First, let me say I'm sorry to those that received unwanted information over the past two days. For those of you who are truly determined to get in, do not let this setback keep you down. With enough will and resolve, you WILL get in. Keep the faith.
Quote:
Does anybody know anything supports or refutes this idea?
I support this idea. Although we think of AdCom as this abstract group, remember that they are just people. Imagine reading 1000 applications, which they do. In case that doesn't make an impression, that's 1000 1000 word applications. Assuming zero people wrote essay four, that's 1,000,000 words for Fall 2008 alone. You could say wow and leave it at that but let's think harder about this. What kind of people would sign up for an admissions committee? Why would you do this? It's not like this is one of the higher paying jobs in the world. That said, I think these are not only caring people but people who care very much about the NYU MBA program. Many are probably NYU MBA graduates who are looking to protect the integrity of the degree they hold and ensure the most positive environment for the incoming students. So when they read this stuff, certain people stand out in their minds. Even though you are technically just an application to them, they know you are a person with dreams too. I think the WL'ers are people who some of AdCom loved and left an impression on and some others on AdCom didn't get that same impression. This left you on the fence and hence the WL. When the admissions committee takes their second look, they remember your application and it becomes a debate over which people they can ALL agree are the best fits for NYU. If you hit the WL, someone at AdCom really liked you but it just wasn't unanimous. So yes, you are tiered in their minds because the people who have to argue for you in those meetings will only argue the hardest for their favorites.
Don't forget, when you complete the Stern MBA,
you will be eligible to be on AdCom. Would you remember the people you liked best? Would you argue for those people the most? I know I would. Therefore, people are tiered, like it or not. It's human nature.