"Best" admission consulting companies?

I went through this process last year and I chose Betsy Massar from Master Admissions. Before I go further, I got accepted to a top 10 MBA program, and I got a small scholarship. I am very pleased with the result.

My criteria included four things: (1) Price/Affordability (2) Experience (3) Personal Connection (4) Style.
• I knew that I wanted to apply to three to four MBA programs (this helped me determine the total cost)
• I knew I wanted to work with someone who gets me. Or who had a process in place that would build a personal connection between us (consultant and I).
• I knew I wanted someone who was experienced, well connected and had the core competencies to help me prepare an amazing application.

My experience with Betsy Massar was great. I won’t list her qualification, you can see that on her website.
Two ways Betsy helped me:
1. Betsy helped me find my story. Like many MBA candidates I am a career switcher so demonstrating why I want to do an MBA and getting to the core message was difficult and took a lot of time. Betsy helped me bring it out through phone conversations and continuous feedback on my writing. This was an extremely frustrating process for me but somehow Betsy knew to dig deeper and she challenged me through every conversation and through every piece of writing I submitted to her. Eventually I made a real connection with my story and why I wanted to pursue an MBA at this stage in my life. Betsy’s process not only helped me with essays but it also helped me develop a concrete plan for my career.
2. Show, don’t tell. Betsy coached me through the process of defining the reasons I wanted to switch careers from Finance to Social Entrepreneurship in Education by helping me connect my story and all my experiences to my plans. This translated to me giving concrete examples of things I had done and it helped me create a realistic plans for my MBA. It allowed me to show the admission committee who I am, show them what I have done, and show them what I plan to do. When I started my applications, most of my writing was telling and not showing. It took me some time to understand how to show, not tell. And Betsy played a key role in getting me there.

If you are looking for a consultant that will write everything for you, Betsy is not for you. If you are willing to work hard, are open to getting challenged, and willing to work with Betsy to develop your application, she is the right consultant for you. Betsy is very nice and caring. But she keeps it real and is very honest. It’s a quality I learned to appreciate by the end of my application process. She catered to my style, gave me the personal attention that I needed, and helped me get into a great MBA program.

I have read all the posts on this forum and there are mixed reviews about most of the admission consulting companies. Can someone share their experience working with any consultant specifically in FINANCE at mbaMission. Please share your views about their 1) eagerness to learn about the client (intensive brainstorming sessions?) and 2) availability/time commitment as deadlines approach. I heard all their consultants work full-time but I am not sure how loaded they are during this peak season as compared to those who are working part-time ?

I wanted to share my experience working with an MBA admissions consultant for my INSEAD application. Sorry for the long post but I wanted to help users of this forum as I have benefitted a lot being part of GC during my MBA journey.

Let me begin with my background. I belong to the most competitive pool of MBA applicants - Indian/IT/M with an average GMAT. When I began planning for INSEAD, I knew that I wanted professional help to submit a strong application given the shortcomings in my profile. I talked to 3 admission consultants here in the US but did not feel the connection or confidence. There was hardly any difference in the conversations, questions and feedback that these 3 consultants provided. I won’t name them as I have not taken their services.

I decided to work with Laura Freedman from Access Education in Singapore (www.Accesseducation.com.sg). My experience with Laura was totally different right from the first Skype session that we had. Working with her was one of the best decisions that I made.

Some of the strengths that I found while working with Laura:
- Laura has an “Insider’s view” on everything INSEAD. She is an INSEAD alum who has worked with the admissions office interviewing candidates and promoting the school, has coached applicants since the '90's and advises current students as a counselor at INSEAD Career Services in Singapore. She's also held INSEAD alumni association board roles in the US, Russia and Singapore (she even helped launch Blue Ocean Strategy in the US!). This vast experience was evident in the inputs that she provided while developing my story, editing the essays and preparing for the interviews. She was able to highlight aspects of my life that I would never have thought as important.

- Laura's career experience was tremendously helpful in helping me articulate my career goals (I'm targeting consulting). She's worked for over 20 years in different industries and functions, including two top-tier consultancies and two global financial institutions, and has lived all over the world. She had a lot of insight into my professional background and how my experience would let me have the biggest impact, and great practical advice about how to get where I'm looking to go.

- Another aspect of working with Laura that I highly appreciate is the face time that you get with her. Unlike telephonic conversations with other admission consultants, I had Skype sessions with Laura where we worked on discussing my story, editing the essays and even had mock interviews (she was an INSEAD alumni interviewer for over 10 years). This provided a personalized touch to the entire process.

- I admire Laura’s direct approach. She can be blunt at times . However, it really worked for me in bringing out the best in my essays. After all, we need a guide who sees beyond the obvious and can provide constructive criticism.

