shiku4Gmat wrote:
About an hour back I downloaded the e-book and the book is great. Kudos to bb!!!
Btw, I need a clarification in Exercise 4: Using Other/Another
sentence 4: I have a large stamp collection. The stamps in this section are from the United States. Others are from other places in the world.
I feel that Others should be replaced by The others because we are specific in the previous sentence (The stamps "in this section"). Please clarify.
I think it depends on the assumptions as you have specifically pointed out and that's what will drive the answer.
Scenario 1: you have 3 sections in an area and you point to one section and in this case, you should use "the others" because "the others" is very specific and you can pretty much point to them. You would use "the" if you could be pretty specific about the remaining stamps.
Scenario 2: you have a section in a museum and then you have many other sections (you don't even know how many) and in that case it will be "others" since it is not specific.
I don't know how to make it more specific or less specific so that only one scenario works out, so may have to remove this particular example. This has been the most of what we have had to revise/update the grammar book with - making sure it could not be interpreted in multiple ways.
Quote:
Further, please let me know whether the following can be added to my rule book.
- 'another' will never be preceded by 'the'
Correct, since another is a+other, so there is an article there already.
_________________