honchos wrote:
kinjiGC wrote:
To many citizens of Napoleonic-era France, before Haiti was Haiti, it was Dominique, a small province of France that produced sugar cane, rum, and tobacco.
(A) before Haiti was Haiti, it was Dominique
(B) Haiti was Dominique, before there was a Haiti
(C) before there was Haiti, it was Dominique
(D) Haiti was what was known as Dominique
(E) Haiti was what had been referred to as Dominique
I am not sure about A) Can any of the experts reply on this?
I picked up D) and my reasoning is
I can convert the sentence as
Haiti was what was known to many citizens of Napoleonic-era France as Dominique, a small province....I AM NOT QUITE SURE IF THE SENTENCE CAN BE INTERPRETED THIS WAY
Can somebody explain if the OA is A) .
The category says it is a GMAT Prep question, but I haven't seen the question in all the GMAT Prep questions that I have solved.
Trust me!! GMAT questions aren't really all that 'great' always...they could end up being quite wierd at times!
Anyways..A, though wierd, is the only choice that fits in best!!
The original sentence categorically says that before Haiti was known as Haiti, it was known as Dominique
(a small province...) to
(whom?) the citizens of France. A does the job well.
D, on the other hand, says that
To many citizens of Napoleonic-era France, Haiti was what was known (to the Germans/Americans/French/Indians...or to the entire world? no clarity to whom Haiti was known as Dominique, we cannot explicitly attribute this knowledge of Haiti being known as Dominique to the French) as Dominique, a small province of France that produced sugar cane, rum, and tobacco.
Second, note that the sentence intends to convey that a region known as Dominique to the French before was so until it actually became Haiti. Today, it is known to the French as a probably bigger or a different small region, Haiti, which probably is not the same as the earlier Dominique was..Point is that Haiti may or may not be equal to Dominique . D just says that Haiti was itself known as Dominique
(i.e. Haiti=Dominique, a fact one cannot be quite sure of)...and a meaning not intended to be conveyed.
Hence, A wins.