Math books.
All are free!

Thank you for using the timer!
We noticed you are actually not timing your practice. Click the START button first next time you use the timer.
There are many benefits to timing your practice, including:

Now xy=x means xy-x=0 or x(1-y)=0 For the equation x(1-y)=0 to hold good, either x has to be 0 or y has to be 1. It can very well be that x=0 and y=1 at the same time. We are not sure. So since it is not clear if x=0 or not, this statement is not sufficient.

Now in statement 2. x+y=y clearly shows x=0.

So it must be B

HTH _________________

"You have to find it. No one else can find it for you." - Bjorn Borg

Now xy=x means xy-x=0 or x(1-y)=0 For the equation x(1-y)=0 to hold good, either x has to be 0 or y has to be 1. It can very well be that x=0 and y=1 at the same time. We are not sure. So since it is not clear if x=0 or not, this statement is not sufficient.

This question goes to show that when you have been looking at 700 level questions too long, you try and pick holes in something as simple as x = y - y ....

on the other hand, its good to finally get a question right!

Hi Jimmy86; if (2) where: x + y = x --> y = 0 [no information about x after subtracting x from both sides]

combining (1) & (2) [x*y=x; x+y=x]: x(0) = x for all values of x, x*0 is always a zero. So, we can say x (the result of the multiplication) is a zero. IMO C _________________

KUDOS me if you feel my contribution has helped you.

y (x + y) = x and so, x will be zero only if Y is also 0 or else the condition is not satisfied. So, IMO its E.

I agree... its E.

in case statement 2 : x+y = x x=-1 , y=0 gives -1+0 = -1 ; satisfies x=0 , y= 0 gives 0+0 = 0 ; satisfies we see x is not necessarily 0. Insufficient

And combining y(x+y)=x if x=0 ; y=0 then 0*(0+0)=0 ; satisfies if x=1/2 ; y=1/2 then 1/2*(1/2+1/2)=1/2 ; satisfies So x is not necessarily 0.Insufficient

Thus IMO its E

But what if the question states that x is an integer. Then i suppose the only value that of x that satisfies y(x+y)=x is x=0. and answer would be C(not sure, feel i am missing something) _________________

--- Jimmy

Life`s battles dont always go, To the stronger or faster man; But sooner or later the man who wins, Is the man who THINKS HE CAN .

KUDOS me if you feel my contribution has helped you.

This question goes to show that when you have been looking at 700 level questions too long, you try and pick holes in something as simple as x = y - y ....

on the other hand, its good to finally get a question right!

Haha yes! I definitely know what you mean. You're so traumatized from every question trying to trick you, that you're reluctant to believe that the answer could be sufficient with something as easy as X=Y-Y. I stared at it for a good 30 seconds trying to pick it apart too. That's hilarious.

(2) if y = x - x, then, it is sufficient to say y = "0".

plug in y (0) into (1) [x*y = x] or x = x*y x = x*0 RHS = x*0 = 0 for any value of a number, 0 times that number = 0 So, RHS is always "0" LHS = x LHS = RHS --> x = RHS x = 0 Sufficient

So, C IMO....except am doing something stupid somewhere. Please correct me. _________________

KUDOS me if you feel my contribution has helped you.

Buddy, I dont think u went wrong... I believe I am somewhere wrong..

The first mistake i made was, in substitution... I shud have substituted as (x+y) * y = (x+y)... instead of (X+Y)*Y= X..

But even after this I am getting (X+Y)*Y=(X+Y) ---> Y=1.. and this will finally yield that Both option are not suffiient... And I am not sure how to proceed further...

Can anyone help me pls...

gmatbull wrote:

(2) if y = x - x, then, it is sufficient to say y = "0".

plug in y (0) into (1) [x*y = x] or x = x*y x = x*0 RHS = x*0 = 0 for any value of a number, 0 times that number = 0 So, RHS is always "0" LHS = x LHS = RHS --> x = RHS x = 0 Sufficient

So, C IMO....except am doing something stupid somewhere. Please correct me.

@Gmatbull.. The first mistake i made was, in substitution... I shud have substituted as (x+y) * y = (x+y)... instead of (X+Y)*Y= X..

