KC wrote:
Growing evidence that coastal erosion occurs continuously, not in just such calamitous bursts like hurricanes, has led scientists and planners to urge a stringent new approach to limiting development along the nation's shoreline.
(A) coastal erosion occurs continuously, not in just such calamitous bursts like hurricanes, has
(B) coastal erosion occurs continuously, not just in calamitous bursts such as hurricanes, has
(C) coastal erosion is continuously occurring, not in just calamitous bursts like hurricanes, having
(D) there is continuous coastal erosion, not just in calamitous bursts such as hurricanes, which has
(E) there is continuous coastal erosion occurring, not in just such calamitous bursts like hurricanes, has
This question is based on Sentence Structure and Idiomatic usage.
In Option A, the placement of the adverb ‘just’ changes the meaning. The adverb, as it is placed in this option modifies ‘such calamitous bursts’. It should modify the other adverb ‘not’. Additionally, the conjunction ‘like’ implies a comparison that is not being made in the sentence. The sentence gives an example of calamitous bursts which is conveyed by the phrase ‘such as’. So,
Option A can be eliminated.
Option B contains the appropriate idiomatic usage – such as. The placement of the adverb ‘just’ is also appropriate in this option. So, B is the best option.Option C is incomplete. The sentence as conveyed by this option only contains two modifiers without a subject and verb to complete the sentence. It also contains the same error of adverb placement as Option A. So,
Option C can be eliminated.
Option D is also incomplete. It again consists of two modifiers. The only difference between C and D is the form of the second modifier. So,
Option D can also be eliminated.
Option E also has the same incorrect adverb placement as Options A and C. The phrase “continuous coastal erosion occurring” is redundant as either the adjective ‘continuous’ or the present participle ‘occurring’ would convey the sense of continuity. So,
Option E can also be eliminated.
Therefore, B is the most appropriate option.Jayanthi Kumar.