Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Status: Never ever give up on yourself.Period.
Joined: 23 Aug 2012
Posts: 129
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, Human Resources
GMAT 1: 570 Q47 V21 GMAT 2: 690 Q50 V33
GPA: 3.5
WE: Information Technology (Investment Banking)

Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Dec 2012, 06:18
Question Stats:
68% (02:36) correct 32% (03:09) wrong based on 307 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclusive. Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive. If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A, y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, and y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y, what is the probability that the product xy is divisible by 3? A. 1/4 B. 1/3 C. 1/2 D. 2/3 E. 3/4
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
Don't give up on yourself ever. Period. Beat it, no one wants to be defeated (My journey from 570 to 690) : http://gmatclub.com/forum/beatitnoonewantstobedefeatedjourney570to149968.html




SVP
Status: Top MBA Admissions Consultant
Joined: 24 Jul 2011
Posts: 2052

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Dec 2012, 19:34
From the given statements, we can conclude that y is prime. Therefore xy will be divisible by 3 if x is divisible by 3. Number of multiples of x between 10 and 21 inclusive = 4 Therefore probability = 4/12 = 1/3 Option B
_________________
GyanOne [www.gyanone.com] Premium MBA and MiM Admissions Consulting
Awesome Work  Honest Advise  Outstanding Results Reach Out, Lets chat!Email: info at gyanone dot com  +91 98998 31738  Skype: gyanone.services




Manager
Status: Never ever give up on yourself.Period.
Joined: 23 Aug 2012
Posts: 129
Location: India
Concentration: Finance, Human Resources
GMAT 1: 570 Q47 V21 GMAT 2: 690 Q50 V33
GPA: 3.5
WE: Information Technology (Investment Banking)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Jan 2013, 04:28
If y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y, then y must be prime. Let's look at a few examples to see why this is true: 6 has a factor 2 such that 1 < 2 < 6: 6 is NOT prime 15 has a factor 5 such that 1 < 5 < 15: 15 is NOT prime 3 has NO factor between 1 and 3: 3 IS prime 7 has NO factor between 1 and 7: 7 IS prime Because it is selected from Set B, y is a prime number between 10 and 50, inclusive. The only prime number that is divisible by 3 is 3, so y is definitely not divisible by 3. Thus, xy is only divisible by 3 if x itself is divisible by 3. We can rephrase the question: “What is the probability that a multiple of 3 will be chosen randomly from Set A?” There are 21 – 10 + 1 = 12 terms in Set A. Of these, 4 terms (12, 15, 18, and 21) are divisible by 3 Thus, the probability that x is divisible by 3 is 4/12 = 1/3. The correct answer is B. (Source : Manhattan GMAT Advanced Quant Guide)
_________________
Don't give up on yourself ever. Period. Beat it, no one wants to be defeated (My journey from 570 to 690) : http://gmatclub.com/forum/beatitnoonewantstobedefeatedjourney570to149968.html




Intern
Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 17

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Jan 2013, 13:52
GyanOne wrote: From the given statements, we can conclude that y is prime. Therefore xy will be divisible by 3 if x is divisible by 3. Number of multiples of x between 10 and 21 inclusive = 4
Therefore probability = 4/12 = 1/3
Option B we need to discuss a little bit here. I agree that y is prime. However y is also chosen, so the probability for a prime number chosen is 13/41. And the probability for x divisible by 3 is 4/12 So the result is (13/41)*(4/12). Please correct me if I'm wrong, thanks



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Jan 2013, 21:37
akhandamandala wrote: GyanOne wrote: From the given statements, we can conclude that y is prime. Therefore xy will be divisible by 3 if x is divisible by 3. Number of multiples of x between 10 and 21 inclusive = 4
Therefore probability = 4/12 = 1/3
Option B we need to discuss a little bit here. I agree that y is prime. However y is also chosen, so the probability for a prime number chosen is 13/41. And the probability for x divisible by 3 is 4/12 So the result is (13/41)*(4/12). Please correct me if I'm wrong, thanks We do not have to worry about choosing y. We are already given that y is prime. So no matter what number we choose as y, we still have to only find out the probability for choosing x. If otherwise, the question had asked for the number of ways in which xy would be divisible by 3, then the number of ways in which y could be selected would have to have been considered.



Director
Status: Been a long time guys...
Joined: 03 Feb 2011
Posts: 964
Location: United States (NY)
Concentration: Finance, Marketing
GPA: 3.75

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Jan 2013, 21:58
Would it have been complex if it were given that B consists of all prime numbers from 1 to 50, inclusive? Will it be \(1/3 + 1/15\) then?
_________________



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 01:56
Marcab wrote: Would it have been complex if it were given that B consists of all prime numbers from 1 to 50, inclusive? Will it be \(1/3 + 1/15\) then? Is that not what the question is already effectively asking??



