The brain contributes to the adaptive success of animals through the c

Question 2

A good first step is to identify the author's purpose in each paragraph. Once you've done that, take a moment to consider how the paragraphs add up. Ask yourself: what was the author's goal in writing this passage as a whole?

In some cases, the primary purpose might be referenced in each paragraph, as you suggest, but we definitely don't want to assume that's the case. Sometimes, the first paragraph might describe the primary purpose, while the last paragraph is just an afterthought. Other times, the first paragraph may present background info, while a later paragraph states the author's purpose. Whatever the case, it's best to avoid assumptions, and to consider the author's purpose with an open mind.

Let's now apply this strategy to the passage:

• Purpose of Paragraph 1: To explain how the "brain contributes to the adaptive success of animals" by allowing our movements to serve a purpose (such as running away from something).
• Purpose of Paragraph 2: To argue that genes control not only our "brains, muscles, and sensory organs," but our sense of "purpose and complex consciousness."

What do these paragraph's add up to? Well, the second paragraph presents an argument about genetic control. More specifically, it argues that genes control not only our brains (which control our muscles), but our "sense of purpose." How does the first paragraph relate to this? Well, it provides background information to set up the argument in the second paragraph. In other words, it discusses the brain's relationship to basic movements and purpose to provide context for the argument about genetic control of different brain functions.

Let's now consider (A):


It's true the first paragraph doesn't mention genes, but that isn't necessarily a problem. Considering the passage as a whole, we see the function of the first paragraph is to provide context for the argument in the second paragraph. So the author's primary purpose is really just to argue that genes control not only our "brains, muscles, and sensory organs," but our sense of "purpose and complex consciousness." This lines up well with answer choice (A), so it's correct.

I hope that helps!

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION Q2:

While the author does not reveal a thesis or purpose in the beginning of the passage, the author does express their position in the latter part of the passage and thus, the primary purpose of the passage best aligns with answer choice A. The passage contains various pieces of information and some explanations, but clearly the overall approach is not merely to present or explain the information. Therefore, explain and outline are dubious. It is also easy to see that the author does not claim to be refuting anyone else’s theory. The passage does, however, present argumentation for the author’s position. After outlining a number of interrelated pieces of information about the adaptive functions of nervous systems, in the second paragraph, the author argues for an interpretation of the information and for a loosely stated conclusion about genetics in relation to human consciousness. Answer choice A best expresses the author’s conclusion, which is presented at the end of the passage.

A Correct. The main focus of the passage is on arguing for a position that is expressed in the latter part of the second paragraph. Answer choice A gives a concise paraphrase of the author’s position.
B In the first paragraph, the author discusses the roles of sensory and motor information transmitted to and from the brain. But this is presented only as a subtopic contributing toward the overall purpose of the passage.
C In writing the passage, the author might conceivably have intended, at least indirectly, to refute someone else’s theory about human perception and consciousness. However, the passage provides no evidence that the author did intend it in this way.
D In the first paragraph, the author discusses motor action and its adaptive function, but this is presented only as a subtopic contributing toward the overall purpose of the passage.
E The first paragraph does contrast human information processing with that performed by computers, but it does so only to support the claims it is making about human brain activity. The second paragraph implies that human information processing surpasses that in other animals but concludes that the processes are fundamentally similar.

The correct answer is A.

Good passage, 4 mins all correct, will be happy to help if required, 700+ questions for sure

Hi,

I'm still confused with the explanation of Q2. Which parts tell us the author is arguing in the passage? It seems the author only explains nerve systems.
thanks

Hey, let me try an help you with a general framework for answering primary purpose questions. For such questions ask yourself "Whats the writers intent behind writing this passage"

What does the author want to prove/disapprove, argue for or against. Don't get into the details but take a step back and take a birds eye view.

A few places where you can generally find the primary purpose is the beginning of the passage, the last few lines or the alongside transition words like However, Nevertheless... etc.

In this passage for example, the whole point is to try and hypothesise that it is the genes that control our sensory organs, all the details are just to give you a broadd understanding of the sensory system to arrive at this point, think of it like a movie or tv show, episode 1 and episode 10 have little in common but they are all part of a narrative... to prove a point, you just need to figure out what that point is. The following excerpt from the passage sums it up quite nicely.

"However, both our sense of purpose and complex consciousness may well be genetically engineered. Our genes have created our brains, muscles, and sensory organs to help us and may also have created a kind of “conscious-purpose machine” to direct us to live and reproduce by means of innate drives—hunger, sexuality, communication, fear, and aggression. This machine may also direct higher-level interpretations of these drives. That direction of consciousness is the ultimate genetic control"


I believe to succeed in CR and RC inference questions you need something known as "second level thinking", you need to think beyond the obvious conclusions, that's exactly the trap GMAT sets for you, because everybody thinks like that, you need to go beyond them especially in 700+ questions, the answers are rarely straight forward if they were it wouldn't be a 700+ question in the first place.

