MasteringGMAT wrote:
Today's production of biofuels derived from corn or from palm oil crops threatens global food supplies—the United States' push for ethanol has already contributed to rising world market prices for corn—and furthermore prompts eager farmers to carve out new farmland from dwindling rain forests. For these reasons, experts now recommend cultivation of the jatropha plant, whose seeds contain up to 40 percent oil. Jatropha and jatropha oil are inedible, so using this oil to manufacture a biofuel will not diminish current global food supplies. And, because the plants favor hot, dry conditions, they are unlikely to threaten rain forests.
Which of the following would, if true, most undermine the rationale provided above for recommending the cultivation of jatropha for biofuel manufacture?
A. Cultivation of jatropha plants in wet climates, though possible, is costly.
B. Some people believe that jatropha oil has medicinal value.
C. One acre of jatropha plants yields 20 percent less oil than one acre of palm trees.
D. The growing conditions favored by jatropha plants are ideal for a number of food crops.
E. The world market price of petroleum-derived fuels has fluctuated widely, sometimes falling below the world market price of any biofuel.
This is a plan-goal type of question.
Story:
- Production of biofuels derived from corn or from palm oil crops threatens global food supplies as corn is used to produce biofuels rather than as a source of food.
- To increase the production of corn, farmers are carving out new farmland from dwindling rainforests.
Plan:
- Promote cultivation of the jatropha plant
Support given
- The seeds contain up to 40 percent oil
- Jatropha and jatropha oil are inedible, so using this oil to manufacture a biofuel will not diminish current global food supplies
- The plants favor hot, dry conditions, they are unlikely to threaten rainforests
Goal:
- To reduce the burden on edible food supplies, such as corn or palm oil, that are used for the production of biofuels.
- To reduce the decrease in farmlands that are being carved out of rainforests to meet the global demand for food crops.
We have to weaken the likely hood of the success of the plan.
A. Cultivation of jatropha plants in wet climates, though possible, is costly.Cost is not a factor in the plan. Hence, this option is not in scope. Also, while the cultivation of jatropha is costly, we don't have any information on the other costs associated with the production process. If the production costs of the biofuel from jatropha plants are significantly less, the cultivation cost is likely to get offset. Hence, this option doesn't provide a strong reason to weaken the plan.
We can eliminate A.
B. Some people believe that jatropha oil has medicinal value.While this option provides an alternate use of jatropha oil, the goal is to reduce the burden on food supplies. Hence, this option doesn't provide a reason to weaken the plan.
We can eliminate B.C. One acre of jatropha plants yields 20 percent less oil than one acre of palm trees.This option is a mild weakener if we consider the fact that we might need more acres of land to produce the same amount of oil from jatropha plants than from palm trees. However, we do not know the type of land on which the jatropha plant grows. If the plant grows on marginal land, which cannot be used for agricultural purposes, the fact that one requires more land wouldn't weaken the plan.
We can eliminate C.D. The growing conditions favored by jatropha plants are ideal for a number of food crops.This option tells us that food crops and jatropha plants share the same growing conditions. So, it is likely that a number of farmers who currently grow food crops start growing jatropha plants instead of food crops. Hence, the production of food crops is likely to decrease, thereby threatening global food supplies. This option gives us a reason to doubt the success of the goal.
We can keep D.E. The world market price of petroleum-derived fuels has fluctuated widely, sometimes falling below the world market price of any biofuel.This option is out of scope at best. The price variance of petroleum-derived fuels is not related to the plan that we are evaluating.
We can eliminate E.Option D