Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Senior RC Moderator
Status: It always seems impossible until it's done!!
Joined: 29 Aug 2012
Posts: 1085
Location: India
GRE 1: 321 Q164 V157
WE: General Management (Aerospace and Defense)

Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
28 Nov 2017, 17:21
2
This post was BOOKMARKED
Question Stats:
19% (00:47) correct 81% (00:45) wrong based on 95 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5? St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6 St2: A and B are Independent events. Source Self
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________
Become a GMAT Club Premium member to avail lot of discounts
Last edited by chetan2u on 02 Dec 2017, 21:34, edited 1 time in total.
edited the OA



PS Forum Moderator
Joined: 25 Feb 2013
Posts: 841
Location: India
GPA: 3.82

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 08:15
Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self To find \(P(A)>0.5\) ? Statement 1: we do not know whether the events are dependent or independent. InsufficientStatement 2: No probabilities are mentioned. InsufficientCombining 1 & 2 implies \(P(A)*P(B)=0.6\) or \(P(A)=\frac{0.6}{P(B)}\) as the product of probabilities is not \(0\) so none of the probability can be \(0\) and the maximum probability of any event can be \(1\) so if \(P(B)<0.6\) then \(P(A)>1\) which is not possible. Hence \(P(B)≥0.6\). At \(P(B)=0.6; P(A)=1\) and \(P(B)=1; P(A)=0.6\). So we see that at both the extremes \(P(A)>0.5\) Sufficientoption C



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 91
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 10:11
1
This post received KUDOS
Hi GnpthStatement 1 : probability of both event A & B = least value of A or B this is because P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B) , if the events are independent. P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B/A) , if the events are independent. now since the max value of probability for any event P(B) or P(B/A)= 1, hence either P(A) = 0.6 and P(B) = 1 , or P(B) = 0.6 and P(A) = 1, in both the cases, P(A) > 0.5 Answer should be A, please confirm In both cases of independent or dependent event, Statement 1 is sufficient to prove that P(A) >0.5Bunuel, niks18chetan2uVeritasPrepKarishmamikemcgarryamanvermagmatniks18 wrote: Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self To find \(P(A)>0.5\) ? Statement 1: we do not know whether the events are dependent or independent. InsufficientStatement 2: No probabilities are mentioned. InsufficientCombining 1 & 2 implies \(P(A)*P(B)=0.6\) or \(P(A)=\frac{0.6}{P(B)}\) as the product of probabilities is not \(0\) so none of the probability can be \(0\) and the maximum probability of any event can be \(1\) so if \(P(B)<0.6\) then \(P(A)>1\) which is not possible. Hence \(P(B)≥0.6\). At \(P(B)=0.6; P(A)=1\) and \(P(B)=1; P(A)=0.6\). So we see that at both the extremes \(P(A)>0.5\) Sufficientoption C
_________________
If you like my post, encourage me by providing Kudos... Happy Learning...



