heidy333
hi GMATNinja
GMATNinjaI still don't understand E
Although the passage said that tax only the rich is an equitable way, the last sentence seems disagree with it. And I think in this way we can conclude an equitable way is to tax all the people instead of just the rich.
Posted from my mobile deviceIt's true that the tax didn't turn out to be as equitable as its proponents hoped -- it almost certainly DID cause economic hardship for the workers who lost their jobs.
Be careful about paraphrasing (E), though -- you've actually changed a key component of the answer choice. Perhaps, in some situations,
"an" equitable tax is one in which all people pay, as you've said. Unfortunately, (E) goes much further than this:
Quote:
(E) Taxes can be equitable only if their burden is evenly distributed over the entire population.
The "tax the rich" solution outlined in the passage didn't work out too well in this particular case. But can we conclude from this that the ONLY tax that is equitable is one that is evenly distributed over the entire population?
Nope, that goes way too far. Perhaps there are other ways of creating an equitable tax. And perhaps a tax that is
evenly distributed (e.g., a millionaire and a minimum wage worker would both pay the same amount) isn't that equitable either.
Looking at the exact language of (E), it's clear that this option isn't supported by the passage.
I hope that helps!