Last visit was: 23 May 2024, 05:07 It is currently 23 May 2024, 05:07
Toolkit
GMAT Club Daily Prep
Thank you for using the timer - this advanced tool can estimate your performance and suggest more practice questions. We have subscribed you to Daily Prep Questions via email.

Customized
for You

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History

Track

every week, we’ll send you an estimated GMAT score based on your performance

Practice
Pays

we will pick new questions that match your level based on your Timer History
Not interested in getting valuable practice questions and articles delivered to your email? No problem, unsubscribe here.

# Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh

SORT BY:
Tags:
Show Tags
Hide Tags
Senior Manager
Joined: 02 Dec 2007
Posts: 260
Own Kudos [?]: 2084 [17]
Given Kudos: 6
Tutor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 14891
Own Kudos [?]: 65439 [17]
Given Kudos: 431
Location: Pune, India
General Discussion
Intern
Joined: 09 Mar 2008
Posts: 21
Own Kudos [?]: 6 [0]
Given Kudos: 0
Current Student
Joined: 28 Dec 2004
Posts: 1581
Own Kudos [?]: 643 [0]
Given Kudos: 2
Location: New York City
Concentration: Social Enterprise
Schools:Wharton'11 HBS'12
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
then your OA is wrong..this is straight up B
Senior Manager
Joined: 02 Dec 2007
Posts: 260
Own Kudos [?]: 2084 [0]
Given Kudos: 6
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
OA is A , however it makes no sense .
Manager
Joined: 23 Jul 2008
Posts: 71
Own Kudos [?]: 194 [0]
Given Kudos: 0
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Nihit wrote:
Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs, a phenomenon that attracts tourists. To bring more tourists, the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting.

Birdwatcher: Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.

Which of the following, if true, would provide the mayor with the strongest counter to the birdwatcher’s objection?

A. Every year a certain percentage of crabs are caught by fishermen as bait for eel traps.
B. Horseshoe crabs are so prolific that given favorable circumstances their numbers increase rapidly.
C. On average, tourists who come to the town in order to watch birds spend more money there than tourists who come for other purposes.
D. The additional land made available by the reclamation project will give migrating shorebirds more space.
Some of the migrating shorebirds make only one stop during their migration form South America to Canada

IMO B
So the argument here is whether the mayor's argument can be supported in light of the birdwatcher's argument. So mayor just offers the land. Birdwatcher says we need more such frogs. If we add B to mayor's argument i think we get it.
Director
Joined: 18 May 2008
Posts: 696
Own Kudos [?]: 2811 [0]
Given Kudos: 0
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
A????????No way! it must be B. whts the source?
Nihit wrote:
OA is A , however it makes no sense .
Director
Joined: 05 Jul 2008
Posts: 623
Own Kudos [?]: 1957 [0]
Given Kudos: 1
Q49  V41
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Yeah! B clearly offers support to mayor by saying the HSC proliferate fast to cover the increase of the nesting area provided by the mayor and city.

A actually undermines the mayor's point by saying that HSC are taken away by FM. Also, it does not specify how much % of them are taken away. Lets say if the FM take 50%, it's a toast. If they take 1%, probably does not make much difference. We can't say for sure. So it can't be A
Manager
Joined: 26 Oct 2008
Posts: 67
Own Kudos [?]: 232 [1]
Given Kudos: 0
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
1
Kudos
Where DO these things come from? Of course it is B. The birdwatcher's objection is that there must be a high DENSITY of crabs in order to attract the birds. He/she is assuming that an increase in the area of the beach necessarily reduces density. Choice B negates this assumption; it says that if beach area is increased, the crabs will multiply to fill it up.
BSchool Moderator
Joined: 28 May 2012
Posts: 83
Own Kudos [?]: 423 [1]
Given Kudos: 11
Location: India
Concentration: General Management, Strategy
GPA: 3.33
WE:Information Technology (Retail)
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
1
Kudos
Please stay away from sources floating around the net.

This questions appears on the GMAT PREP as well.

The OA to the above question is B.

It's senseless to make discussions with a wrong OA.

Thanks,
Ankit
Intern
Joined: 30 Mar 2012
Posts: 5
Own Kudos [?]: 84 [2]
Given Kudos: 18
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
2
Kudos
Clear B. Option A makes nonsense
VP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1343
Own Kudos [?]: 2401 [0]
Given Kudos: 355
Concentration: Finance
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Nihit wrote:
Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs, a phenomenon that attracts tourists. To bring more tourists, the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting.