- In spite of the time difference between the US and Singapore, Laura always made time and provided multiple options for scheduling the sessions.

- Laura's mock interview prep was spot on. It not only prepared me for interview surprises but also boosted my confidence immensely.

Despite the weaknesses in my profile, I still made it to INSEAD. I cannot thank Laura enough for the guidance and personalized attention that she provided to make this happen.

My advice to future MBA aspirants: If INSEAD is your dream school (just as it was mine), then do reach out to Laura Freedman. Her guidance will surely improve your chances, and you'll learn a lot about yourself in the process. Also, be part of GMATClub. This is a great community and folks here are really helpful.

Please feel free to PM me for any help.

I started my applications in november 2011 to apply for fall 2012. I was very confused how to go about it and by the end of the whole process i had '0' interview calls
With an IT background from india,i had one of the most common profiles. I straight away knew i needed an admission counselor to help me through my applications for fall 2013. I put in a lot of effort researching about the counselors. I made sure i call them and extract each and every detail out of them.

After a lot of research and calls i zeroed in on Experts Global. I had a word with their founder, Mayank Srivastava, and i was very impressed. Though i was still worried about the authenticity. My parents met these guys and were convinced, so i took the leap. They provide a guarantee statement offering refund with the applications package in which they assure you and admit in certain ranked schools with or without scholarship depending upon your profile.

I have not regretted my decision even for a second. From day one you feel a part of the process. They make you go through questionnaires. The questionnaires help you bring out information about yourself which you would have never used otherwise. After going through the questionnaires, we mutually decided on the 10 schools i would be applying to. I had a 700 GMAT and a little over 2 years of experience in the Indian IT industry, yet Mayank was pretty upbeat about my chances.
With all the guidance, my essays turned out perfect. I realized i could have never written such good essays without any help.

Mayank was always a phone call or an email away. He helped through out the process and made sure that i was equally involved so that the learning process is not hindered. They also provided me with guidelines for recommenders so that the recommendations turn out perfect. All my applications were crosschecked carefully and thoroughly before submitting. They helped me with interviews by conducting mock interviews. Even after my admits, they helped me in obtaining my I20 and visa.

My the end of my process I had 7 interview calls from the 10 i applied to and i converted 6 of them with scholarships. I agree that i applied in round one hence the chance for scholarships was more but i approached these guys in september 2012 and they still managed to push me through into round 1 applications.

I will be joining UIUC with a 50% scholarship and i would give credit to experts for their guidance.

I'd like to add that these guys operate with very high ethical standards so i would definitely recommend them to everyone.

Experts Global

I have been a silent member on this board for a while but wanted to share my positive experience with Amerasia to benefit others. If required, I can verify my identity with the moderators.

Background:
Technology (Engineering/non-IT) background, over-represented (Indian/Male), 5+ years of work experience with a technology firm in the US (in product development).

I used a top-named admissions consulting company the previous year with a lackluster experience and decided to give it another shot with Amerasia based on the positive reviews on this forum. As a re-application, I felt that I needed more help at honing in on my story and bringing out the essential aspects (which is where I missed the mark the first time around).

Initial Consultation:
After submitting my initial inquiry, Adam Hoff contacted me promptly and was happy to pair me up with one of their consultants - Alex, who has experience in branding and marketing - something that Adam explained might help me propel my application. While I had wanted to work with Adam or Paul, I was not decided if I wanted to do school packages or just work on a hourly basis or a combination of the two and because of this, Adam could not sign me up to work with him or Paul (as they usually work heavily with package clients).

Shortly after, I had an hour long conversation with Alex, who had gone through my profile in advance (important for me, as I feel other consultants usually review your profile when they are on the phone with you), gave me suggestions for my application and did not try to push me to sign up with him. Moreover, the conversation was not rushed and Alex was open to a follow up call even before I decided to proceed with Amerasia. After having done several initial consultations with many top named admissions consultants, this was the easiest conversation I have had. I suggest other candidates consider how easy it is to speak with a consultant (since you will be working with him/her for the next few months, and make sure to gauge if they will have time for you, can work well with you and will listen/help you through your concerns).

Application Help:
Since I knew most of the schools I wanted to apply to, the process was easier to start off with, but I did seek advise from Alex later on in the process on some additional schools, and he was able to give me a good insight into them.

Before starting on the essays, I filled up some questionnaires that were targeted at answering most of the MBA essay/interview questions, following which, I brainstormed with Alex to get my stories straight. This was a crucial step for me as this is where I believed I needed the most help. This step took a couple of phone conversations and continued evolving as the process continued. Most notably through this step was that Alex gave me his cell number and told me to text/call him whenever I had any question.

