Thanks for the prompt and detailed responses, guys!
In response to your questions: I graduated with a 3.8+ GPA, summa cum laude from the flagship public university in my state (but not Michigan or Berkeley caliber). I'm a U.S. citizen. My current job is in finance and is research based, but it is not academic research. I am confident that I can get a 700+ on the GMAT, and I think I have a reasonable chance of getting 750+.
My ultimate goal is not to attend a particular school, but rather to subsequently land a tenure track position in an AACSB certified school. If it's not a premier university, I'd be fine with that. I'd be perfectly happy with a tenure-track position at, for example, a state university that is not the state's flagship campus. I just want to get paid to do research and a little teaching!
I have a few more questions:
1) From what I can tell by looking through the websites of various universities of various calibers, and seeing where the assistant professors of finance received their PhDs, it seems that a super elite degree is not necessary to attain a tenure track position at an AACSB school. Am I correct in thinking that the academic job market is pretty good for finance PhDs, even if they don't have a degree from an elite school?
2) Tuition is the main reason I'd prefer to enroll directly in a PhD program. Would a high enough math GMAT score be sufficient to demonstrate my mathematical ability?
3) Am I being realistic when I'm thinking of sending out applications to PhD programs this fall/winter?
Thanks,
tonic2