Birdwatcher: Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.

Which of the following, if true, would provide the mayor with the strongest counter to the birdwatcher’s objection?

A. Every year a certain percentage of crabs are caught by fishermen as bait for eel traps.
B. Horseshoe crabs are so prolific that given favorable circumstances their numbers increase rapidly.
C. On average, tourists who come to the town in order to watch birds spend more money there than tourists who come for other purposes.
D. The additional land made available by the reclamation project will give migrating shorebirds more space.
Some of the migrating shorebirds make only one stop during their migration form South America to Canada

This is B by POE and for the reasons mentioned above
Intern
Joined: 10 Sep 2013
Posts: 18
Own Kudos [?]: 121 [0]
Given Kudos: 30
Location: India
Concentration: Accounting, Finance
GMAT Date: 10-25-2013
GPA: 3.66
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Nihit wrote:
Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs, a phenomenon that attracts tourists. To bring more tourists, the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting.

Birdwatcher: Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.

Which of the following, if true, would provide the mayor with the strongest counter to the birdwatcher’s objection?

A. Every year a certain percentage of crabs are caught by fishermen as bait for eel traps.
B. Horseshoe crabs are so prolific that given favorable circumstances their numbers increase rapidly.
C. On average, tourists who come to the town in order to watch birds spend more money there than tourists who come for other purposes.
D. The additional land made available by the reclamation project will give migrating shorebirds more space.
Some of the migrating shorebirds make only one stop during their migration form South America to Canada

Even i opted for option B. But i feel A is the correct answer (though I am not sure)

But this can be a possible explanation for A: Fishermen use Crabs as bait for eel trap every year and still migrating shorebirds stop at the beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs. This implies that the high density of crabs on the beach is maintained.

B mentions favorable circumstances which will be another assumption.

Am I Wrong???
Intern
Joined: 15 Apr 2013
Posts: 45
Own Kudos [?]: 32 [0]
Given Kudos: 43
GMAT 1: 570 Q44 V25
GPA: 3
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
jellybean23 wrote:
Nihit wrote:
Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs, a phenomenon that attracts tourists. To bring more tourists, the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting.

Birdwatcher: Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.

Which of the following, if true, would provide the mayor with the strongest counter to the birdwatcher’s objection?

A. Every year a certain percentage of crabs are caught by fishermen as bait for eel traps.
B. Horseshoe crabs are so prolific that given favorable circumstances their numbers increase rapidly.
C. On average, tourists who come to the town in order to watch birds spend more money there than tourists who come for other purposes.
D. The additional land made available by the reclamation project will give migrating shorebirds more space.
Some of the migrating shorebirds make only one stop during their migration form South America to Canada

Even i opted for option B. But i feel A is the correct answer (though I am not sure)

But this can be a possible explanation for A: Fishermen use Crabs as bait for eel trap every year and still migrating shorebirds stop at the beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs. This implies that the high density of crabs on the beach is maintained.

B mentions favorable circumstances which will be another assumption.

Am I Wrong???

I think A actually supports the Birdwatcher's objection. We are looking for something that counters his objection that 'Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.'.

If we assume A to be correct then it implies that fishermen use crabs ----> fewer crabs ----> fewer chances of uncovering eggs ----> migrating shorebirds will go hungry. We need something that contradicts this.

B contradicts the birdwatcher's objection. favorable circumstances (already mentioned in the question stem that 'the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting', hence we can expect the crab population to rise) ----> more crabs ----> more chances of uncovering eggs ----> more shorebirds will stop at the beach. This rightly counters the birdwatchers objection.

Hope it clarifies your doubt. I tried my best to explain it.

Kudos if you like

Good luck!!!
Manager
Joined: 17 Oct 2012
Posts: 55
Own Kudos [?]: 532 [0]
Given Kudos: 53
Location: India
Concentration: Strategy, Finance
WE:Information Technology (Computer Software)
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
B will strenghen the argument of Mayor so IMO B should be the correct answer.
Manager
Joined: 11 Aug 2011
Posts: 134
Own Kudos [?]: 1726 [0]
Given Kudos: 886
Location: United States
Concentration: Economics, Finance
GMAT Date: 10-16-2013
GPA: 3
WE:Analyst (Computer Software)
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Found this explanation in beatthegmat thread and posting here :

This is a question that, upon first read, may seem vaguely illogical and abstruse. The key phrase is this: "shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest," which means that crabs dig their own nest, and thus accidentally uncover the eggs buried of nearby nests, and this is in fact what brings birds, which in turn brings tourists. This provides the link needed for the birdwatcher's argument; there must be a dense population of crabs for this accidental uncovering to occur; therefore, increasing the space in which crabs can nest will decrease the density, and decrease the number of accidental uncoverings. This is at the heart of the birdwatcher's argument.

