Bunuel wrote:
The Urban Apartment Towers complex has seen a number of police visits to the property recently, resulting in the police breaking up loud parties held by young residents and attended by other young people. These circumstances are hurting the complex’s reputation and ability to attract new residents. To reduce the number of police visits and improve profitability, management plans to advertise its vacant apartments in a local publication for people aged 50 and up.
Which of the following, if true, would cast the most doubt regarding the effectiveness of the management’s plan?
(A) No recent police visits to Urban Apartment Towers have been to the apartments of residents over the age of 50.
(B) A substantially cheaper apartment complex may be built in a neighboring town.
(C) Residents over the age of 50 are more likely to call police in circumstances in which young people would not call.
(D) A nearby condominium complex of similar size had far fewer police visits last year than Urban Apartment Towers.
(E) People over 50 are much more likely than young people to host parties with fewer than 10 guests.
Argument
Management wants to reduce police visits and improve profitabiilty. So, they want to rent vacant apartments to old people. They feel that these people will not host loud parties and so police will visit less. But what about young people who are already there and host parties.
Question type
Find the weakness
(A) No recent police visits to Urban Apartment Towers have been to the apartments of residents over the age of 50. --> thats good but what about visits to those young people who already live there. Also, what about old visits. -->Incorrect
(B) A substantially cheaper apartment complex may be built in a neighboring town. --> that infact doesnot address the issue of management of reducing police visit --> OUT OF SCOPE --->Incorrect
(C) Residents over the age of 50 are more likely to call police in circumstances in which young people would not call. --> So, if more old people will live there, more police will be called. It will hurt the reputation more. --> CORRECT
(D) A nearby condominium complex of similar size had far fewer police visits last year than Urban Apartment Towers. --> that doesnt help _> OUT of scope -->Incorrect
(E) People over 50 are much more likely than young people to host parties with fewer than 10 guests. --> seems promising, but will they host loud parties in under 10 guest. How much energy old people will have? --> C is better -->Incorrect