Calling All CBS 2011 Applicants!!

did they already filled in or what.. for the last few weeks there have been only dings w/o interviews..
under review on 21sts started received dings so I guess i will have to wait 10 days to get mine.. (went under review on the 31st)..

I am going to send an ED next year on the 1st of August and will have my acceptance by october=)

eekkkk people who submitted 1/5 and under review 1/21 are getting notified i haven't heard anything and those are my dates. wont be long i hope!


looks like it could be alot more than 10 days they didn't notify everyone who submitted then today.

anyone interview in January and still waiting for a decision? My app went complete on 1/24. The wait has been brutal.

No, I have no idea if it's true. I was just exaggerating for effect, but...It worked! Got my first Kudo! Let's try it some more!
Warning: Everything in this post is speculative, self-entitled and probably flat wrong.

I have been scouring these boards for CBS clues over the last few months, and I don't think I've seen any figures on the actual ED-RD % breakdown. On the BW blog I once saw an admissions rep say that "the numbers aren't published, but you have the same overall chance of admission in either round." As my grandmother used to say, "The numbers aren't published, but that's probably a load of malarkey." I applied early January RD for precisely the same reasons as wschaeff and a lot of others. I incorrectly assumed there was a discrete amount of spots allocated to RD and ED applicants (like college applications, and 90% of B School admission rounds).

But as it turns out, Columbia seems to have 3 rounds, each of which is fluid. Check it - Round 1: ED, Round 2: RD (September - December), Round 3: RD (December - April). I thought I was applying in something like a Round 2, because I got it into my head that any RD app submitted before the fellowship deadline had the same odds. Better research (or an admissions consultant) would have told me that significantly better RD odds are in the window right after ED. Now the ding-parade has really started cruising since that handful of early January applicants got invites (nearly all on Feb 16, see page 171). I made flawed assumptions, and that's my fault. I surely can't call Columbia disingenuous, even if they are trying to jack up their yield. But if not misleading, the CBS admissions process suffers from a gross lack of clarity and transparency.

It is one of the best business schools in the world. I would do just about anything to get a Columbia MBA. Period. But this here forum has at least 50(!) MORE PAGES than Stanford, HBS, Booth, McCombs, Haas, Wharton, Tuck or any other forum. That's 1,000 more rants, questions, unanswered prayers and pleas than any comparable B-School! What could possibly account for such a difference? The fact that we can't go to the source to get even a modicum of insight into this long, expensive and highly stressful process! Every one of these places is a black box, but CBS goes above and beyond to torture its applicants with uncertainty. Maybe if we were given a bit more information, both prospectively and after submission, I wouldn't spend 20 minutes crafting an uninformed internet diatribe against an institution I want so badly to be a part of.

I'm blowing in the wind here, guys. I just need some clarity.


Oh, and if I get an interview invite tomorrow, I will burn this post to the ground faster than you can say Morningside Heights.

I attended a CBS admissions event in October. The presenter (I believe he was the dean of admissions) said that there's no difference between an ED applicant's chances of acceptance and a RD applicant's, as long as the RD applicant submits his/her app before Dec 15.

Oh my god...like many others here on GC I treated the 5th of January as some sort of r2 deadline...that was probably lethal to all of us who got dinged within the last two weeks. Drives me nuts, especially regarding the fact that I only waited until Jan 5th to avoid getting a sudden idea for my essays and having already submitted my application. I just wonder why CBS does not make the process more transparent.

Oh my god...like many others here on GC I treated the 5th of January as some sort of r2 deadline...that was probably lethal to all of us who got dinged within the last two weeks. Drives me nuts, especially regarding the fact that I only waited until Jan 5th to avoid getting a sudden idea for my essays and having already submitted my application. I just wonder why CBS does not make the process more transparent.

since this thread has been so beneficial to my own peace of mind re: the admissions process, i thought i'd chime in with my own status. thanks to all who posted before, it has been really helpful in navigating the admissions process. to those who have been dinged, i feel for you. to those who are still waiting, don't lose hope!

it's obvious to me that my numbers and stats are not very impressive (as you can see in my profile), so i'm very surprised at the recent posters who have been dinged in the past week. my timeline has been as follows: i submitted on 1/5, underwent review on 1/21, and have yet to hear any response from cbs thus far.

i'm coming from an architecture/non-profit background and made it very clear in my essays that an mba would help me make a necessary career shift. i think it's this background that has kept my application from being waived, so to all those who are considering reapplying, i think the essays are key, key, key. here's hoping to good news.