Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59561

Question Stats:
48% (03:27) correct 52% (03:12) wrong based on 202 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies? A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59561

Re M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Sep 2014, 00:26
Official Solution:Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C To find the total cost of copying 1,200 pages, we need to know: 1. How long it takes for an attendant to copy 1,200 pages on each copier. 2. How much it costs per job on each of the machines. Cost of Time: A \(\frac{1200}{12} = 100\) mins (exact) costs: $60 B \(\frac{1200}{7} = 170\) mins (approx) costs: $90 C \(\frac{1200}{19} = 63\) mins (approx) costs: $60 Price per Job: A \(1200*$0.08=$96\) B \(1200*$0.05=$60\) C \(1200*$0.11=$132\) Total cost including attendant's pay: A \(96+60 = 156\) B \(60+90 = 150\) C \(132+60 = 192\) The best choice is Copier B. Answer: B
_________________



Manager
Joined: 12 Sep 2010
Posts: 229
Concentration: Healthcare, General Management

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
21 Aug 2015, 13:01
amishra1 wrote: Hi Bunuel,
In this case...we figured out the costs associated with the individual printers, and that itself took some time. What about options D and E? are there some generalizations regarding the rate of 2 workers together such as: unless the rate of 2 workers together working together is more than double the rate of any of the individuals....they are better off working alone? would this be a fair generalization?
Thanks, You can eliminate D and E immediately because the question asks "which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?" This problem is not difficult to understand. However, you have to recognize that it will be very time consuming. Depending on where you are at on the test(in terms of the time you have left and your mental state), you might need to make a random guess among A, B, and C to move on.



Manager
Joined: 16 May 2019
Posts: 132

Bunuel wrote: Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?
A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C An alternative approach: First of all, let me say that I did not eliminate choices (D) and (E) right away. For all I knew, copiers A and B would complete the job at the same cost, or copiers A and C would, which would make choices (D) and (E) trick answers instead of obvious snares. With that said, I solved this one using the following method, a combination of number sense and logic (my favorite approach to Quant problems): 1) Figure out the cost per minute per copier  Copier A: 12 copies/minute * 8 cents/copy = 0.96, or 96 cents per minute Copier B: 7 copies/minute * 5 cents/copy = 0.35, or 35 cents per minute Copier C: 19 copies/minute * 11 cents/copy = (1.90 + 0.19), or 2.09 per minute 2) Figure out how long the job will take for each copier and convert to attendant hours  Copier A: 1,200 copies/(12 copies/minute) = 100 minutes, or 2 attendant hours, based on the problem setup Copier B: 1,200 copies/(7 copies/minute) ~ 171 minutes, or 3 attendant hours Copier C: 1,200 copies/(19 copies/minute) ~ 63 minutes, or 2 attendant hours Now, logic took over. Since Copier C had missed the 1hour mark and had to share 2hour space with Copier A, it would have to gain back those $30 on Copier A to be more costeffective. A few factors, when taken together in the following chain of reasoning, allowed me to rule out this possibility: 1) Copier C cost more than $1.00 per minute than Copier A (2.09 versus 0.96, respectively) for 63 minutes: 63 * $1.00 = $63.00 (as an estimate) 2) Copier A took only 37 minutes more than Copier C to complete the job: 37 * 0.96 < 63 Copier A had to be more costeffective than Copier C, then, even without working out all the numbers. I got rid of choices (C) and (E). Meanwhile, Copier B had hit the 3hour attendant mark, so it would also have to pull back $30 on Copier A to be more costeffective. I approached the numbers in a similar manner as before: 1) Copier A cost 96  35, or 61 cents more per minute than Copier B for 100 minutes: 100 * 0.61 = $61.00. (This removes the $30 deficit$61  $30 = $31 in favor of Copier B.) 2) Copier B took 71 minutes longer to complete the job than Copier A. 71 * 0.35 < 31. (Calculating tenths, or increments of 10 percent, is almost instantaneous, since each tenth simply slides the decimal one place to the left. Thus, 71 * 0.10 = 7.1, and even four of those (0.40) would be less than 31.) With choices (A) and (D) out of the way, only one choice, the answer, was left. (B) won out. I am posting this solution in case anyone else takes a similar approach to this problem or other tough problems like it. Do not discount the power of logic.  Andrew



Intern
Joined: 08 Jul 2015
Posts: 40
GPA: 3.8
WE: Project Management (Energy and Utilities)

