Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 50002

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Aug 2018, 23:42
Question Stats:
67% (01:29) correct 33% (00:53) wrong based on 281 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics



Director
Status: Learning stage
Joined: 01 Oct 2017
Posts: 892
WE: Supply Chain Management (Energy and Utilities)

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2018, 02:56
Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) Let company X's profit last year be p and company Y's profit be 'q' last year. Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. So X's profit this year=1.25p.(1) Question stem: \(profit_{X}>profit_{Y} ?\) (This year) St1: Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. Or,\(\frac{p}{q}=\frac{5}{2}\) (2) No data available on profit of company Y this year. So, we can't determine any relationship between profit of X and Y this year. Insufficient. St2:Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. So Y's profit this year=0.6q(3) from (1) and (3),This year, \(\frac{profit_{X}}{profit_{Y}}=\frac{1.25p}{0.6q}=\frac{1.25}{0.6}*(\frac{p}{q})\)(4) Since p and q are unknown. We can't determine the above relationship. Hence, insufficient. combining, from (2), we have the ratio of p/q . Hence we can substitute it in (4). Therefore, we can say which company has more profit this year. Sufficient. (C)
_________________
Regards,
PKN
Rise above the storm, you will find the sunshine



Intern
Joined: 18 Nov 2013
Posts: 37

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2018, 09:57
PKN wrote: Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) Let company X's profit last year be p and company Y's profit be 'q' last year. Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. So X's profit this year=1.25p.(1) Question stem: \(profit_{X}>profit_{Y} ?\) (This year) St1: Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. Or,\(\frac{p}{q}=\frac{5}{2}\) (2) No data available on profit of company Y this year. So, we can't determine any relationship between profit of X and Y this year. Insufficient. St2:Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. So Y's profit this year=0.6q(3) from (1) and (3),This year, \(\frac{profit_{X}}{profit_{Y}}=\frac{1.25p}{0.6q}=\frac{1.25}{0.6}*(\frac{p}{q})\)(4) Since p and q are unknown. We can't determine the above relationship. Hence, insufficient. combining, from (2), we have the ratio of p/q . Hence we can substitute it in (4). Therefore, we can say which company has more profit this year. Sufficient. (C) Why shouldn't it be A? Since the profit of Y/X is given as 5:2 and X profits increased by 25 %, doesn't it give a clue? Let us say X's profit is 200 and Y's profit is 500; the x profit will never go above 500.



Manager
Joined: 06 Nov 2016
Posts: 61
Location: Viet Nam
Concentration: Strategy, International Business
GPA: 3.54

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Aug 2018, 10:33
harish1986 wrote: PKN wrote: Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) Let company X's profit last year be p and company Y's profit be 'q' last year. Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. So X's profit this year=1.25p.(1) Question stem: \(profit_{X}>profit_{Y} ?\) (This year) St1: Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. Or,\(\frac{p}{q}=\frac{5}{2}\) (2) No data available on profit of company Y this year. So, we can't determine any relationship between profit of X and Y this year. Insufficient. St2:Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. So Y's profit this year=0.6q(3) from (1) and (3),This year, \(\frac{profit_{X}}{profit_{Y}}=\frac{1.25p}{0.6q}=\frac{1.25}{0.6}*(\frac{p}{q})\)(4) Since p and q are unknown. We can't determine the above relationship. Hence, insufficient. combining, from (2), we have the ratio of p/q . Hence we can substitute it in (4). Therefore, we can say which company has more profit this year. Sufficient. (C) Why shouldn't it be A? Since the profit of Y/X is given as 5:2 and X profits increased by 25 %, doesn't it give a clue? Let us say X's profit is 200 and Y's profit is 500; the x profit will never go above 500. We need to compare X's Profit this year and Y's Profit this year. Statement 1 give us info about the ratio of Y's Profit last year and X's Profit last year. As a result, we can compare X's Profit this year and Y's Profit last year. However, we do not know anything about Y's Profit this year, we cannot compare X's Profit this year and Y's Profit this year. > Statement 1 alone is not sufficient. Statement 2 give us the relationship between Y's Profit last year and Y's Profit this year. Nothing related to X's profit is mentioned > clearly not sufficient. (1) + (2) we have all relationships needed > Sufficient. X's profit this year = (5/4)* X's profit last year = (5/4) * (2/5) * Y's profit last year = (5/4) * (2/5) * (5/3) * Y's profit this year Answer : C. Hope it's clear.
_________________
（＾人＾）
GMATCLUB Search for tags
GMAC © Official Guides  The Master Directory + Links
Question Directory by Topic & Difficulty Problem Solving  Data Sufficiency  Sentence Correction  Critical Reasoning  Reading Comprehension
ONLINE FREE (FULL LENGTH) GMAT CAT (PRACTICE TESTS) LINK COLLECTION