Director
Status: Been a long time guys...
Joined: 03 Feb 2011
Posts: 964
Location: United States (NY)
Concentration: Finance, Marketing
GPA: 3.75

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 02:21
The question says that B consists of all integers from 10 to 50, inclusive.
_________________



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 02:28
Marcab wrote: The question says that B consists of all integers from 10 to 50, inclusive. True.. But the options to choose Y is essentially a set of prime numbers between 10 and 50...



Director
Status: Been a long time guys...
Joined: 03 Feb 2011
Posts: 964
Location: United States (NY)
Concentration: Finance, Marketing
GPA: 3.75

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 02:49
MacFauz wrote: Marcab wrote: The question says that B consists of all integers from 10 to 50, inclusive. True.. But the options to choose Y is essentially a set of prime numbers between 10 and 50... I agree that indirectly it is stating that B consists of prime numbers from 10 to 50, but my query was rather different. Suppose, if it were given that B consists of all prime numbers from 1 to 50 rather than 10 to 50, then what will be the answer. I hope, I am being clear this time.
_________________



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 02 Jan 2013, 03:38
Marcab wrote: MacFauz wrote: Marcab wrote: The question says that B consists of all integers from 10 to 50, inclusive. True.. But the options to choose Y is essentially a set of prime numbers between 10 and 50... I agree that indirectly it is stating that B consists of prime numbers from 10 to 50, but my query was rather different. Suppose, if it were given that B consists of all prime numbers from 1 to 50 rather than 10 to 50, then what will be the answer. I hope, I am being clear this time. Oh.. Sorry. I read that as 10 to 50 again... I'm not very sure. But let me give it a try edit: If it is 1 to 50, For required outcome : y is 3 and x is any number or y is not 3 and x is a multiple of 3 \(\frac{1}{15} * 1 + \frac{14}{15} * \frac{4}{12}\) \(= \frac{12}{15*12} + \frac{14*4}{15*12}\) \(= \frac{68}{180} = \frac{17}{45}\) A very ugly answer and lots of calculator work.. There should be an easier more correct way..
Originally posted by MacFauz on 02 Jan 2013, 03:22.
Last edited by MacFauz on 02 Jan 2013, 03:38, edited 1 time in total.



Intern
Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 17

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 03:33
MacFauz wrote: akhandamandala wrote: GyanOne wrote: From the given statements, we can conclude that y is prime. Therefore xy will be divisible by 3 if x is divisible by 3. Number of multiples of x between 10 and 21 inclusive = 4
Therefore probability = 4/12 = 1/3
Option B we need to discuss a little bit here. I agree that y is prime. However y is also chosen, so the probability for a prime number chosen is 13/41. And the probability for x divisible by 3 is 4/12 So the result is (13/41)*(4/12). Please correct me if I'm wrong, thanks We do not have to worry about choosing y. We are already given that y is prime. So no matter what number we choose as y, we still have to only find out the probability for choosing x. If otherwise, the question had asked for the number of ways in which xy would be divisible by 3, then the number of ways in which y could be selected would have to have been considered. Thanks for your reply. I would like to defend my idea: "Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive" means set B will contain prime and nonprime numbers "If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A" means x is chosen randomly from set A without limitation condition "y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, and y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y" means y is also chosen like x but with condition. So y is not a given number, y must be chosen from set B and satisfy the condition "has no factor z such that 1 < z < y". Now take a look from another view: "Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclusive. Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive. If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A, y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, what is the probability that the product xy is divisible by 3?" The condition for y in this version is removed, so what is your idea in this case ???



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 03:51
akhandamandala wrote: MacFauz wrote: akhandamandala wrote: From the given statements, we can conclude that y is prime. Therefore xy will be divisible by 3 if x is divisible by 3. Number of multiples of x between 10 and 21 inclusive = 4
Therefore probability = 4/12 = 1/3
Option B we need to discuss a little bit here. I agree that y is prime. However y is also chosen, so the probability for a prime number chosen is 13/41. And the probability for x divisible by 3 is 4/12 So the result is (13/41)*(4/12). Please correct me if I'm wrong, thanks We do not have to worry about choosing y. We are already given that y is prime. So no matter what number we choose as y, we still have to only find out the probability for choosing x. If otherwise, the question had asked for the number of ways in which xy would be divisible by 3, then the number of ways in which y could be selected would have to have been considered. Thanks for your reply. I would like to defend my idea: "Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive" means set B will contain prime and nonprime numbers "If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A" means x is chosen randomly from set A without limitation condition "y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, and y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y" means y is also chosen like x but with condition. So y is not a given number, y must be chosen from set B and satisfy the condition "has no factor z such that 1 < z < y". Now take a look from another view: "Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclusive. Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive. If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A, y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, what is the probability that the product xy is divisible by 3?" The condition for y in this version is removed, so what is your idea in this case ??? In such a case, there are 13 ways in which y can be selected to be a multiple of 3 and 28 ways in which y can be selected to not be a multiple of 3. \(\frac{13}{41} * 1 + \frac{28}{41}* \frac{4}{12}\) \(= \frac{67}{123}\) i believe the fact the y is a prime number greater than 10 given in the original question is significant because it clearly says that y CANNOT be a multiple of 3.