However, there is a key assumption in the birdwatcher's argument: increasing the space for crab nesting will ONLY result in a decrease in crab density IF there is not a proportionate increase in crabs. In other words, if there were double the space, AND DOUBLE THE CRABS, the crab density would remain stable. We'd get more accidental egg uncovering, more birds, and more tourists; the birdwatcher would be wrong in her conclusion, and the mayor right.

Answer choice B reflects this logic, explaining that horseshoe crabs are both "prolific" and that their number increases rapidly given favorable circumstances (such as a beach reclamation project to give them extra space).

The other answer choices are mismatches. Choice A is about decreases, not increases, in crab population (and goes by percentage, which means that this situation would not change even if the population did). Choice C is about money, and far out of scope; the argument is about bringing more tourists, not about bringing more tourist money. Choice D is irrelevant and redundant: crabs have more space, so do birds- so what? Choice E discusses an irrelevant fact that has no direct bearing on the situation; we already know that birds stop here to get eggs, so we can safely assume they will continue to do so.

Following the thread of causation (in this case- crab density Arrow crabs uncovering eggs Arrow more birds Arrow more tourists) is key, here and on many CR questions.

Kudos me if you like the post !!!!!
Manager
Joined: 03 Dec 2012
Posts: 144
Own Kudos [?]: 842 [0]
Given Kudos: 291
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Nihit wrote:
OA is A , however it makes no sense .

I dont know what source ur referring but the OA is B. Period.
Director
Joined: 20 Dec 2015
Status:Learning
Posts: 873
Own Kudos [?]: 568 [0]
Given Kudos: 755
Location: India
Concentration: Operations, Marketing
GMAT 1: 670 Q48 V36
GRE 1: Q157 V157
GPA: 3.4
WE:Engineering (Manufacturing)
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Imo B
To weaken the conclusion of the bird watcher we have show that the density of horseshoe crab will not decrease .
B gives us reason for that
Manager
Joined: 11 Jun 2017
Posts: 55
Own Kudos [?]: 102 [0]
Given Kudos: 8
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
B.
The increase in area or space will result in the crabs being spread out and they will not uncover each other's eggs accidently and thus the number of birds would reduce and consequently the number of tourists. This is the whole point of the birdwatcher's argument. However, if the density of carbs is high, then that coupled with an increase in area would lead to more eggs being uncovered and thus, more birds and tourist. This is exactly what B implies.
Intern
Joined: 21 Jan 2018
Posts: 6
Own Kudos [?]: 0 [0]
Given Kudos: 17
Location: India
Schools: IIM (WL)
GPA: 3
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horseshoe-crab eggs, a phenomenon that attracts tourists. To bring more tourists, the town council plans to undertake a beach reclamation project to double the area available to crabs for nesting.

Birdwatcher: Without a high density of crabs on a beach, migrating shorebirds will go hungry because shorebirds only eat eggs that a crab happens to uncover when it is digging its own nest.

Which of the following, if true, would provide the mayor with the strongest counter to the birdwatcher’s objection?

HAVE TO USE ELIMINATION METHOD :

(A) Every year a certain percentage of crabs are caught by fishermen as bait for eel traps. ### NO POINT ABOUT EEL ###

(B) Horseshoe crabs are so prolific that given favorable circumstances their numbers increase rapidly. ### ANSWER AS IT COUNTERS THE OBJECTION ###

(C) On average, tourists who come to the town in order to watch birds spend more money there than tourists who come for other purposes. ###IRRELEVANT ###

(D) The additional land made available by the reclamation project will give migrating shorebirds more space. ###TRUE###

(E) Some of the migrating shorebirds make only one stop during their migration form South America to Canada ###IRRELEVANT ###
Re: Mayor: Migrating shorebirds stop at our beach just to feed on horsesh [#permalink]
1   2
Moderators:
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
6936 posts
GMAT Club Verbal Expert
238 posts
CR Forum Moderator
832 posts