The method I followed to answer my essay questions was to type a few essay drafts, and then jump on the phone and discuss what to change/update with Alex. We set up a weekly call as that gave me time to complete a couple of drafts (and if the essays to review reduced, I would prepone the call). I loved the flexibility and ease of getting in touch with Alex. He would answer my emails/texts almost instantaneously and the ability to discuss the changes for the drafts over the phone made it easier to reduce any miscommunication and avoid any follow-up delays.

Interview Help:
I just did one mock interview. Alex gave me a list of questions and I did my own research to find other posted questions. This was a fairly normal process. Alex did give me misc. interview tips such as posture, what to do when nervous etc. which I found beneficial.

Results:
I got an interview call from 7 of the 8 schools I applied to (4 in top 10 and 4 in top 20) and was offered admission at 5 of those 8.

Final Thoughts:
My decision to use an admissions consultant was a personal one. However, I do believe I found a fit working with Alex and Amerasia. Yes, I was a little bummed that I could not work with Adam or Paul (especially since most of the glowing reviews for Amerasia highlight their names), however with my situation (mix of package/hourly), this was understandable.

The process of working with Alex, for me was more of one friend helping another rather than a business contract. I would like to emphasize the importance of fit and hence the initial consultation. If anyone has any specific questions, I can answer them through PM.

I just wanted to take a minute to fill you all in on my experience with SB. I wouldn’t take the time to do this unless I really felt positively about my experience. I signed up with the firm in 2012 and was paired with Esther Magna, my consultant. I knew from the beginning that I wanted to use a consultant to assist with my applications since my GPA was really low (<3.0).

I applied to three schools and hired SB for all of them. Esther was great!! I was genuinely worried about being accepted to any of them, but Esther really helped me identify the strong points of my background and experience, and ensure I consistently stressed those to the admissions committees. I know I can be overbearing with the frequency that I send emails, but Esther was fantastic (she may be more addicted to her Blackberry than I am!). I ALWAYS received a prompt reply with helpful feedback.

My background is not especially distinctive - white male, finance background, etc. - but with Esther’s help, I was able to craft an application strategy that stressed my attributes that I believe differentiated me from other applicants. She also had personal connections with former members of various admissions committees who reviewed my essays and critiqued them in advance – this was a huge help.

One last comment. Although the price of SB can be intimidating, as it was for me, hiring the firm turned out to be a great decision financially in the long run. I ended up receiving a scholarship for a full year’s tuition at a top 10 US MBA school. Clearly the expense of a consultant can be high, but it paid off for me big time with Esther.

Hi everyone,

I highly recommend Alice Van Harten from Menlo Coaching. I am not a regular poster because I took my GMAT 4.5 years ago back in China for my US graduate school application. After my graduate study and almost 3 years of work experiences in US, I thought of applying for MBA 1) to have a better career path 2) to relocate to California for personal reasons, and 3) I can still use the old GMAT score before it expires

I decided to hire a consultant since I was only targeting top schools, and English is my 2nd language so I was trying to avoid any silly mistakes on my essays. Alice is far beyond my expectation. I accidentally found this posting while I was looking for the consultants. I saw some good words about Alice and decided to give her a call, I mean, the first call was free anyway. After my first conversation with Alice, I pretty much decided that I will hire her, although I have called a couple other consultants as well. I decided to hire her because

1) I know I can trust her since our first call. Different from other consultant who recommended me to apply for 5+ schools, Alice advised me to apply three. I was surprised when she said I did not need to apply that many, because this meant less working hours and less $ for her (She charges by hours). I am glad that I found a consultant who was not doing this just for money. Later on when I started to know her, she mentioned teaching was her interests and I felt her sincere and genuine personality. She sincerely hopes me to succeed, and she enjoys teaching. The trust is so important when you hire a consultant, because you need to feel comfortable to talk about yourself, your stories and everything to them.

2) As I continuously worked with her, I felt lucky that I had her with me during the process. Besides her sincere and fun personality, she is SO knowledgeable and SO sharp! It is hard to imagine that I have only known her for a few months but I really felt that she has known me forever. She remembers a lot of things about me and she knows which stories should be put on the essay. Sometimes I don't even remember that I told her but she remembered and we put the story into a good essay.

3) Although I mentioned she is fun to work with, she is very direct as well. She knows what is the best for me and she very directly expresses herself. That is very good and very effective communication. In another word, sometimes I know she was "pushing" me, but her communication was so effective and she was so nice, so I did not feel "pushy" at all. I guess I am trying to say, although she has a very very nice personality, she helps me get things done on time as well. Every time she provided very clear timelines and homework for next steps and I really enjoyed that, because again, it is about trust. I know we are on the right track.