Intern
Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 17

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 04:18
MacFauz wrote: akhandamandala wrote: MacFauz wrote: we need to discuss a little bit here.
I agree that y is prime. However y is also chosen, so the probability for a prime number chosen is 13/41. And the probability for x divisible by 3 is 4/12 So the result is (13/41)*(4/12).
Please correct me if I'm wrong, thanks We do not have to worry about choosing y. We are already given that y is prime. So no matter what number we choose as y, we still have to only find out the probability for choosing x. If otherwise, the question had asked for the number of ways in which xy would be divisible by 3, then the number of ways in which y could be selected would have to have been considered. Thanks for your reply. I would like to defend my idea: "Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive" means set B will contain prime and nonprime numbers "If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A" means x is chosen randomly from set A without limitation condition "y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, and y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y" means y is also chosen like x but with condition. So y is not a given number, y must be chosen from set B and satisfy the condition "has no factor z such that 1 < z < y". Now take a look from another view: "Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclusive. Set B consists of all the integers between 10 and 50, inclusive. If x is a number chosen randomly from Set A, y is a number chosen randomly from Set B, what is the probability that the product xy is divisible by 3?" The condition for y in this version is removed, so what is your idea in this case ??? In such a case, there are 13 ways in which y can be selected to be a multiple of 3 and 28 ways in which y can be selected to not be a multiple of 3. \(\frac{13}{41} * 1 + \frac{28}{41}* \frac{4}{12}\) \(= \frac{67}{123}\) i believe the fact the y is a prime number greater than 10 given in the original question is significant because it clearly says that y CANNOT be a multiple of 3. That's very good. We step by step go to the mutual agreement that "y is a number chosen randomly from Set B" means there are various ways in which y is chosen; so y may be a prime or may be a nonprime number. What is the probability that y will be a prime number?



Director
Status: Been a long time guys...
Joined: 03 Feb 2011
Posts: 964
Location: United States (NY)
Concentration: Finance, Marketing
GPA: 3.75

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 04:42
Quote: For required outcome : y is 3 and x is any number or y is not 3 and x is a multiple of 3 MacFauz why have you neglected the 3 in the other one? Can't we take any number just as it was done earlier?
_________________



VP
Joined: 02 Jul 2012
Posts: 1091
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy
GPA: 3.8
WE: Engineering (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Jan 2013, 20:44
@akhandamandala : I believe that in the original question, it is given that "y" is a prime number. So, the probability that y will be prime is 100%.
@Marcab : I have already considered a situation where y is 3 and x is a multiple of 3 in the first scenario. Hence, in the second scenario, I am considering only a situation where y is not a multiple of 3 and x is a multiple of 3. If in the second case, "y" is not 3 and "x" is also not a multiple of 3, then the product would not be divisible by 3.



Intern
Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 17

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Jan 2013, 02:53
Set B does not contains prime numbers only, that's the set of ALL integers from 10 to 50, and there are 11 (not 13 as aforementioned) prime numbers in the range [10, 50]. In the other hand, y is chosen RANDOMLY from the set B, and y is prime; so P(y is prime) = 1 is not persuasive.
I posted the original quiz on facebook (without the multiple choices), there's a reply with the idea that the probability for y is prime is <1. So far my idea does not stand alone. Why don't you make a survey in which you post this original quiz (omit the multiple choices) on your facebook or blog?



Intern
Joined: 17 Nov 2012
Posts: 17

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Jan 2013, 13:04
I think this question is very controversial. There would be significant amount of people understand that y is chosen randomly in order to satisfy the condition y is prime, not that y is given as a prime.



Manager
Joined: 25 Feb 2014
Posts: 205

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Mar 2014, 20:23
y has no factor z such that 1 < z < y this means that y is a prime and it has to lie between 10 and 50 inclusive. Now, since the product of xy is divisible by 3 so that means that we have to look for multiples of 3 in set A since primes from set B are all greater than 3. Set B has 12 elements and out of which 4 are multiples of 3 so probability should be 4/12 = 1/3.
Consider giving kudos if my post helped.



Intern
Joined: 10 May 2013
Posts: 6

Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Sep 2015, 10:43
I'm little bit confused here. The way GyanOne provided is pretty logical and I like it but I have a conundrum with more choosey approach. In Set A we have 12 integers, these ones divisble by 3  12, 15,18, 21  4 numbers In set B we have 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47  11 prime numbers prob of xy divisible by 3 = (xy's divisble by 3)/(total possible xy's) xy's divisible by 3= 11x4=44 total possible xy's= 11x124=128, I deduct 4 to avoid double counting of 11, 13, 17,19 as these appear in both sets so, I have 44/128=11/32, slightly more that 1/3. please, tell me where am I wrong here.




Re: Set A consists of all the integers between 10 and 21, inclus
[#permalink]
21 Sep 2015, 10:43



Go to page
1 2
Next
[ 31 posts ]

