I bought this book and went through it when I was studying, and found it to be pretty helpful. I don't think I maximized it in the sense that my study of it was a little disjointed, however I still found myself grasping the topics much better at the higher levels. It will help you see through the layers that separate hard questions from 700 level questions. GMAT day my quant was bad - I got started off with a tough question and never really recovered, ended up with a 43, but I would still recommend this book.
Different perspective post exam: I took the real GMAT a couple of days ago -- scored Q50. My overall score was 760 (Q 50, V 44). I was always pretty strong in the verbal section (LSAT prep years ago and I write reports and grant proposals). But quant really scared me -- I invested a lot of time in the advanced quant book mainly because my first manhattan CAT quant did not go all that well.
Now what I realized is this (post real gmat and gmat prep practice) -- the manhattan quant questions are a lot of fun if you like solving difficult math problems. But they are not representative of the real deal. The real gmat questions are very elegant -- in that -- they are not HARD -- they are just *brilliantly* tricky. Manhattan problems take a long time to solve -- they require a lot of work. But the real gmat questions have this tone about them -- its so unique. Most of the problems on the real gmat can be cracked with a proper technique and an analytical approach -- you don't need to use fancy formulas or solve complex expressions and equations. I am very pleased with my Q50 -- but I don't think the manhattan advanced quant guide helped me much. The real GMAT questions are very subtle -- they are not over powering. The best guide you can use is the GMATPrep software. Keep resetting this software and do every problem (there are plenty of problems in both the bins) on there. I could hardly complete the Manhattan quant sections -- but I completed my real gmat quant exam with 8 minutes to spare.
I am so impressed with the way the real gmat math people conjure up these simple yet elegant problems -- not overpowering but subtle. The manhattan advanced book does not mimic this tone.
Congratulations. What was your first MGMAT CAT quant score by the way? I am just curious.
rjdunn03
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
Posted: Sun Aug 21, 2011 2:49 pm
Manager
Joined: Thu May 05, 2011 Posts: 167 Location: United States (IL) GMAT 1: 780 Q49 V50
WE: Research (Other) Followers: 5
I had 690 on the first MGMAT CAT. I think it was 43 or 44 in Q.
gablaze23 wrote:
Congratulations. What was your first MGMAT CAT quant score by the way? I am just curious.
I am getting a flat grade of Q43 in my MGMAT too. I have taken 3 tests so far, Q45, Q43 and another Q43.
You said you would rather work with OG materials bec their style of questions are more elegant and whatnot, but do you think Manhattan GMAT materials prepare you in Math so much so that the actual GMAT will feel easier? Lol. I want to know whether in your opinion, I should still finish the Advanced Quant problem sets, which is another 150 numbers. Or should I just re-do my OG?
DevilDoggNC
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
It's very hard to say -- I would hate to lead you down the wrong road.
And what worked for me, or even my opinion on this subject -- might be completely wrong.
The 150 problems are challenging and will help you build your analytical and quant skills -- no doubt about it.
But if you were hard pressed for time (as I was) -- I am not convinced that those hard 150 problems are going to help you the most when it comes to scoring. The GMAT prep problems -- I did only those the last 3 weeks and re-set the software and got several new questions on multiple attempts. Those were the most representative of the real stuff.
It all depends on how much time you have. If time is not an issue -- I would say working through the 150 problems in MGMAT Advanced guide will help you get better. The MGMAT explanations are pretty good too.
But if your test is in 2 or 3 weeks -- don't ignore the GMAT Prep or leave it till the last couple of days (people make this mistake thinking its only 2 tests and not realizing that each test bin has a question bank). GMAT Prep and the last 100 problems in PS and DS sections of the OG beat the rest of the materials out there (in my humble opinion).
gablaze23 wrote:
DevilDoggNC wrote:
I had 690 on the first MGMAT CAT. I think it was 43 or 44 in Q.
gablaze23 wrote:
Congratulations. What was your first MGMAT CAT quant score by the way? I am just curious.
I am getting a flat grade of Q43 in my MGMAT too. I have taken 3 tests so far, Q45, Q43 and another Q43.
You said you would rather work with OG materials bec their style of questions are more elegant and whatnot, but do you think Manhattan GMAT materials prepare you in Math so much so that the actual GMAT will feel easier? Lol. I want to know whether in your opinion, I should still finish the Advanced Quant problem sets, which is another 150 numbers. Or should I just re-do my OG?
DevilDoggNC
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
This will be a good subject to get some other points of view.
I am sure there are people on both camps who swear by their experiences. There is one school of thought that says that if you practice on really hard stuff -- then you will ace the easy stuff. I am not so sure about this though. If you practice on really hard stuff -- you might miss the subtlety and minor twists in relatively easier questions (something GMAC does).
