November 22, 2018 November 22, 2018 10:00 PM PST 11:00 PM PST Mark your calendars  All GMAT Club Tests are free and open November 22nd to celebrate Thanksgiving Day! Access will be available from 0:01 AM to 11:59 PM, Pacific Time (USA) November 23, 2018 November 23, 2018 10:00 PM PST 11:00 PM PST Practice the one most important Quant section  Integer properties, and rapidly improve your skills.
Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Intern
Joined: 01 May 2013
Posts: 10

A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 15 Oct 2017, 08:42
Question Stats:
61% (00:56) correct 39% (01:11) wrong based on 173 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the set, xy is also in the set. If 2 and 6 are in the set, which of the following must also be in the set? I. 3 II. 12 III. 24 A. None B. I only C. II only D. I and II only E. II and III only Hey Guys, I am confused here. Please help. According to me the following is the logic: 2, 6 are in the set, then 2*6 = 12 is also in the set if 6 and 2 are in the set then 2*3=6 ==> 3 must be also in the set if 12 and 2 are in the set then 2*12 = 24 should also be in the set
So according to me all 3 options are possible in the set. However such an option does not exist. Please clarify.
Thanks.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
Originally posted by kalravaibhav on 03 Oct 2013, 11:21.
Last edited by Bunuel on 15 Oct 2017, 08:42, edited 2 times in total.
Renamed the topic and edited the question.



Magoosh GMAT Instructor
Joined: 28 Dec 2011
Posts: 4488

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Oct 2013, 12:44
kalravaibhav wrote: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the set, xy is also in the set. If 2 and 6 are in the set, which of the following must also be in the set? I. 3 II. 12 III. 24
a) None b) I only c) II only d) I and II only e) II and III only
Hey Guys,
I am confused here. Please help. According to me the following is the logic:
2, 6 are in the set, then 2*6 = 12 is also in the set if 6 and 2 are in the set then 2*3=6 ==> 3 must be also in the set if 12 and 2 are in the set then 2*12 = 24 should also be in the set
So according to me all 3 options are possible in the set. However such an option does not exist. Please clarify.
Thanks. Dear kalravaibhav, Be careful about switching parts of the premise and conclusion in an IFTHEN statement. The statement If P, then Q does not imply If Q, then P. Similarly, the statement If P and Q, then T does not implies If P and T, then Q. That's the transformation you did. TRUE: if x and y are in the set, the xy is also in the setFALSE: if x and xy are in the set, then y is also in the setThat's precisely the logic you followed in the line of yours that I marked in red. That's not true  in fact, that was precisely the trap of the question, inducing folks to make this incorrect logical deduction. Does all this make sense? Mike
_________________
Mike McGarry Magoosh Test Prep
Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire. — William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)



Manager
Joined: 26 Sep 2013
Posts: 196
Concentration: Finance, Economics
GMAT 1: 670 Q39 V41 GMAT 2: 730 Q49 V41

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Oct 2013, 17:54
got it correct, but honestly I guessed.
You don't know if 2 or 6 are x or y. There could be 30 numbers in this set, and who knows what X and Y will be. All you know is two of the numbers in the set, so you can't know what other numbers have to be in it. Poorly worded question IMO



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 50712

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Oct 2013, 23:32



Magoosh GMAT Instructor
Joined: 28 Dec 2011
Posts: 4488

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Oct 2013, 12:10
AccipiterQ wrote: got it correct, but honestly I guessed.
You don't know if 2 or 6 are x or y. There could be 30 numbers in this set, and who knows what X and Y will be. All you know is two of the numbers in the set, so you can't know what other numbers have to be in it. Poorly worded question IMO Dear AccipiterQ, First of all, I am just going to recommend a grammar correction in what you have written: " You don't know whether 2 or 6 are x or y." That's a very typical GMAT SC trap. See: http://magoosh.com/gmat/2012/gmatsente ... swhether/I would say  the wording of this question is very clear. I would call this a high quality, wellwritten question. The issue you raise  we don't know whether the numbers given equal x or y  this betrays a subtle misunderstanding. In some algebra problems, the "solve for x" variety of problems, x or y or any variable will have one definite value, or perhaps two possible values, and the point is to find those individual values. In many other algebraic situations, the variables are general variables that don't have specific values. For example, when we have the equation of the graph of a line in the xy plane, such as y = 2x  3, the x & y don't have individual specific values  rather, the x & y coordinates of every point on the line, the whole continuous infinity of them, satisfy the equation. Thus, the x & y could be any one of a whole infinity of values, and yet it's very precise and clear which x' & y's could or couldn't fit the pattern. In this set, it is unambiguous from context  x and y are general variables that could equal any member of the set. If we know a number is in the set, that number could equal x or y. At the outset, the only known members of the set are 2 & 6, so either could be x, and either could be y. That's how we know 12 must be in the set. There's nothing saying that x and y have to be different, so if we pick x = y = 2, then 4 has to be in the set, and if we pick x = y = 6, then 36 has to be in the set. With just this analysis, we see the members of the set must include {2, 4, 6, 12, 36}. Now, any of those five numbers could be x, and any of the five could be y. Thus, if we pick x = 2 and y = 12, we see that 24 must be in the set. In fact, for what it's worth, here is the full set of all numbers less than 100 that must be in the set {2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32, 36, 48, 64, 72, 96} Many other numbers could be in the set, but those are the ones that absolutely have to be in the set, no question. It's true  many other element could be in the set, but that's not the question. The question is unambiguously clear: " which of the following must also be in the set?" From the analysis above, we see that 12 and 24 absolutely must be in the set, no doubt. It's true, 3 could be in the set, but that's strictly irrelevant to this particular question. My friend, it is crucially important for you to understand: any ambiguity you experience in this question does not lie in the wording of the question itself, but in subtle gaps in your own understanding. I want you to understand this, so you resolve these issues and don't have this same ambiguous experience on test day. Let me know if you have any further questions. Mike
_________________
Mike McGarry Magoosh Test Prep
Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire. — William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)