Because I have received a very good job offer from an IT Giant company at the silicon valley, I decided to stop the application and take that offer. I kinda felt bad because I know if I continue the process, I will see good results with Alice's help. That's why I am writing this posting here, because I enjoyed and learned a lot while working with Alice, I want to recommend her to everyone. As I mentioned, I am not a regular poster because I have taken my GMAT years ago. Any verification is welcomed.

Hi,

Has anyone worked recently with any of these two consultants ?

1) Alex Chu/mbaapply - awesome posts and general advice, but not able to find feedback in 2012 or 2013.
2) Fortuna Admissions - has several former adcom members on the team, very impressive but relatively new.

Pls PM me if you have any feedback.

I am still working with Laura but I second every word of this post...Regardless of the result, its just been an incredible journey as she has helped me appreciate things about me which I never thought of...Laura truly rocks!

Any feedback on Admit Advantage? It's been around for a few years and the founder (Kofi Kankam) posts here and on BTG. However, I can't find any reviews that seem impartial.

Also, wanted some feedback from those of you who found good consultants. When deciding between consultants, what did you find to be more useful:
1) A consultant who has a background similar to yours. The similarity would probably help in connecting with the consultant and for him/her to really understand where you are coming from and what you want to do
2) A consultant that has actual experience working as AdCom member. The advantage here would be the consultant would've seen what works and doesn't work for people with a profile such as yours.

Thanks in advance!

I reached out to the MBA Crystal Ball team to understand my position as an Indian applicant. Here are my thoughts on their services:

1. MAP process - The MBA MAP process is meticulously prepared and pushes candidates to think honestly to get the best out of the whole process.

2. MAP interview and follow up discussion - The discussions were very open without any sugar coating and ego-massaging aspects.

Like most folks, I started these processes with the aim to know my 'chances' at my target schools. However the team slowly guided me to think more holistically like what are my *real* post MBA goals and how my choices of schools stands in relation to it. To highlight one crucial aspect, I started the process with a rigid goal without thinking through few aspects such as the overall cost of an MBA and how long it would take me to payback my debts and what work is carried out in my target post-MBA companies.

Coming out of this process, my goals have a lot more meaning w.r.t to my background, target schools and I feel super-confident as an applicant to position myself to the admissions team and recruiters.

Not only that, I felt MBA crystal ball team conveyed the real message without imposing any time constraint on either the initial or final wrap up call. I don't think anyone else will provide such high quality service and be willing to answer all the questions that I had researched.

To add some more context, I had also utilized a one-school comprehensive package from a admission consulting firm in US (and payed more than a month's US salary) and feel the value that I got out of the MBA MAP was way more. I guess the MBA Crystal ball team understand and appreciate the Indian applicant's position much more than any American consulting firm can.

I will recommend MBA Crystal ball MAP service to anyone who wants to understand their profile better and not just their chances w.r.t to some randomly picked schools.

Real take away: Start early, know your position and how you come across to the admissions team, talk to the MBA MAP team with an open mind (your see-me-save-the-world goal will be torn apart if it doesn't have strong legs) and build your overall position.

Has anyone ever used mbaessayconsultant web site or Sandip ?This site has lots of great testimonial and very cheap price but I have never read any review of this site anywhere?

To those deliberating,
A year ago exactly I read these reviews and like you I considered if they were undercover advertisement letters, but after a year of work with Aringo, with better moments and worse, I promise you that Aringo can also help realize the dream for you. I personally was accepted to all the schools to which I applied and I attribute a great portion of this achievement to the support and help of the different Aringo staff.
A very intensive and not simple period awaits you, but with all my heart I can say that if you choose to work with Aringo you will extract your maximum potential - sometimes as much as you never dreamed you had.
Good luck to you all!

abc

Can you please share your details whether you were active on the Club with some other username earlier ?

What is the authenticity of your claim? You've created this account today just to post this message I think!!

I'm afraid it's NOT convincing

I availed the MAP service from MBACrystalBalldot com and I must say its totally worth it. Having worked with a leading admission consulting firm in US and paying them $2500 for two schools, the value I got from MAP service for about $400 is worth every penny and equally comparable in quality and commitment. If you are contemplating on whether to shell out huge sum for these services, I definitely recommend MCBfor a fraction of the cost.

Moreover the MAP service is something in my opinion you should do even before you start your MBA journey including preparation for GMAT, as the outcome of this service is going to reinforce your choice of MBA or it will de mystify the decision and save you a lot of time and stress. The service maps your profile to top schools and suggests how good are your chances of getting in to each of them. The service included two detailed phone consultations, evaluation of my profile and story pitch for the MBA adcom (goals, achievements and overall fit proposition etc) and concluded with a detailed personalized report that listed my chances of getting into top schools around the world and also feedback on the application strategy based on my inputs.