It's important to get the easy / medium questions right and make sure you avoid silly mistakes -- this will ensure that you maximize your score. I'm sure there are others who feel differently about this strategy than I do.
For example, I see a number of people on this forum practice LSAT CR and RC questions. I know a bit about the LSAT and although I took it 10 years ago not much has changed on the exam. And most of the guys doing the LSAT CR questions aren't the ones scoring V46 and V48 -- trying to get V51. A lot of the guys doing the LSAT CR and RC questions are the ones scoring V31 and V32 -- hoping that practicing the *tough* stuff from the LSAT is going to improve their score. I would do the exact opposite -- work on fundamentals -- such as finding the conclusion of the argument and understanding the underlying logic -- improving critical reading skills etc.
gablaze23 wrote:
but do you think Manhattan GMAT materials prepare you in Math so much so that the actual GMAT will feel easier?
Asher
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
Posted: Mon Aug 22, 2011 11:02 pm
Manager
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2011 Posts: 77 Location: India GMAT 1: Q V
Followers: 0
Does the Advanced GMAT Quant Strategy Supplement (Paperback) come with online access.
I just received the delivery of this book purchase by flipkart.com, India, but it did not have the online access code. Now when i spoke to flipkart, they say that the book may not come with an online access. Is that the case? Please let me know.
_________________ Regards, Asher
Aj85
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
I am going to begin this book this weekend. Hope I learn lots of things and my strategies get better.
Asher wrote:
Does the Advanced GMAT Quant Strategy Supplement (Paperback) come with online access.
I just received the delivery of this book purchase by flipkart.com, India, but it did not have the online access code. Now when i spoke to flipkart, they say that the book may not come with an online access. Is that the case? Please let me know.
No the book does not comes with online access. Only basic 8 guides of Manhattan come with access to tests, the supplement guides do not.
Asher
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
Posted: Tue Aug 23, 2011 3:55 am
Manager
Joined: Wed Apr 06, 2011 Posts: 77 Location: India GMAT 1: Q V
Followers: 0
Best, Matt Mapplebeck Student Services Associate Manhattan GMAT
Thanks Matt.
I wrote to books@manhattangmat.com about the issue, and was granted access to the online material.
_________________ Regards, Asher
xjunglee1
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
Posted: Thu Jan 05, 2012 6:54 am
Intern
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2011 Posts: 24 Location: United States
Concentration: Technology, Real Estate GMAT Date: 03-26-2012
WE: Project Management (Computer Software) Followers: 0
Thanks everyone for the inputs. Just to share my experience on this book I performed surprisingly poor in DS and I went through the chapter on DS and it significantly improved my score. I guess possible reason is I was handling DS questions incorrectly although basics were right. So I found this book really useful.
AbhiJ
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
This will be a good subject to get some other points of view.
I am sure there are people on both camps who swear by their experiences. There is one school of thought that says that if you practice on really hard stuff -- then you will ace the easy stuff. I am not so sure about this though. If you practice on really hard stuff -- you might miss the subtlety and minor twists in relatively easier questions (something GMAC does).
It's important to get the easy / medium questions right and make sure you avoid silly mistakes -- this will ensure that you maximize your score. I'm sure there are others who feel differently about this strategy than I do.
For example, I see a number of people on this forum practice LSAT CR and RC questions. I know a bit about the LSAT and although I took it 10 years ago not much has changed on the exam. And most of the guys doing the LSAT CR questions aren't the ones scoring V46 and V48 -- trying to get V51. A lot of the guys doing the LSAT CR and RC questions are the ones scoring V31 and V32 -- hoping that practicing the *tough* stuff from the LSAT is going to improve their score. I would do the exact opposite -- work on fundamentals -- such as finding the conclusion of the argument and understanding the underlying logic -- improving critical reading skills etc.
Awesome advice
_________________ How hard you play when no one is watching.
gmatpunjabi
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
I took a diagnostic and got Q39 (and V39). I've been re-learning all the basics that I had forgotten, and am quickly approaching that glass ceiling (just got a Q42 on a practice test after making some silly mistakes). What are my options for breaking through the glass ceiling to eventually reach Q50? I have more than enough time. What are the alternatives to purchasing and using this book in conjunction with, say, GMAT Club tests?
AbhiJ
Re: Advanced GMAT Quant from Manhattan GMAT [#permalink]
The key to reaching Q48-49 is to a.) improve accuracy/timing on DS problems b.) get a good handle on the frequently tested topics - again to improve timing.
GMATClub tests are very good for this purpose - after 10 or so tests you would see your score crossing Q45 and possibly Q47+.
_________________ How hard you play when no one is watching.