Director
Joined: 09 Mar 2016
Posts: 940

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2018, 06:28
Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) niks18 here is my reasoning of problem x = 1.25 y = 0.60 ratio y to x = 5 : 2 last year ratio y to x = \(\frac{5y}{2+x}\) this year combining two statements together \(\frac{1.25}{0.60}\) = \(\frac{2+x}{5y}\) cross multiply (2+x)0.60 = 1.25(5y) is it correct equation ? if not where did I go wrong pls explain thanks! P.S. changed my solution 10 times



PS Forum Moderator
Joined: 25 Feb 2013
Posts: 1216
Location: India
GPA: 3.82

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
05 Aug 2018, 10:31
dave13 wrote: Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) niks18 here is my reasoning of problem x = 1.25 y = 0.60 ratio y to x = 5 : 2 last year ratio y to x = \(\frac{5y}{2+x}\) this year combining two statements together \(\frac{1.25}{0.60}\) = \(\frac{2+x}{5y}\) cross multiply (2+x)0.60 = 1.25(5y) is it correct equation ? if not where did I go wrong pls explain thanks! P.S. changed my solution 10 times Hi dave13I am not exactly sure, what you did there and how you got the highlighted part



Director
Joined: 09 Mar 2016
Posts: 940

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Aug 2018, 06:23
niks18 wrote: dave13 wrote: Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) niks18 here is my reasoning of problem x = 1.25 y = 0.60 ratio y to x = 5 : 2 last year ratio y to x = \(\frac{5y}{2+x}\) this year combining two statements together \(\frac{1.25}{0.60}\) = \(\frac{2+x}{5y}\) cross multiply (2+x)0.60 = 1.25(5y) is it correct equation ? if not where did I go wrong pls explain thanks! P.S. changed my solution 10 times Hi dave13I am not exactly sure, what you did there and how you got the highlighted part niks18 i am not sure what i did there either but let me explain it thanks for pointing out my mistake ok let write detailed solution which i dont think is correct but still x profits this year = 1.25 y profits this year = 0.60 let X be the number of profits of company X let Y be the number of profits of company Y If last year ratio of profits Y to X was 5 : 2 or \(\frac{5}{2}\) Then this Year ratio must be \(\frac{5 y}{2+x}\) Based on the above data i create an equation \(\frac{1.25}{0.60} = \frac{2+x}{5 y}\) cross multiply and now again i got stuck whats wrong with my solution how to get the value ? Hi pushpitkc , I think niks18 is on holiday maybe you can explain ? hi gmatbusters can you please bust this qustion for me ? i need correct detailed sulotion based on my wrong solution above



Senior DS Moderator
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 877
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Aug 2018, 08:41
Hi @dave13, I tried to explain the error, Please let me know if it is not clear. dave13 wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) here is my reasoning of problem x = 1.25 y = 0.60 ratio y to x = 5 : 2 last year ratio y to x = \(\frac{5y}{2+x}\) this year combining two statements together \(\frac{1.25}{0.60}\) = \(\frac{2+x}{5y}\) cross multiply (2+x)0.60 = 1.25(5y) is it correct equation ? if not where did I go wrong pls explain thanks! P.S. changed my solution 10 times [/quote] Hi dave13I am not exactly sure, what you did there and how you got the highlighted part[/quote] niks18 i am not sure what i did there either but let me explain it thanks for pointing out my mistake ok let write detailed solution which i dont think is correct but still x profits this year = 1.25 , y profits this year = 0.60 It is wrong, we cannot take x and y as you did, because it will be only possible if both x and y have equal profit =1.let X be the number of profits of company X last yearlet Y be the number of profits of company Y last yearIf last year ratio of profits Y to X (last year) was 5 : 2 or \(\frac{5}{2}\) Then this Year ratio must be \(\frac{5 y}{2+x}\) NOT VALID Based on the above data i create an equation
[m]\frac{1.25}{0.60} = \frac{2+x}{5 y}[/m] cross multiply and now again i got stuck whats wrong with my solution how to get the value ? Hi pushpitkc[/url] , I think niks18 is on holiday maybe you can explain ? hi gmatbusters[/url] can you please bust this qustion for me ? i need correct detailed sulotion based on my wrong solution above [/quote]
_________________
Win Tests/ Prep Courses Weekly Quant Quiz Contest SC: Confusable words All you need for Quant, GMAT PS Question Directory,GMAT DS Question Directory Error log/Key Concepts Combination Concept: Division into groups Question of the Day (QOTD) Free GMAT CATS



Senior DS Moderator
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 877
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Aug 2018, 08:50
dave13, please see this approach Let the profit of X last year = x Let the profit of Y last year = y This year , X profit = X'= 1.25x Y this year profit = Y' ? To find whether X'> Y' ? Statement 1 : \(\frac{y}{x}\)= \(\frac{5}{2}\) So y = 2.5x But Y' is not known, NOT SUFFICIENT.Statement 2: Y' = 0.6y But we don't know the relation between x and y , NOT SUFFICIENT.Combining Statement 1 & 2, We get Y this year profit = Y' = 0.6y = 0.6*2.5x = 1.5x Also from Question stem, X profit = X'= 1.25x So, X'< Y'SUFFICIENT answer CBunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170)
_________________
Win Tests/ Prep Courses Weekly Quant Quiz Contest SC: Confusable words All you need for Quant, GMAT PS Question Directory,GMAT DS Question Directory Error log/Key Concepts Combination Concept: Division into groups Question of the Day (QOTD) Free GMAT CATS



