In this critically acclaimed film, there are a well-developed plot and

Hi Chetan,

What About Option E WhY is it incorrect

Hi kani,
E is "There is a well-developed plot and an excellent plot of characters in this critically acclaimed film."
if you reverse the sentence " a well-developed plot and an excellent plot of charactersis are in this critically acclaimed film.
so what you require is verb are

Indeed a good one , which seems really baffling.

Lets break down the sentence it will be crystal clear :-

In this critically acclaimed film there is/are a well-developed plot and an excellent cast of characters.

So there are two items -

1. a well-developed plot
2. an excellent cast of characters.

Go back to MGMAT it states

The word and can unite two or more singular subjects, forming a compound plural subject.

Now explore the options -


A) In this critically acclaimed film, there are a well-developed plot and an excellent cast of characters.
B) In this critically acclaimed film, there is a well-developed plot and an excellent cast of characters.
C) In this film, which is critically acclaimed, there is a well-developed plot and an excellent cast of characters.
D) In this film, which has been critically acclaimed, there are a well-developed plot and an excellent cast of characters.
E) There is a well-developed plot and an excellent plot of characters in this critically acclaimed film.

Thus only (A) survives !!

To put in simple terms:
1. There is a brother and sister in the class
2. There are a brother and sister in the class
Example 1 is wrong and 2 is correct

Hi Chetan,

What About Option E WhY is it incorrect[/quote]

Hi kani,
E is "There is a well-developed plot and an excellent plot of characters in this critically acclaimed film."
if you reverse the sentence " a well-developed plot and an excellent plot of charactersis are in this critically acclaimed film.
so what you require is verb are[/quote]

Hi Chetan,

I completely agree with on this, but just from grammatical sense isn't E correct ,although it may loose on intended meaning part.

sir why is the use of present perfect wrong??
the film when came out was critically acclaimed and still is.......isnt that right??

avikroy

I have edited two typos in this reply. First, it is not B, but choice D, which is under discussion about the use of present perfect. The second typo I have edited is from saying 'past perfect' to 'present perfect'. As we see, there is no past perfect at all in any of the choices.

The point here is that when you use a present perfect such as 'has been critically acclaimed', it implies that the acclaim is all over now or is about to be over. Whereas, the use of present tense makes it explicit that even today the acclaim is relevant. One can see this from the fact that the choice uses a present tense verb 'are' to describe the status of the compound subject.

Normally we take the present tense to be more eternal than a present perfect.

In addition, if you mean that the film was acclaimed only at the time when it was released and not beyond, then the correct tense would be to use the simple past tense for a bygone issue

Thank you sir ......got the idea .....daagh

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.