Magoosh GMAT Instructor
Joined: 28 Dec 2011
Posts: 4651

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 16:04
Janvisahu wrote: Hi GnpthStatement 1 : probability of both event A & B = least value of A or B this is because P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B) , if the events are independent. P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B/A) , if the events are independent. now since the max value of probability for any event P(B) or P(B/A)= 1, hence either P(A) = 0.6 and P(B) = 1 , or P(B) = 0.6 and P(A) = 1, in both the cases, P(A) > 0.5 Answer should be A, please confirm Dear Janvisahu, I'm happy to respond. My friend, I'm sorry, but your reasoning is flawed. Basically, you were assuming that Statement #2 was already true as you were reasoning with Statement #1. Let's be clear: a formulabased approach to probability is doomed to failure. All the formulas in probability are contextspecific, and if you don't understand exactly when you can and when you can't use one, then are driving blind through the realm. The formula P(A and B) = P(A)*P(B) is ONLY true in the very rare and special case events A & B are independent. Most things in the real world are not independent, and if A & B are not independent, then that formula is entirely outthewindow. For two events to be independent, truly independent, means that if we know the outcome of event A, that gives us absolutely no information about the outcome of event B, and vice versa. The following are realworld event pairs that are not independent 1) A = person earns over $200K annually, B = person has a collegedegree or higher 2) A = a person eats pork, B = a person is a Muslim 3) A = a person has smoked for years, B = a person gets cancer None of these pairs are independent, because if we know the answer to one question, that answer automatically makes the other event either more likely or less likely. As it turns on, typically only artificial inanimate things are truly independent, such as the dots showing on two different dice rolled together, or two successful flips of a coin. A few very unusual rare things in the real world would be truly independent. For example, if A = a person is lefthanded, and B = a person gets cancerso far as I know, those two are entirely independent, because knowing the answer to one question leaves us totally in the dark about the answer to the other question. Thus, most real events are NOT independent, and so the P(A and B) = P(A)*P(B) is useless and 100% inapplicable most of the time. We can only use that in the very special case in which A & B are guaranteed to be independent. Under statement #1, the two events could be independent, but they don't have to be independent. Back to statement #1: St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6Case (a): P(A) = 0 and P(B) = 0.6, so P(A and B) = 0.6. This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of no. Case (b): P(A) = 0.8, P(B) = 0.75, events & A & B are independent: then P(A and B) = 0.6 This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of yes. Consistent with Statement #1, we can construct scenarios that produce either a yes or no answer to the prompt. Thus, statement #1, alone and by itself, is not sufficient. Statement #2 is not sufficient by itself either, but when we combine the statement, then we get the reasoning that you provided. Together, the statements are sufficient, and the correct answer is (C). Does all this make sense? Mike
_________________
Mike McGarry Magoosh Test Prep
Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire. — William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)



Senior RC Moderator
Status: It always seems impossible until it's done!!
Joined: 29 Aug 2012
Posts: 1085
Location: India
GRE 1: 321 Q164 V157
WE: General Management (Aerospace and Defense)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 17:19
mikemcgarry : Thanks for the wonderful explanation of the independent events. Kudos!
_________________
Become a GMAT Club Premium member to avail lot of discounts



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 91
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 19:30
Thanks for your clarification, but I am a bit confused... As per your explanation ""Back to statement #1: St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6 Case (a): P(A) = 0 and P(B) = 0.6, so P(A and B) = 0.6. This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of no. "" If P(A) =0, it means A is impossible event, then how probability of both A and B can be non zero. Please explain. mikemcgarry wrote: Janvisahu wrote: Hi GnpthStatement 1 : probability of both event A & B = least value of A or B this is because P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B) , if the events are independent. P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B/A) , if the events are independent. now since the max value of probability for any event P(B) or P(B/A)= 1, hence either P(A) = 0.6 and P(B) = 1 , or P(B) = 0.6 and P(A) = 1, in both the cases, P(A) > 0.5 Answer should be A, please confirm Dear Janvisahu, I'm happy to respond. My friend, I'm sorry, but your reasoning is flawed. Basically, you were assuming that Statement #2 was already true as you were reasoning with Statement #1. Let's be clear: a formulabased approach to probability is doomed to failure. All the formulas in probability are contextspecific, and if you don't understand exactly when you can and when you can't use one, then are driving blind through the realm. The formula P(A and B) = P(A)*P(B) is ONLY true in the very rare and special case events A & B are independent. Most things in the real world are not independent, and if A & B are not independent, then that formula is entirely outthewindow. For two events to be independent, truly independent, means that if we know the outcome of event A, that gives us absolutely no information about the outcome of event B, and vice versa. The following are realworld event pairs that are not independent 1) A = person earns over $200K annually, B = person has a collegedegree or higher 2) A = a person eats pork, B = a person is a Muslim 3) A = a person has smoked for years, B = a person gets cancer None of these pairs are independent, because if we know the answer to one question, that answer automatically makes the other event either more likely or less likely. As it turns on, typically only artificial inanimate things are truly independent, such as the dots showing on two different dice rolled together, or two successful flips of a coin. A few very unusual rare things in the real world would be truly independent. For example, if A = a person is lefthanded, and B = a person gets cancerso far as I know, those two are entirely independent, because knowing the answer to one question leaves us totally in the dark about the answer to the other question. Thus, most real events are NOT independent, and so the P(A and B) = P(A)*P(B) is useless and 100% inapplicable most of the time. We can only use that in the very special case in which A & B are guaranteed to be independent. Under statement #1, the two events could be independent, but they don't have to be independent. Back to statement #1: St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6Case (a): P(A) = 0 and P(B) = 0.6, so P(A and B) = 0.6. This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of no. Case (b): P(A) = 0.8, P(B) = 0.75, events & A & B are independent: then P(A and B) = 0.6 This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of yes. Consistent with Statement #1, we can construct scenarios that produce either a yes or no answer to the prompt. Thus, statement #1, alone and by itself, is not sufficient. Statement #2 is not sufficient by itself either, but when we combine the statement, then we get the reasoning that you provided. Together, the statements are sufficient, and the correct answer is (C). Does all this make sense? Mike
_________________
If you like my post, encourage me by providing Kudos... Happy Learning...



