Strategy guide for Game X: In the board game Game X, the traditional

Question

Strategy guide for Game X:  In the board game Game X, the traditional openings—strategic sequences of moves at the beginning of games—are most advantageous against opponents who understand both the traditional and the nontraditional openings, and also against those who do not understand any of the openings very well. However, nontraditional openings are most advantageous against opponents who understand only the traditional openings. Aggressive openings, whether traditional or nontraditional, generally favor a player who uses them against an opponent less experienced with Game X, whereas defensive openings, whether traditional or nontraditional, tend to reduce an opponent's advantage when used by a player less experienced with Game X.

Select for  Aggressive , traditional the scenario in which the information above most strongly suggests that an aggressive, traditional opening would be most advantageous for you to use, and select for Defensive, nontraditional the scenario in which the above information most strongly suggests that a defensive, nontraditional opening would be most advantageous for you to use. Make only two selections, one in each column.

av722 · Accepted Answer

This question was very difficult for me because I got bogged down by the details upon my initial reading. I thought writing a chart about the different kinds of openings would help, but here is how I approached the question again.

Go straight to the question below the scenario. We're looking for what would be opening would most advantageous for us-- whether it be aggressive traditional or defensive nontraditional.

Aggressive Traditional
Scanning the scenario, it says 'Aggressive openings, whether  traditional or nontraditional , generally  favor  a player who uses them against an  opponent less experienced with Game X '. All of the choices but one have the opponent as either the same experience level or more experience with game X. Eliminate those and the reminaing choice is 'Your opponent understands both the traditional and nontraditional openings, but you have more experience with Game X'.

Defensive Nontraditional
In the last sentence it says 'defensive openings, whether  traditional or nontraditional , tend to  reduce  an opponent's advantage when used by a player  less experienced with Game X '. So we want a choice that puts us either at the same level or at a lower level than our opponent. All 4 choices but the one we chose above remain.
Next we'll look to eliminate based on the 'Nontraditional' part. In the scenario, it says 'nontraditional openings are most  advantageous  against opponents who  understand only the traditional  openings'. Only one supports this line-- 'Your opponent has more experience with Game X but understands only the traditional openings.'

Matsu12 · Answer

I'm having a hard time understanding why the answer for Defensive Non-Traditional is "Your opponent has more experience with Game X but understand only the traditional openings" instead of "Your opponent understands both the traditional and Non-Traditional openings, and has more experience with Game X"

My logic says that defensive openings are for people that are less experienced than the opponent, which is what both arguments state, but can't find why we are opting for option b.

My logic says that defensive openings are for people that are less experienced than the opponent, which is what both arguments state, but can't find why we are opting for option b.

nazii · Answer

Hello
defensive openings, whether traditional or nontraditional, tend to reduce an opponent's advantage when used by a player less experienced with Game.
Because of this part, if you are a person with less experience and use defensive, that's good for you since you can reduce your opponent chance (Advantage.) By definition for nontradional as well, B is therefore correct

Arpitamitra · Answer

Hi,

Can anyone please help me understand the question in details.

horrorslive · Answer

@  MartyTargetTestPrep  @ KarishmaB  could you please provide an explaination for this question?

ramiav · Answer

Hope that this answer helps you Quite dirty, but on the left "your player", and on the vertical the other player so there are many categories ( exp, and technologies used, maybe there are some things that are not reflected as No knowledge, or same experience) https://gmatclub.com/forum/download/file.php?id=81784 GMAT-Club-Forum-sigr3wx2.png

Iashish.sharma · Answer

Could anyone provide OA for this question?

Posted from my mobile device

jm2k5 · Answer

I'll simplify using the following nomenclature.

Replace the arrow (---> )in the below statements with ("is advantageous against opponents who know/are"). 
TO = Traditional Openings
NTO = Non Traditional Openings
DNO = Do not know Openings
AO = Aggressive Openings
DO =Defensive Openings
LE = Less Experienced
ME = More Experienced.

Now follow the question statement.

1. TO ----> TO,NTO,DNO
2. NTO ----> TO
3. AO ----> LE
4. DO ----> ME

Now see statements 1 and 3.

Traditional Agressive Openings is advantageous against an oponent who knows both T and NT openings but is less experienced than you. (Option 3)*

And Statements 2 and 4.

Non Traditional Defensive Openings is advantageous against an opponent who knows Traditional Openings but is more experienced than you. (Option 2)

* I must point out that if you are using Traditional Openings, it does not matter what kind of opening your opponent plays, you will always be at an advantage. So, it only comes down to experience.

