Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 07 Feb 2010
Posts: 110

A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Nov 2010, 05:43
Question Stats:
60% (02:14) correct 40% (02:24) wrong based on 903 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white? (1) \(\frac{r}{b+w} > \frac{w}{b+r}\) (2) \(bw > r\) Attachment:
Marbles.JPG [ 64.66 KiB  Viewed 2631 times ]
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64153

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Nov 2010, 05:52
anilnandyala wrote: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white?
(1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) (2) bw > r The question is \(\frac{R}{R+B+W}>\frac{W}{R+B+W}\) true? Or is \(R>W\) true? (1) \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{R}{B+W} +1> \frac{W}{B+R}+1\) > \(\frac{R+B+W}{B+W}> \frac{W+B+R}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{1}{B+W}> \frac{1}{B+R}\) > \(B+R>B+W\) > \(R>W\). Sufficient. OR:Given: \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > Cross multiply, we can safely do this as \(B+W\) and \(B+R\) are more than zero. We'll get \(R(B+R)>W(B+W)\) > \(RB+R^2>WB+W^2\) > \((R^2W^2)+(RBWB)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W)+B(RW)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W+B)>0\). As \(R+W+B>0\), the above inequality to hold true \(RW\) must also be more than zero, so \(RW>0\) > \(R>W\). (2) \(BW>R\), not sufficient to determine whether \(R>W\) or not. Answer: A.
_________________




Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 10485
Location: Pune, India

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Nov 2010, 11:40
anilnandyala wrote: a certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles & r red marbles. if one marble is to be chosen random from jar is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability the marble chosen is white? a) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) b) bw > r The probability that red marble is chosen will be greater than the probability that white marble is chosen if there are more red marbles than white marbles. So the queestion is just: Is r > w Statement 1: r/(b + w) > w/(b + r) Cross multiply to get r(b + r) > w(b + w) .... [(b + w) and (b + r) are definitely positive so cross multiplying is not a problem.] Now, if r > w, (b + r) has to be greater than (b + w) If r were less than w, then (b + r) < (b + w) and the left side would have been smaller than the right side. So this implies that r must be greater than w. Sufficient. Statement 2: b > r + w But we cant compare r and w so not sufficient. Answer (A).
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Senior Manager
Joined: 08 Nov 2010
Posts: 259
WE 1: Business Development

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Nov 2010, 22:55
VeritasPrepKarishma and Bunuel  thanks a lot for ur explanations.
+1 from me... again.
keep up the good job.



Manager
Status: what we want to do, do it as soon as possible
Joined: 24 May 2010
Posts: 56
Location: Vietnam
WE 1: 5.0

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Nov 2010, 22:36
Bunuel wrote: anilnandyala wrote: a certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles & r red marbles. if one marble is to be chosen random from jar is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability the marble chosen is white? a) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) b) bw > r (1) \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{R}{B+W} +1> \frac{W}{B+R}+1\) > \(\frac{R+B+W}{B+W}> \frac{W+B+R}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{1}{B+W}> \frac{1}{B+R}\) > \(B+R>B+W\) > \(R>W\). Sufficient. OR:Given: \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > Cross multiply, we can safely do this as \(B+W\) and \(B+R\) are more then zero. Answer: A. awesome explanation. I have translated the question to is r>w but did not know how to solve the (1). Now get it clear



Manager
Joined: 05 Nov 2012
Posts: 133

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Dec 2013, 10:17
Given 8 red marbles and y white marbles. Number of ways you can pick any two marbles is \((8+Y)C2\). Ways of picking 2 red marbles is 8*7 (first time you can pick out of 8 red marbles and second time you can pick one of the remaining 7 marbles). Ways of picking 1 marble of each color. This can happen in 2 ways. 1 way) First pick white and second pick red [y*8 ways] or 2 way) first pick red and second pick white [8*y ways]. So total number of ways to pick two different colors will be \(y*8 + 8*y\) = \(2*8y\)
A jar contains 8 red marbles and y white marbles. If Joan takes 2 random marbles from the jar, is it more likely that she will have 2 red marbles than that she will have one marble of each color?
Question is asking for  is probability of picking 2 red marbles > probability of picking different color marbles, is \(\frac{8*7}{(8+Y)C2} > \frac{2*8y}{(8+Y)C2}\) Therefore, \(y<7/2=3.5\)
(1) y ≤ 8 y can be less than or greater than 3.5  NS (2) y ≥ 4 y is always greater than 3.5  S
So B



VP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1494
Concentration: Finance

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Jan 2014, 05:31
anilnandyala wrote: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white?
(1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) (2) bw > r Is r>w? r/(b+w)>w(b+r) rb + r^2 ? wb + w^2 (r+w)(rw) > b(wr) Now if rw>0 then wr < 0 and inequality holds true. Other way around if rw<0, LHS is negative and RHS is positive and inequality does NOT hold true So only valid scenario is rw>0 and thus r>w Sufficient (B) Not enough Info Answer is A Cheers J PS. Alternatively, first statement can be treated as rw / b+r>0 Well b+r is always positive, thus rw has to be positive too Then r>w