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 5547

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 19:40
2
This post received KUDOS
Expert's post
1
This post was BOOKMARKED
Janvisahu wrote: Hi GnpthStatement 1 : probability of both event A & B = least value of A or B this is because P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B) , if the events are independent. P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B/A) , if the events are independent. now since the max value of probability for any event P(B) or P(B/A)= 1, hence either P(A) = 0.6 and P(B) = 1 , or P(B) = 0.6 and P(A) = 1, in both the cases, P(A) > 0.5 Answer should be A, please confirm Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self Hi.. You are correct. If the probability of an event A is 0.x, the probability of it, A, happening with another event B will be LESS than 0.x and equal to 0.x if the other event B is 100% to happenthis has to be true irrespective of type of event..Quote: Back to statement #1: St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6 Case (a): P(A) = 0 and P(B) = 0.6, so P(A and B) = 0.6. This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of no. Case (b): P(A) = 0.8, P(B) = 0.75, events & A & B are independent: then P(A and B) = 0.6 This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of yes. Consistent with Statement #1, we can construct scenarios that produce either a yes or no answer to the prompt. Thus, statement #1, alone and by itself, is not sufficient. ] mikemcgarry, it seems you have taken OR in case (a) as the P(A and B) will be 0 in this case independent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(b).. P(b)=1.2 ... cannot be >1..... NOT possible dependent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(a/b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(a/b).. P(a/b)=1.2 cannot be >1 NOT possible P(a/b) is probability of b happening when a has already happened so it has to be less than P(a)statement I is sufficient
_________________
Absolute modulus :http://gmatclub.com/forum/absolutemodulusabetterunderstanding210849.html#p1622372 Combination of similar and dissimilar things : http://gmatclub.com/forum/topic215915.html
BANGALORE/



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 91
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
30 Nov 2017, 20:28
4
This post received KUDOS
Thank you for clarification of doubt. Kudos to you. Please provide kudo, I helped in rectification of OA. chetan2u wrote: Janvisahu wrote: Hi GnpthStatement 1 : probability of both event A & B = least value of A or B this is because P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B) , if the events are independent. P(A& B) = P(A)*P(B/A) , if the events are independent. now since the max value of probability for any event P(B) or P(B/A)= 1, hence either P(A) = 0.6 and P(B) = 1 , or P(B) = 0.6 and P(A) = 1, in both the cases, P(A) > 0.5 Answer should be A, please confirm Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self Hi.. You are correct. If the probability of an event A is 0.x, the probability of it, A, happening with another event B will be LESS than 0.x and equal to 0.x if the other event B is 100% to happenthis has to be true irrespective of type of event..Quote: Back to statement #1: St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6 Case (a): P(A) = 0 and P(B) = 0.6, so P(A and B) = 0.6. This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of no. Case (b): P(A) = 0.8, P(B) = 0.75, events & A & B are independent: then P(A and B) = 0.6 This is consistent with Statement #1 gives a prompt answer of yes. Consistent with Statement #1, we can construct scenarios that produce either a yes or no answer to the prompt. Thus, statement #1, alone and by itself, is not sufficient. ] mikemcgarry, it seems you have taken OR in case (a) as the P(A and B) will be 0 in this case independent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(b).. P(b)=1.2 ... cannot be >1..... NOT possible dependent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(a/b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(a/b).. P(a/b)=1.2 cannot be >1 NOT possible P(a/b) is probability of b happening when a has already happened so it has to be less than P(a)statement I is sufficient
_________________
If you like my post, encourage me by providing Kudos... Happy Learning...



