nocilis
Several of a certain bank's top executives have recently been purchasing shares in their own bank. This activity has occasioned some surprise, since it is widely believed that the bank, carrying a large number of bad loans, is on the brink of collapse. Since the executives are well placed to know their bank's true condition, it might seem that their share purchases show that the danger of collapse is exaggerated. However, the available information about the bank's condition is from reliable and informed sources, and corporate executives do sometimes buy shares in their own company in a calculated attempt to calm worries about their company's condition. On balance, therefore, it is likely that the executives of the bank are following this example.
In the argument given, the two boldfaced portions play which of the following roles?
A. The first describes the circumstance the explanation of which is the issue that the argument addresses; the second states the main conclusion of the argument.
B. The first describes the circumstance the explanation of which is the issue the argument addresses; the second states a conclusion that is drawn in order to support the main conclusion of the argument.
C. The first provides evidence to defend the position that the argument seeks to establish against opposing positions; the second states the main conclusion of the argument.
D. The first provides evidence to support the position that the argument seeks to establish; the second states a conclusion that is drawn in order to support the argumentâ€TMs main conclusion.
E. Each provides evidence to support the position that the argument seeks to establish.
Situation:Several of a certain bank's top executives have recently been purchasing shares in their own bank.
Reaction to the situation:This is surprising because it is widely believed that the bank, carrying a large number of bad loans, is on the brink of collapse.
Since the executives are well placed to know their bank's true condition, it might seem that their share purchases show that the danger of collapse is exaggerated.
Consideration against the reaction:However, the available information about the bank's condition is from reliable and informed sources
Executives do sometimes buy shares in their own company in a calculated attempt to calm worries about their company's condition.
Conclusion:It is likely that the executives of the bank are following this example.
Let's jump on to the options directly.
(A) The first describes the circumstance the explanation of which is the issue that the argument addresses; the second states the main conclusion of the argument. Correct. The first is a surprising circumstance that the argument addresses (the reaction it is getting and what needs to be considered in light of it). The second is the main conclusion of the argument.
(B) The first describes the circumstance the explanation of which is the issue the argument addresses; the second states a conclusion that is drawn in order to support the main conclusion of the argument. The second is the main conclusion of the argument, not an intermediate conclusion. The explanation that the author gives of the circumstance is that the executives purchasing bank shares is a calculated attempt to allay fears. This is the author’s opinion. It is the main conclusion.
(C) The first provides evidence to defend the position that the argument seeks to establish against opposing positions; the second states the main conclusion of the argument. The first is not evidence to defend the position the argument seeks to establish. It is a situation that the argument seeks to discuss.
(D) The first provides evidence to support the position that the argument seeks to establish; the second states a conclusion that is drawn in order to support the argument’s main conclusion. Again, the first is not evidence to defend the position the argument seeks to establish. It is a situation that the argument seeks to discuss. The second is the main conclusion.
(E) Each provides evidence to support the position that the argument seeks to establish.Incorrect as discussed above.
Answer (A)Discussion on Boldface Questions:
https://youtu.be/U57vXdqujkY