Swoosh617 wrote:
So after a pretty insightful back-and-forth convo that I had with EssaySnark through PM, here's some takeaways that I think could help some of you applying:
Most of the convo was about that first essay involving your post-MBA goal. I made the mistake of assuming that since the short-response question was asking about the short-term goal, that I would spend the entire essay talking about my long-term goal. The advice I had gotten previously was to talk about where I wanted to be at the peak of my career. The problem was that adcom generally looks for applicants that have a realistic idea of where they want to be 5-8 years from now and how an MBA will take them there. My essay must have been confusing because I spent too much time talking about where I wanted to be 15-20 years from now, without ever stating that that's the time frame i was speaking towards. It made it sound as if I would be running my own investment management fund before I was 30, which painted a pretty unrealistic picture in the eyes of adcom.
If anything, I should have at least built a clear roadmap between where I am now and where I will be at my peak, but the majority of the essay should have been about where I see myself in those middle years.
Hey Swoosh617 - just to clarify:
The majority of Columbia essay 1 should actually be focusing on the immediate post-MBA goal, how you'll get there, why you're qualified for it, how Columbia will help you. Maybe that's what you meant by "those middle years" since we're talking 2016 (grad date) and onwards, which seems like a really long time from now, but just wanted that to be crystal clear for everyone.
Don't go too far out with goals and ambition with Columbia. Be anchored in the practical and realistic, and show how you're going to get where you say you want to go.
We're always bummed when we hear stories like yours, Swoosh617. You're an uber-qualified candidate who had a misstep on the essays. It's great that you shared your experience openly here, so that others may benefit. It's also great that you applied to Columbia super early since now you can correct course and tackle those other excellent MBA programs. We're convinced you'll see a different outcome with your Round 1 apps.
Good luck to everyone going for Columbia and remember, those goals are important!! Here and other schools too, but definitely here.
EssaySnark