Hi I am confused- I do not see that specific line in the passage? That isn't meant to be a paraphrase of any other line is it? And without that clearly stated line, the answer is less obviously C.

Hi nityaraju,

Option C for Question 3 can be inferred from the lines:
"Because humans are capable of self-reflection, we feel that our sensory perception and muscle activity are guided by apparent purposiveness. However, both our sense of purpose and complex consciousness may well be genetically engineered. Our genes have created our brains, muscles, and sensory organs to help us and may also have created a kind of “conscious-purpose machine” to direct us.....".

Implication being that our genes create an awareness of our own consciousness, because of which we are able to self-relfect.

Hope This Helps.
Thanks.

A) argue that genes may control complex as well as basic brain functions- Correct
1st para: what brain does
2nd para: how does it happens?

B) explain the relationship between sensory and motor operations of the brain
It is mentioned as outline to describe brain function in 1st passage; not a main

C) refute a theory about human perception and consciousness
No refutation

D) explain the principal elements of the adaptive behavior of motor action
Primary purpose is not explain adaptive behavior but it is present in 1st para to set the groundwork for overall meaning of passage.

E) outline the difference between human and nonhuman information processing
Only mentioned in the end of 1st para

When individual sees, sensor organs (eyes) translate physical events (individual see) into nerve impulses through sensor organs(eye) connected to brain with sensors nerves.

But it is not mentioned how this interpretation in SENSORY NERVES happens.

Very close option
Refer line :
The brain is connected to the sense organs by sensory nerves.
Animals that have survived are those equipped with sense organs—the eyes, ears, taste buds, skin, and nose—that translate patterns of physical events into nerve impulses in the brain.


Refer line : However, it will be decades before the functions of human sense organs can be duplicated by machines.


no comparison between humans and animals of any organs
Refer line :
adaptive success of animals through the control and coordination of muscle contractions.
human senses can achieve more sophisticated feats of pattern recognition than computers



If see this option in hurry then may miss what is being asked? Read again!

Brain is connected with sensory organs through SENSORY NERVES
Brain is connected with muscles through MOTOR NERVES
Not Brain is connected with SENSORY NERVES and MOTOR Nerves






Sensorimotor means: sense + motor system (split the word)
Dictionary meaning: sensorimotor : Of or relating to the sensory and motor coordination of an organism or to the controlling nerves

Refer lines:
The brain contributes to the adaptive success of animals through the control and coordination of muscle contractions. This leads to the survival of an animal only if the timing of muscle contractions bears some relation to purpose. Animals that have survived are those equipped with sense organs.

(muscles coordination won’t happen unless perceived by sense organs when to run and when to eat on seeing food)

Why the consciousness happens? How humans knows when to contract muscles or send nerver impulses to brain?

Because humans are capable of self-reflection. Both our sense of purpose and complex consciousness may well be genetically engineered.


Yes we know the information is sent to brain but what initiates the sending? Why this happens at first place?

Refer line:
we feel that our sensory perception and muscle activity are guided by apparent purposiveness. However,


Because humans are capable of self-reflection


This happens why ? Because humans are capable of self-reflection.and then genetic does all this. Genes are HOW. The question is asked WHY?


Yes, we know eyes can perceive things but how this happens at first place?

coreyander Thanks for posting this! I see that this passage is tagged with source "GMAT Prep", do you know exactly where you found it? I don't immediately recall seeing this one on the practice tests or question packs.

Hi,
This question is from GMAT Question Pack 2.

This passage is tagged as Easy Difficulty level in GMAT Question Pack!! But I felt it is somewhere near 700+ level.
I have felt this difference in difficulty level in many official verbal questions.
Is this difference felt by anyone else too??

The official explanation to question 3 mentions a sentence the author states.

However that sentence is not located within the passage.

“Midway through the 2nd paragraph the author states:Our own introspection tells us that we are indeed concious....”

Is this a direct quote of a sentence the author states?

Is the passage complete?

Posted from my mobile device

Totally. Even in SC and CR, some questions mentioned in Medium level difficulty on GMAT prep are actually 700 level questions and some questions mentioned in Difficult level difficulty on GMAT prep are actually 600-700 level questions! It's completely bonkers, but it's true!

Please elaborate more on Q3?

Question: Find SOURCE ( from where it all started)
With this thought B, D, E are steps followed after C.



You can try to understand the logic of these lines.


Because humans are capable of self-reflection (C)
--> apparent purposiveness (B)
---> genetically engineered(D)----> created our brains, muscles, and sensory organs ---> conscious-purpose machine (B) ( meaning: direct us and live reproduce by means of innate drives - E)

In Summary, Because humans are capable of self reflection , the purposiveness comes which is due to genetically engineering.

Note: A can be ignored as it is not in our area of concern at the moment.



Now can you spot answer C?
I hope it helps.