Emma614 · Answer

Defensive, nontraditional situations where the player is LESS EXPERIENCED,  reduce  the opponent's advantage. But if the opponent only knows traditional openings, then it's the most advantage. The degree of advantage is much higher than the previous

Gemmie · Answer

Against oppents understanding....Traditional......Nontraditional......Neither

Traditional...................................Yes................Yes.....................Yes

Nontraditional..............................Yes

Against oppents........Less experienced......More experienced

Agressive..................Yes

Defensive................................................Yes

Your opponent has more experience with Game X but understands only the traditional openings. 
+ Opponent is more experienced => Defensive
+ Understand only traditional openings => Nontraditional

Your opponent understands both the traditional and nontraditional openings, but you have more experience with Game X 
+ Opponent is less experienced => Aggresive
+ Understand both traditional and nontraditional => Traditional

sachi-in · Answer

There is too much information in this question, yet it's of a lower difficulty level.

Is there any way to solve it under 3 4 minutes ?

Comparing the two types of moves with every 4 options ( 8 total ) seems prone to careless mistakes, ardous and time consuming.

SatvikVedala · Answer

Approach:

Traditional Openings -----> Adv -----> against -----> Traditional/Non Traditional Openings
Also, Traditional Openings -----> Adv -----> against -----> Opponents who don't understand Traditional/Non Traditional Openings

Non Traditional Openings ---> Adv ---> against ----->Traditional Openings

Aggressive ----> T/NT ----> Adv ----> against ----> Less experienced opponent

Defensive ----> T/NT ----> Adv ----> against ----> When one is Less experienced than Opponent

Based on this we end up in 4 scenarios

1. Aggressive ---> Traditional ---> Adv ----> against ----> Less experienced opponent who understands T/NT openings
2. Aggressive ----> Traditional ---> Adv ----> against ----> Less experienced opponent who don't understand T/NT openings
3. Aggressive ---->NT Open. ----> Adv ----> against ----> Less experienced opponent who understands Traditional Openings

4. Defensive ----> Traditional ---> Adv ----> When ----> One is Less experienced but opponent understands T/NT openings
5. Defensive ----> NT Open. ---> Adv ----> When ----> One is Less experienced but opponent understands T openings

djangobackend · Answer

1. TO >> TO+NTO or NEITHER
2. NTO >> only TO 
3. AO (any) >> against less exp. players (any - since not specified)

tricky part - whereas defensive openings, whether traditional or nontraditional, tend to reduce an opponent's advantage when used by a player less experienced with Game X - " tend to reduce an opponent's advantage" this simply means that you are at advantage and " when used by a player less experienced with Game X" means that you have less experience so -

4. DO (any) >> against more exp. players (any - since not specified)

Answers - 
 Aggressive, traditional - Your opponent understands both the traditional and nontraditional openings, but you have more experience with Game X  -  since AO will work with less exp. players AND TO will work when opponent has both TO+NTO .

Defensive, nontraditional - Your opponent has more experience with Game X but understands only the traditional openings  -  since DO will work against more exp. players and NTO will work against only TO players.

soma7 · Answer

Hi,

I understand why many of us wonder why not the last option for defensive, non-traditional.

According to my guess, both option B and E state's that opponent must be of high experience which is a must be condition. But since it asks for defensive, non-traditional , Non-traditional players are best against only traditional players. So they have to defend them who has more experience and as well as a traditional strategy person

laborumplaceat · Answer

First check - if the opponent is experienced or less experienced.
If experienced, means defensive technique. And then for non traditional openings - played should only understand traditional openings -> this is B

If opponent is not so experienced or less experienced than you - then aggressive openings better. And for you to play with traditional openings-> the player can understand traditional or non traditional openings.

Siddharth17 · Answer

don't focus too much on the details. just go to the question

aggressive, traditional
check what is needed for aggressive & traditional

vk1001 · Answer

you also have to consider the use of traditional versus non traditional. In the paragraph we are told "  However, nontraditional openings are most advantageous against opponents who understand only the traditional openings." Hence you need use :
-defensive: since you are less experienced 
 -non traditional: since your opponent only knows about traditional openings and you will at advantage to use non-traditional approach.

bishal128 · Answer

Bunuel   karishma  is this proper GMAT question! Because I see flaw in the reasoning regarding traditional and nontraditional players

suscipitmagni · Answer

We need a player that will have more experience than us at game X but also only understands traditional openings. This way we can use defensive non-traditional startegies. This make option b stronger than option d , where the opponent knew non-traditional openings as well.

Strategy guide for Game X: In the board game Game X, the traditional

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

Aggressive, traditional	Defensive, nontraditional
		You and your opponent understand the same openings for Game X.
		Your opponent has more experience with Game X but understands only the traditional openings.
		Your opponent understands both the traditional and nontraditional openings, but you have more experience with Game X
		You and your opponent have the same amount of experience with Game X.
		Your opponent understands both the traditional and nontraditional openings, and has more experience with Game X.

GMAT Two-part Analysis (TPA) Questions

Strategy guide for Game X: In the board game Game X, the traditional

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards