[24+ 5(23)^1/2)]^1/2 + [24- 5(23)^1/2)]^1/2 lies between:

I took a different approach. The \(\sqrt{23}\) is between 4 and 5. As 23 is closer to 25 than 16, the square root will be just under 5. So \(5\sqrt{23}\) will be just under 25. That makes the first part of the equation approximately \(\sqrt{49}\) and the second part of the equation \(\sqrt{1}\).

Actually this part is not correct. You can see that the question itself has this term : \(\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}}\) and the term under the root has to be positive. Thus, \(24\geq5\sqrt{23}\). So, it is just less than 24. With this you can approximate the first part as\(\approx \sqrt{48}\) and not as \(\sqrt{49}\).

IMO, now you wouldn't know whether the second part is approximately 0 or a little more than 0. So I guess, with this method, one can get stuck between C and D.

I would follow what Bunuel has suggested above.

First expression is almost 7 since square root of 23 is pretty close to 5 and square root of 49 = 7

By the same token expression two should be very close to 1 since it can't be negative

So we have 'Almost 7' + 1 = 'Almost 8'

D works just fine

Cheers
J

I am not able to understand how (24^2 - 25*23)^1/2 = 2.

As How I am doing it:

(24^2 - (24+1)(24-1))^1/2
(24^2 - (24^2 - 1^2))^1/2
(24^2 - 24^2)^1/2 by approximation as 24^2-1 would be almost equal to 24^2
=0

Can anyone please help me where I am going wrong?

Many Thanks!!!

How do you get that expression two is very close to 1?

\(\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}}\)
If we assume that 23 is close to 25 so its square root is 5, (24 - 25) gives you -1. But that is not possible since the whole thing is under a root. It must be slightly positive. Since \(\sqrt{23}\) is less than 5, \(5*\sqrt{23}\) must be less than 25, in fact it must be slightly less than 24 since the root has to be 0 or +ve.

So \(\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}}\) will become slightly more than 0.

This means you have 'Almost 7' to which you are adding 'Almost 0'. Can you say whether the sum will be less than or more than 7? No. Hence you get stuck between (C) and (D).

Now to get to the answer you will have to use Bunuel's method.

You are misreading something.

\(\sqrt{24^2 - 25*23} = \sqrt{576 - 575} = 1\)

The 2 with it is the 2 from the 2ab term of \((a+b)^2 = a^2 + b^2 + 2ab\)

Put a = \(24 + 5\sqrt{23}\)
Put b = \(24 - 5\sqrt{23}\)

Now find \((a + b)^2\). You get this as 50.
Then what is (a+b)? It is \(\sqrt{50}\)

For me the best thing to do is note that 5\sqrt{23} is equal to 25*23 doing this you note that the answer to your question will be ˜\sqrt{50} and is between 7 and 8

\(\sqrt{23}\) >>>> considered it as \(\sqrt{25}\)
First expression would come up as 7
So 7 + something would be the Answer = D

If we USE approximation then first value we get near 7 and the second value just near 1 so the final value between 7 and 8.

Hi,

I solved the question using same method, however it was difficult to judge and so went with C. It might have taken extra time in exam. What to do in similar situations? Any other way around?

Bunuel Hi. I've read your explanations and seems like I understood it but can you please tell me what was wrong with my approach?

x=\((\sqrt{24+5([square_root]23}[/square_root]))^(\sqrt{1/2)+(24-5([square_root]23}))[/square_root])^(1/2)\)
1: square both sides --> \(X^2\)=\(24+5(\sqrt{23})+24-5(\sqrt{23})\)
2: positive and negative \(5(\sqrt{23})\)=0 so \(x^2\)=24+24=48
3: make a square root from both sides --> x=\((\sqrt{48})\) and it is less than 7

Bunuel, I understood your explanation until this point:

Apply \((a+b)(a-b)=a^2-b^2\) to the second term:

\(24+5\sqrt{23}+2\sqrt{24^2-25*23}+24-5\sqrt{23}=48+2=50\).

Is like you decided not to show some of your solving, but I got lost. I don't know how you arrived at the answer.
Please help, thanks!

Added extra steps:

\((\sqrt{24+5\sqrt{23}} +\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}})^2=(\sqrt{24+5\sqrt{23}})^2+2\sqrt{24+5\sqrt{23}}*\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}}+(\sqrt{24-5\sqrt{23}})^2=\)
\(=24+5\sqrt{23}+2\sqrt{(24+5\sqrt{23})(24-5\sqrt{23})}+24-5\sqrt{23}=48+2\sqrt{(24+5\sqrt{23})(24-5\sqrt{23})}\).

Apply \((a+b)(a-b)=a^2-b^2\) to the second term (\(2\sqrt{(24+5\sqrt{23})(24-5\sqrt{23})}\)):

\(48+2\sqrt{24^2-25*23}=48+2\sqrt{1}=50\).

So, our expression equals to: \(\sqrt{50}\approx{7.something}\)

Thanks a lot!

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.