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
26 May 2016, 02:48
chaitanyakankanaka wrote: Hi Bunnel,
I didnt get how yoy got $90 for 170min? can you please explain me to clear my doubt? chaitanyakankanaka: Every 60mins the attendant get $30, next min he'll get extra $30 (cost@60mins = $30, cost@61mins = 30 + 30 = $60) So, 170mins = 60m + 60m + 50m = 30 + 30 + 30 = $90.
_________________
[4.33] In the end, what would you gain from everlasting remembrance? Absolutely nothing. So what is left worth living for? This alone: justice in thought, goodness in action, speech that cannot deceive, and a disposition glad of whatever comes, welcoming it as necessary, as familiar, as flowing from the same source and fountain as yourself. (Marcus Aurelius)



Intern
Joined: 11 Jan 2013
Posts: 4

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
16 Jan 2015, 12:13
Hi Bunuel,
In this case...we figured out the costs associated with the individual printers, and that itself took some time. What about options D and E? are there some generalizations regarding the rate of 2 workers together such as: unless the rate of 2 workers together working together is more than double the rate of any of the individuals....they are better off working alone? would this be a fair generalization?
Thanks,



Intern
Joined: 01 Aug 2015
Posts: 2

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
20 Oct 2015, 03:09
Hi Bunnel,
I didnt get how yoy got $90 for 170min? can you please explain me to clear my doubt?



Senior Manager
Joined: 12 Aug 2015
Posts: 280
Concentration: General Management, Operations
GMAT 1: 640 Q40 V37 GMAT 2: 650 Q43 V36 GMAT 3: 600 Q47 V27
GPA: 3.3
WE: Management Consulting (Consulting)

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Nov 2015, 22:41
I don't get why this problem is 95% hard rated. "Alone" eliminates right away D and E. Machine C is way too slow and expensive so choice C out. You can spend a minute and calculate to rule out whether B or A however at short reasoning B looks preferable. Why? Because it is faster when the time matters  attendat gets paid for the time spent and every additional minute could count. Although B is more costly in terms of $/1 page  in time constraints I would bet on B without calculation and continue.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 26 Dec 2016
Posts: 18

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2017, 04:23
shasadou wrote: I don't get why this problem is 95% hard rated. "Alone" eliminates right away D and E. Machine C is way too slow and expensive so choice C out. You can spend a minute and calculate to rule out whether B or A however at short reasoning B looks preferable.
Why? Because it is faster when the time matters  attendat gets paid for the time spent and every additional minute could count. Although B is more costly in terms of $/1 page  in time constraints I would bet on B without calculation and continue. Why is Machine C way too slow ? I think it's the fastest one with 19 copies per minute ...



Intern
Joined: 22 Jan 2017
Posts: 30

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Sep 2017, 13:44
1200/19 is approximately 63 not approximately 61. Also, to be more GMAT like, it should be explicitly stated that rate units stay the same the whole time. Other than that, good question and one that really tests how quickly you can do arithmetic.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59561

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
01 Oct 2017, 04:53
grassmonkey wrote: 1200/19 is approximately 63 not approximately 61. Also, to be more GMAT like, it should be explicitly stated that rate units stay the same the whole time. Other than that, good question and one that really tests how quickly you can do arithmetic. _______________ Edited. Thank you.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 18 Jul 2018
Posts: 51
Location: United Arab Emirates

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Mar 2019, 06:37
Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?
A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C
To find the total cost of copying 1,200 pages, we need to know: 1. How long it takes for an attendant to copy 1,200 pages on each copier. 2. How much it costs per job on each of the machines. Cost of Time: A \(\frac{1200}{12} = 100\) mins (exact) costs: $60 B \(\frac{1200}{7} = 170\) mins (approx) costs: $90 C \(\frac{1200}{19} = 63\) mins (approx) costs: $60 Price per Job: A \(1200*$0.08=$96\) B \(1200*$0.05=$60\) C \(1200*$0.11=$132\) Total cost including attendant's pay: A \(96+60 = 156\) B \(60+90 = 150\) C \(132+60 = 192\) The best choice is Copier B.
Answer: B Hi BunuelHow did you calculate for Copier A, how did you calculate cost of time = $60? Similarly, for Copier B, how did you calculate cost of time = $90? Kindly please explain?? Thanks Would really appreciate your help!