Manager
Joined: 27 Oct 2017
Posts: 91
Location: India
Concentration: International Business, General Management
GPA: 3.64
WE: Business Development (Energy and Utilities)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
02 Dec 2017, 20:10
Bunuel, GnpthPlease revise the OA to A. As discussed in the post above, OA should be A. Please provide Kudos to provide the right OA . Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self
_________________
If you like my post, encourage me by providing Kudos... Happy Learning...



PS Forum Moderator
Joined: 25 Feb 2013
Posts: 841
Location: India
GPA: 3.82

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Dec 2017, 01:30
Janvisahu wrote: Bunuel, GnpthPlease revise the OA to A. As discussed in the post above, OA should be A. Please provide Kudos to provide the right OA . Gnpth wrote: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5?
St1: The probability that events A and B both occur is 0.6
St2: A and B are Independent events.
Source Self Hi Janvisahu & chetan2uIn my opinion I would not consider statement 1 as sufficient for the simple reason that we do not know about the dependence and/or independence of events A & B Now as you have taken into account that even for dependent events P(A)>0.5 but does this statement clarifies what is event A and what is event B and what is there dependency Baye's theorem for conditional probability states that  \(P(A and B) = P(AB)*P(B)=P(BA)*P(A) =>P(AB)=\frac{P(BA)*P(A)}{P(B)}\) so per this statement and using your reasoning to find P(A), I can also have P(B)=0.6/P(AB). Now P(B)>0.5 and we know nothing about P(A) here. I'll illustrate this with simple example  Q) If in a town population of 180,000 females, 66.66666% can expect to live to age 60, while 40% can expect to live to age 80. Given that a woman is 60, what is the probability that she lives to age 80? This is an example of a conditional probability. In this case, the original sample space can be thought of as a set of 180,000 females. The events B and A are the subsets of the sample space consisting of all women who live at least 60 years, and at least 80 years, respectively. We consider B to be the new sample space, and note that A is a subset of B. Thus, the size of B is 120,000, and the size of A is 72,000. So, the probability in question equals 72,000/120,000= 0.6. Thus, a woman who is 60 has a 60% chance of living to age 80 Clearly I have utilized events A & B in a way to show P(A)<0.5, here The point I am trying to make is until and unless A & B are clearly defined we cannot use Statement 1 only to find the P(A). it can very well be used for P(B). Hence this statement is not sufficient. I might be wrong here and if we have any expert on Baye's theorem/discrete conditional probability, then I would definitely like to learn few things and stand corrected. I am also not sure whether Gnpth had thought of these scenarios before drafting the question. So we should give him the benefit of doubt and move ahead with Option C