GMAT Tutor
Joined: 24 Jun 2008
Posts: 2100

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Jun 2015, 23:25
I like this problem because there are at least five different ways to solve it. I'll mention a more conceptual solution since no one has mentioned it yet, but there are some great solutions above as well: If you know the concept of "odds" that is used in daily life, you can answer this question very quickly. "Odds" are just ratios of good outcomes to bad outcomes, while probabilities are ratios of good outcomes to total outcomes (good+bad). So when we say the odds that something will happen are 2 to 1, that means there's a 2/3 probability it will happen, and a 1/3 probability it will not. In this question, the fraction r/(b+w) is just the ratio of red marbles to other marbles, so it just represents the odds of picking a red marble. Similarly the fraction w/(b+r) is the ratio of white marbles to other marbles, so it represents the odds of picking a white marble. And if the odds of getting red are better than the odds of getting white, the probability of getting red must be higher than the probability of getting white, so S1 is sufficient.
_________________
GMAT Tutor in Montreal
If you are looking for online GMAT math tutoring, or if you are interested in buying my advanced Quant books and problem sets, please contact me at ianstewartgmat at gmail.com



GMAT Club Legend
Joined: 11 Sep 2015
Posts: 4879
Location: Canada

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Apr 2018, 10:12
anilnandyala wrote: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white?
(1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) (2) bw > r Target question: Is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater than the probability that the marble chosen will be white? We can rephrase the target question as... REPHRASED target question: Is r > w? Statement 1: r/(b + w) > w/(b + r) Let's let T = the TOTAL number of marbles in the jar. This means that b + w + r = T This also means that b + w = T  r And it means that b + r = T  w So, we can take statement 1, r/(b + w) > w/(b + r), and rewrite it as... r/(T  r) > w/(T  w) Multiply both sides by (T  r) to get: r > w(T  r)/(T  w) Multiply both sides by (T  w) to get: r(T  w) > w(T  r) Expand both sides: rT  rw > wT  rw Add rw to both sides: rT > wT Divide both sides by T to get: r > w Since we can answer the REPHRASED target question with certainty, statement 1 is SUFFICIENT Statement 2: b  w > r Add w to both sides to get: b > w + r All this means is that there are more black marbles than there are white and red marbles combined. Given this information, there's no way to determine whether or not r is greater than w Since we cannot answer the REPHRASED target question with certainty, statement 2 is NOT SUFFICIENT Answer: A Cheers, Brent
_________________
Test confidently with gmatprepnow.com



Manager
Status: wake up with a purpose
Joined: 24 Feb 2017
Posts: 195
Concentration: Accounting, Entrepreneurship

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Aug 2019, 09:58
Bunuel wrote: anilnandyala wrote: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white?
(1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) (2) bw > r The question is \(\frac{R}{R+B+W}>\frac{W}{R+B+W}\) true? Or is \(R>W\) true? (1) \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{R}{B+W} +1> \frac{W}{B+R}+1\) > \(\frac{R+B+W}{B+W}> \frac{W+B+R}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{1}{B+W}> \frac{1}{B+R}\) > \(B+R>B+W\) > \(R>W\). Sufficient. OR:Given: \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > Cross multiply, we can safely do this as \(B+W\) and \(B+R\) are more than zero. We'll get \(R(B+R)>W(B+W)\) > \(RB+R^2>WB+W^2\) > \((R^2W^2)+(RBWB)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W)+B(RW)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W+B)>0\). As \(R+W+B>0\), the above inequality to hold true \(RW\) must also be more than zero, so \(RW>0\) > \(R>W\).(2) \(BW>R\), not sufficient to determine whether \(R>W\) or not. Answer: A. I don't understand the highlighted part. Would you please explain it in simple words? BunuelPosted from my mobile device
_________________
If people are NOT laughing at your GOALS, your goals are SMALL.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64153

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Aug 2019, 19:42
RashedVai wrote: Bunuel wrote: anilnandyala wrote: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red marbles. If one marble is to be chosen at random from the jar, is the probability that the marble chosen will be red greater then the probability that the marble chosen will be white?
(1) r/(b+w) > w/(b+r) (2) bw > r The question is \(\frac{R}{R+B+W}>\frac{W}{R+B+W}\) true? Or is \(R>W\) true? (1) \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{R}{B+W} +1> \frac{W}{B+R}+1\) > \(\frac{R+B+W}{B+W}> \frac{W+B+R}{B+R}\) > \(\frac{1}{B+W}> \frac{1}{B+R}\) > \(B+R>B+W\) > \(R>W\). Sufficient. OR:Given: \(\frac{R}{B+W} > \frac{W}{B+R}\) > Cross multiply, we can safely do this as \(B+W\) and \(B+R\) are more than zero. We'll get \(R(B+R)>W(B+W)\) > \(RB+R^2>WB+W^2\) > \((R^2W^2)+(RBWB)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W)+B(RW)>0\) > \((RW)(R+W+B)>0\). As \(R+W+B>0\), the above inequality to hold true \(RW\) must also be more than zero, so \(RW>0\) > \(R>W\).(2) \(BW>R\), not sufficient to determine whether \(R>W\) or not. Answer: A. I don't understand the highlighted part. Would you please explain it in simple words? BunuelPosted from my mobile deviceWe have \((RW)(R+W+B)>0\). The product of two multiples, (RW) and (R+W+B), to be positive they must have the same sign. Since, the second multiple, R+W+B, is positive, then the first multiple, RW, mut also be positive: R  W > 0.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 11 Jun 2019
Posts: 25

Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 May 2020, 12:51
Bunuel  please could you explain the simplification for (1) again?




Re: A certain jar contains only b black marbles, w white marbles and r red
[#permalink]
15 May 2020, 12:51