Manager
Joined: 26 Sep 2013
Posts: 196
Concentration: Finance, Economics
GMAT 1: 670 Q39 V41 GMAT 2: 730 Q49 V41

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Oct 2013, 16:31
mikemcgarry wrote: AccipiterQ wrote: got it correct, but honestly I guessed.
You don't know if 2 or 6 are x or y. There could be 30 numbers in this set, and who knows what X and Y will be. All you know is two of the numbers in the set, so you can't know what other numbers have to be in it. Poorly worded question IMO Dear AccipiterQ, First of all, I am just going to recommend a grammar correction in what you have written: " You don't know whether 2 or 6 are x or y." That's a very typical GMAT SC trap. See: http://magoosh.com/gmat/2012/gmatsente ... swhether/I would say  the wording of this question is very clear. I would call this a high quality, wellwritten question. The issue you raise  we don't know whether the numbers given equal x or y  this betrays a subtle misunderstanding. In some algebra problems, the "solve for x" variety of problems, x or y or any variable will have one definite value, or perhaps two possible values, and the point is to find those individual values. In many other algebraic situations, the variables are general variables that don't have specific values. For example, when we have the equation of the graph of a line in the xy plane, such as y = 2x  3, the x & y don't have individual specific values  rather, the x & y coordinates of every point on the line, the whole continuous infinity of them, satisfy the equation. Thus, the x & y could be any one of a whole infinity of values, and yet it's very precise and clear which x' & y's could or couldn't fit the pattern. In this set, it is unambiguous from context  x and y are general variables that could equal any member of the set. If we know a number is in the set, that number could equal x or y. At the outset, the only known members of the set are 2 & 6, so either could be x, and either could be y. That's how we know 12 must be in the set. There's nothing saying that x and y have to be different, so if we pick x = y = 2, then 4 has to be in the set, and if we pick x = y = 6, then 36 has to be in the set. With just this analysis, we see the members of the set must include {2, 4, 6, 12, 36}. Now, any of those five numbers could be x, and any of the five could be y. Thus, if we pick x = 2 and y = 12, we see that 24 must be in the set. In fact, for what it's worth, here is the full set of all numbers less than 100 that must be in the set {2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32, 36, 48, 64, 72, 96} Many other numbers could be in the set, but those are the ones that absolutely have to be in the set, no question. It's true  many other element could be in the set, but that's not the question. The question is unambiguously clear: " which of the following must also be in the set?" From the analysis above, we see that 12 and 24 absolutely must be in the set, no doubt. It's true, 3 could be in the set, but that's strictly irrelevant to this particular question. My friend, it is crucially important for you to understand: any ambiguity you experience in this question does not lie in the wording of the question itself, but in subtle gaps in your own understanding. I want you to understand this, so you resolve these issues and don't have this same ambiguous experience on test day. Let me know if you have any further questions. Mike Oh my goodness....you probably just added 30 points onto my GMAT score with this post alone. Seriously, on practice tests I have gotten EVERY one of these questions wrong. Wow....that is so clear now...I just had a 'light bulb' go off over my head. So based on being given 2 and 6, you could come up with an infinite number of numbers that have to be in the set then, yes? P.S. Thank you for the SC tip, I've managed to go from getting about 20% of them right to about 90% right by picking up tips like that, every one helps.



NonHuman User
Joined: 09 Sep 2013
Posts: 8869

Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the
[#permalink]
Show Tags
15 Sep 2018, 22:39
Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot! Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up  doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos). Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________
GMAT Books  GMAT Club Tests  Best Prices on GMAT Courses  GMAT Mobile App  Math Resources  Verbal Resources




Re: A set of numbers is defined such that if x and y are in the &nbs
[#permalink]
15 Sep 2018, 22:39