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 5547

Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Dec 2017, 02:30
niks18 wrote: in my opinion I would not consider statement 1 as sufficient for the simple reason that we do not know about the dependence and/or independence of events A & B Now as you have taken into account that even for dependent events P(A)>0.5 but does this statement clarifies what is event A and what is event B and what is there dependency The point I am trying to make is until and unless A & B are clearly defined we cannot use Statement 1 only to find the P(A). it can very well be used for P(B). Hence this statement is not sufficient. I might be wrong here and if we have any expert on Baye's theorem/discrete conditional probability, then I would definitely like to learn few things and stand corrected. I am also not sure whether Gnpth had thought of these scenarios before drafting the question. So we should give him the benefit of doubt and move ahead with Option C Hi... We have had a long discussion already... Be it P(A) or P(B), Bayer's theorem or logic, none can be <0.6.. niks18 wrote: Baye's theorem for conditional probability states that 
\(P(A and B) = P(AB)*P(B)=P(BA)*P(A) =>P(AB)=\frac{P(BA)*P(A)}{P(B)}\)
so per this statement and using your reasoning to find P(A), I can also have P(B)=0.6/P(AB). Now P(B)>0.5 and we know nothing about P(A) here. Let's look the way you have suggested..P(A and B)=\(P(B)*P(\frac{A}{B})=0.6\).. Take the max value of P(B) to get the least value of \(P(\frac{A}{B})\).. \(1*P=0.6\)...so \(P(\frac{A}{B})=0.6\).. That is prob of A happening given B has already happened and B is 100% so P(A) boils down to 0.6 If \(P(B)=0.6\), then \(P(\frac{A}{B})\)=1.. means if b is happening, a will also happen, so P(A) also becomes 0.6.. Now let's discuss on the example given by you.. Quote: Q) If in a town population of 180,000 females, 66.66666% can expect to live to age 60, while 40% can expect to live to age 80. Given that a woman is 60, what is the probability that she lives to age 80? So, the probability in question equals 72,000/120,000= 0.6. Thus, a woman who is 60 has a 60% chance of living to age 80 Clearly I have utilized events A & B in a way to show P(A)<0.5, here You have taken P(60) as 1 and looking for P(80), so generally not the relationship we are looking for.. Also you have reduced the event to ONLY A, because you are taking people xg 80 as % of people xg 60 BUT the people xg 80 have to be taken as part of total..The Q of yours should look for P(people xg 60 AND people xg 80). Ofcourse it will be EQUAL to just people xg 80, so answer 40% Both p(60 and 80) and p(80) or whatever you want to call is 0.4 and the other P(60) is 1 Thus it doesn't fit in here.. Hope it helps..
_________________
Absolute modulus :http://gmatclub.com/forum/absolutemodulusabetterunderstanding210849.html#p1622372 Combination of similar and dissimilar things : http://gmatclub.com/forum/topic215915.html
BANGALORE/



Senior RC Moderator
Status: It always seems impossible until it's done!!
Joined: 29 Aug 2012
Posts: 1085
Location: India
GRE 1: 321 Q164 V157
WE: General Management (Aerospace and Defense)

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
03 Dec 2017, 09:23
Okay. I haven't fully thought through it. But I did come across many problems which used the reasoning to arrive that we need both to solve. But based on Chetan's analysis I guess I will take look at some more examples to conclusively get the discrepancies out. P.S I didn't intend to make it debatable OA. But was sure about the approach in the examples I saw and my own reasoning.
_________________
Become a GMAT Club Premium member to avail lot of discounts



Magoosh GMAT Instructor
Joined: 28 Dec 2011
Posts: 4651

Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5 [#permalink]
Show Tags
04 Dec 2017, 16:30
chetan2u wrote: mikemcgarry, it seems you have taken OR in case (a) as the P(A and B) will be 0 in this case independent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(b).. P(b)=1.2 ... cannot be >1..... NOT possible dependent events P(a and b) = P(a)*P(a/b) so 0.6 = 0.5*P(a/b).. P(a/b)=1.2 cannot be >1 NOT possible P(a/b) is probability of b happening when a has already happened so it has to be less than P(a)statement I is sufficient Dear chetan2u, It seems as if the debate is settling down at this point, but just for the record, I want to say to chetan2u: my brilliant colleague, you are 100% right and I made a pigheaded mistake. Of course, if P(A and B) = 0.6, then for that 60% of the time, event A is certainly happening. Therefore, form Statement #1, we absolutely know that event A happens at least 60% of the time, no formula needed. Statement #1 is sufficient. I don't know why I didn't think about it this way earlier. Thank you for pointing out my error, my friend. Mike
_________________
Mike McGarry Magoosh Test Prep
Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire. — William Butler Yeats (1865 – 1939)




Re: Is the probability of Event A greater than 0.5
[#permalink]
04 Dec 2017, 16:30






