Bunuel wrote:
In a sprint race, a man has to run two distances, D1 and D2, to complete the race. Jim is participating in the race. If distance D2 is thrice of the distance D1, what is average speed of Jim?
(1) Jim covered the distance D1 by running at 1 kilometer per hour and distance D2 by running at 6 kilometers per hour.
(2) The amount of time Jim took to cover distance D1 was twice of the time it took him to cover distance D2.
OFFICIAL EXPLANATION FROM Egmat
Correct Answer: A
Steps 1 & 2: Understand Question and Draw Inferences
Given: * A man a man has to run two distances, D1 and D2, to complete a sprint race.
* Jim is participating in the race.
* Distance D2 is thrice of the distance D1.
To Find: * Average speed of Jim. Average Speed = Total distance covered/Total time taken
* Total distance covered = D1 + D2 = D1 + 3 D1= 4D1
* Total time taken= Time taken to cover D1 + Time taken to cover D2
Time taken to cover \(D_1 = \frac{D_1}{S_1}\) , where S1 is the speed to cover D1.
Time taken to cover \(D_2 = \frac{D_2}{S_2} = \frac{(3D_1)}{S_2}\) , where S2 is the speed to cover D2.
* Average Speed = \(\frac{(4D_1)}{(Time \ taken \ to \ cover \ D_1+ Time \ taken \ to \ cover \ D_2 )} = \frac{4D_1}{\frac{D_1}{S_1} + \frac{D_2}{S_2}} = \frac{4D_1}{\frac{D_1}{S_1} + \frac{3D_1}{S_2}}= \frac{4}{\frac{1}{S_1} + 3S_2}\)
* We need S1 and S2 to find the answer.
We do not have enough information to find the answer, let us analyze the statements.
Step 3: Analyse Statement 1: “Jim covered the distance D1 by running at 1 kilometer per hour and distance D2 by running at 6 kilometers per hour.”
* S1 = 1 and S2 = 6
Therefore, statement 1 alone is sufficient. Step 4: Analyse Statement 2: “The amount of time Jim took to cover distance D1 was twice of the time it took him to cover distance D2.”
* Time taken to cover D1 = 2 × Time taken to cover D2
* \(\frac{D_1}{S_1} = 2 × \frac{(3D_1)}{S_2}\)
* \(\frac{1}{S_1} =\frac{6}{S_2}\)
* \(S_2 = 6S_1\)
This statement gives a relation between S1 and S2. However, we can find the value of S1 and S2.
Therefore, statement 2 alone is NOT sufficient.
Step 5: Analyse both statements together: This step is not required, since, we got the answer from statement 1
Hence, the correct answer is Option A.