Director
Joined: 09 Mar 2016
Posts: 940

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Aug 2018, 09:02
gmatbusters wrote: dave13, please see this approach Let the profit of X last year = x Let the profit of Y last year = y This year , X profit = X'= 1.25x Y this year profit = Y' ? To find whether X'> Y' ? Statement 1 : \(\frac{y}{x}\)= \(\frac{5}{2}\) So y = 2.5x But X' is not known, NOT SUFFICIENT.Statement 2: Y' = 0.6y But we don't know the relation between x and y , NOT SUFFICIENT.Combining Statement 1 & 2, We get Y this year profit = Y' = 0.6y = 0.6*2.5x = 1.5x Also from Question stem, X profit = X'= 1.25x So, X'< Y'SUFFICIENT answer CBunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) hi gmatbusters many thanks for response and explanation: just one question how did you get this So y = 2.5x ? I understand that \(\frac{y}{x}\) = \(\frac{5}{2}\) but somehow cant undestand how you got y = 2.5x thank you!



Senior DS Moderator
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 877
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Aug 2018, 09:10
Your Query : I understand that \(\frac{y}{x}\) = \(\frac{5}{2}\) but somehow cant undestand how you got y = 2.5x Response : y/x = 5/2= 2.5, now multiply both sides by x , we get y = 2.5x. hope it is clear now. dave13 wrote: gmatbusters wrote: dave13, please see this approach Let the profit of X last year = x Let the profit of Y last year = y This year , X profit = X'= 1.25x Y this year profit = Y' ? To find whether X'> Y' ? Statement 1 : \(\frac{y}{x}\)= \(\frac{5}{2}\) So y = 2.5x But X' is not known, NOT SUFFICIENT.Statement 2: Y' = 0.6y But we don't know the relation between x and y , NOT SUFFICIENT.Combining Statement 1 & 2, We get Y this year profit = Y' = 0.6y = 0.6*2.5x = 1.5x Also from Question stem, X profit = X'= 1.25x So, X'< Y'SUFFICIENT answer CBunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) hi gmatbusters many thanks for response and explanation: just one question how did you get this So y = 2.5x ? I understand that \(\frac{y}{x}\) = \(\frac{5}{2}\) but somehow cant undestand how you got y = 2.5x thank you!
_________________
Win Tests/ Prep Courses Weekly Quant Quiz Contest SC: Confusable words All you need for Quant, GMAT PS Question Directory,GMAT DS Question Directory Error log/Key Concepts Combination Concept: Division into groups Question of the Day (QOTD) Free GMAT CATS



Senior DS Moderator
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 877
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
11 Aug 2018, 20:46
Replying to a PM, Yes we can solve this question by taking numbers. Aim: To find Whether X this year profit is greater than Y ? Let X last year profit = 100 X this year profit = 125 Aim reduces to: finding Y profit this yearSt1) Y last year profit = 5/2 times X last year profit = 250 But we have no idea of Y this year profit. So insufficient to answer. St2) Y profit dropped by 40% this year But we don't know Y profit last year, so insufficient to find Y profit this year. Combinin St1 & 2, We et Y last year profit = 0.6*Y last year profit = 0.6*250= 150 hence , We can answer that X this year profit is not greater than Y this year profit. SUFFICIENT, Answer C
_________________
Win Tests/ Prep Courses Weekly Quant Quiz Contest SC: Confusable words All you need for Quant, GMAT PS Question Directory,GMAT DS Question Directory Error log/Key Concepts Combination Concept: Division into groups Question of the Day (QOTD) Free GMAT CATS



Senior Manager
Joined: 19 Oct 2013
Posts: 301
Location: Kuwait
GPA: 3.2
WE: Engineering (Real Estate)

Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Oct 2018, 08:37
Bunuel wrote: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profits. Was the dollar amount of Company X's profits this year greater than the dollar amount of Company Y's? (1) Last year, the ratio of Company Y's profits to Company X's profits was 5:2. (2) Company Y experienced a 40% drop in profits from last year to this year. NEW question from GMAT® Quantitative Review 2019 (DS14170) x1 be for last year x2 be for this year x2 = x1 * 1.25 we want to know y2 > x2? Statement 1) tells us that y1 to x1 is 5a to 2a this is insufficient because I don't know how will the y2 change. Statement 2) tells us that y2 = 0.6 * y1 But I don't have any basis of comparison between x2 and y2 Statement (1) and (2) combined tells us that y2 = 5a * 6/10 = 3a and x2 = 2a * 1.25 = 5/4 * 2 = 5/2 = 2.5a 3a > 2.5a sufficient. Answer choice C




Re: Company X's profits this year increased by 25% over last year's profit &nbs
[#permalink]
18 Oct 2018, 08:37