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59561

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Mar 2019, 07:38
JIAA wrote: Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?
A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C
To find the total cost of copying 1,200 pages, we need to know: 1. How long it takes for an attendant to copy 1,200 pages on each copier. 2. How much it costs per job on each of the machines. Cost of Time: A \(\frac{1200}{12} = 100\) mins (exact) costs: $60 B \(\frac{1200}{7} = 170\) mins (approx) costs: $90 C \(\frac{1200}{19} = 63\) mins (approx) costs: $60 Price per Job: A \(1200*$0.08=$96\) B \(1200*$0.05=$60\) C \(1200*$0.11=$132\) Total cost including attendant's pay: A \(96+60 = 156\) B \(60+90 = 150\) C \(132+60 = 192\) The best choice is Copier B.
Answer: B Hi BunuelHow did you calculate for Copier A, how did you calculate cost of time = $60? Similarly, for Copier B, how did you calculate cost of time = $90? Kindly please explain?? Thanks Would really appreciate your help! Check here: https://gmatclub.com/forum/threecopym ... 60805.htmlHope it helps.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 09 Jun 2018
Posts: 105

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
22 Sep 2019, 16:50
Bunuel wrote: Official Solution:
Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?
A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C
To find the total cost of copying 1,200 pages, we need to know: 1. How long it takes for an attendant to copy 1,200 pages on each copier. 2. How much it costs per job on each of the machines. Cost of Time: A \(\frac{1200}{12} = 100\) mins (exact) costs: $60 B \(\frac{1200}{7} = 170\) mins (approx) costs: $90 C \(\frac{1200}{19} = 63\) mins (approx) costs: $60 Price per Job: A \(1200*$0.08=$96\) B \(1200*$0.05=$60\) C \(1200*$0.11=$132\) Total cost including attendant's pay: A \(96+60 = 156\) B \(60+90 = 150\) C \(132+60 = 192\) The best choice is Copier B.
Answer: B I did it this way and it took 4 minutes to answer the question, is there a quicker way to get this or is this just a time intensive question?



Intern
Joined: 15 Jan 2019
Posts: 13

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Sep 2019, 09:23
I felt "(you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute)," was not clear, so what I infer from this is that $30 for 1 hour and $60 for 2 hours.. so how do I infer it's $30 for 3 hrs??



Manager
Joined: 16 May 2019
Posts: 132

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
23 Sep 2019, 09:53
sankarsh wrote: I felt "(you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute)," was not clear, so what I infer from this is that $30 for 1 hour and $60 for 2 hours.. so how do I infer it's $30 for 3 hrs?? sankarsh  Sorry if my explanation was not clear. Your interpretation is correct: it costs $30 per hour per attendant. Bunuel based his solution on this given information in a clearcut manner. I was merely highlighting the relative differences between/among two or three copiers at a time. Since we know Copier C costs more per minute to run than Copier A, for instance, and since they both require 2 hours of attendant work (since Copier C barely ticked past the 1hour mark), any advantage Copier C might gain, in terms of costefficiency, by completing the job faster must outweigh the "penalty" of the additional $30 that it incurred, despite the fact that Copier A also required 2 attendant hours. As I showed above, the advantage for C does not outweigh the drawback. The comparison between Copier A and Copier B was more straightforward, and the $30 difference between the two comes from B taking 1 attendant hour longer to complete the job. If you are still confused, I would be happy to discuss the matter further. I am not saying my solution is better than the official one, by any means. I was just pointing out another way to solve the problem, and sometimes I feel it is good for others who may base their Quant approach on a similar balance between intuition and their mathematical knowledge base to see that it is okay to approach problems creatively.  Andrew



Intern
Joined: 23 Nov 2018
Posts: 22
Location: United States (WA)
Concentration: Strategy, General Management
Schools: HBS '22, Kellogg '22, Ross '22, Haas '22, Tuck '22, Yale '22, Duke '22, Darden '22, McDonough '22, Boston U '22, Foster '22, Mendoza '22, Carey Arizona "22, Smeal "22
GMAT 1: 640 Q41 V37 GMAT 2: 690 Q43 V41
GPA: 3.38

Re: M0535
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Oct 2019, 08:12
Bunuel wrote: Three copy machines are making copies of the same document. Copier A makes 12 copies per minute, Copier B makes 7, and Copier C makes 19. It costs 8 cents/copy for Copier A, 5 cents/copy for Copier B, and 11 cents/copy for Copier C. If a separate attendant has to be hired for each copier and be paid $30 per hour (you have to pay $60 if the attendant works for one hour and one minute), which copier alone will be the most efficient choice to make 1,200 copies?
A. Copier A B. Copier B C. Copier C D. A and B E. A and C I just want to emphasize that you cannot eliminate D and E based on the wording "copier alone." Copier alone is the same as saying as that copier working by itself and not with another copier to share the workload. If the question asked, "which copier is the only one that will be the most efficient choice," then this would eliminate D & E. MentorTutoring explains this in his/her alternative approach above as well.