But even after this I am getting (X+Y)*Y=(X+Y) ---> Y=1.. and this will finally yield that Both option are not suffiient... And I am not sure how to proceed further...

I think you seem to make the expression difficult to yourself. First, realize that (2) has simplified the job: from x+y = x, you know y = 0. (x+y) * y = (x+y) ==> (x+y)0 = x+0 0 = x +0 0 = x you still arrive at C. _________________

KUDOS me if you feel my contribution has helped you.

The statements 1 and 2 are contradicting to each other.. Option 1 says that, X * Y = X which tends to give Y = 1,

But option 2 gives, X + Y = X, and So Y = 0. I believe such questions wont appear in GMAT and so less to worry about this question...

gmatbull wrote:

sivai87 wrote:

@Gmatbull.. The first mistake i made was, in substitution... I shud have substituted as (x+y) * y = (x+y)... instead of (X+Y)*Y= X..

But even after this I am getting (X+Y)*Y=(X+Y) ---> Y=1.. and this will finally yield that Both option are not suffiient... And I am not sure how to proceed further...

I think you seem to make the expression difficult to yourself. First, realize that (2) has simplified the job: from x+y = x, you know y = 0. (x+y) * y = (x+y) ==> (x+y)0 = x+0 0 = x +0 0 = x you still arrive at C.

The statements 1 and 2 are contradicting to each other.. Option 1 says that, X * Y = X which tends to give Y = 1,

But option 2 gives, X + Y = X, and So Y = 0. I believe such questions wont appear in GMAT and so less to worry about this question...

Not so. First of all statement (2) is \(x+y=y\) and not \(x+y=x\).

Next, (1) \(xy=x\) --> \(x(y-1)=0\) --> either \(x=0\) (and \(y\) can take any value) OR \(y=1\) (and \(x\) can take any value). So we can not say that \(y=1\) from this statement.

If the question were:

Is \(x = 0\)?

(1) \(xy = x\) (2) \(x+y=x\) (Note that this statement is changed)

Then the answer would be C:

(1) \(xy=x\) --> \(x(y-1)=0\) --> either \(x=0\) (and \(y\) can take any value) OR \(y=1\) (and \(x\) can take any value). Not sufficient. (2) \(x+y=x\) --> \(y=0\). Not sufficient to answer whether \(x=0\).

(1)+(2) As from (2) \(y=0\neq{1}\) then according to (1) \(x=0\). Sufficient.

The statements 1 and 2 are contradicting to each other.. Option 1 says that, X * Y = X which tends to give Y = 1,

But option 2 gives, X + Y = X, and So Y = 0. I believe such questions wont appear in GMAT and so less to worry about this question...

Not so. First of all statement (2) is \(x+y=y\) and not \(x+y=x\).

Next, (1) \(xy=x\) --> \(x(y-1)=0\) --> either \(x=0\) (and \(y\) can take any value) OR \(y=1\) (and \(x\) can take any value). So we can not say that \(y=1\) from this statement.

If the question were:

Is \(x = 0\)?

(1) \(xy = x\) (2) \(x+y=x\) (Note that this statement is changed)

Then the answer would be C:

(1) \(xy=x\) --> \(x(y-1)=0\) --> either \(x=0\) (and \(y\) can take any value) OR \(y=1\) (and \(x\) can take any value). Not sufficient. (2) \(x+y=x\) --> \(y=0\). Not sufficient to answer whether \(x=0\).

(1)+(2) As from (2) \(y=0\neq{1}\) then according to (1) \(x=0\). Sufficient.

So for this revised question answer would be C.

Hope it helps.

I seem to recall that you can't add/subtract variables from both sides of the equation unless you know the sign of the variables. But the question doesn't tell you the sign of x or y so I don't think the problem can be approached this way. I think the only way to answer the question is to plug in numbers for x and y then check to see if the equation holds.

For Option1, which of the below method need to be followed?

Method1 ---- \(xy = x\) ----> \(xy-x = 0\) ----> \(x(y-1) = 0\) ----> \(x = 0, y = 1\) ---- I thought this method is always true in determining a value Method2 ---- \(xy = x\) - Substitute values \(x=0\) & \(y\)can be any value? or \(x\) can be any value and \(y=1?\)