gloomybison wrote:
VeritasKarishmaHi Karishma
I have a question regarding the Q4
Can't answer be A? in the last sentence it says "t is also not impossible that some European cartographer arbitrarily placed the name on the map" which caters to "
may have been invented by Ortelius in 1587"
In D it says "has a grammatical relationship to the names of two viceroys" though it may be true we are not %100 sure
"
If one of the two viceroys was thus honored, the place name was created by the relatively rare method of using the adjective form of the personal name, a derivation comparable to that of Smithsonian or Wagnerian."
all in all, having "may" pushed me to choose A over D because both are possible and option A states it "may" be rather than D which says "has", implying that Mendocino is %100 derived from names of viceroys
Thank you for your valuable replies:)
I get where you are coming from but there is a subtle point that leads us to the correct answer.
(4) According to the passage, the word “Mendocino”
(A) may have been invented by Ortelius in 1587
(B) came about as a result of a misunderstanding on the part of Duflot de Mofras
(C) was first heard by European explorers in the Philippines
(D) has a grammatical relationship to the names of two viceroys
(E) was first used by cartographers in 1542
We are talking about the WORD "Mendocino", not why the place was named so.
The passage tells us:
"...the place name was created by the relatively rare method of using the adjective form of the personal name, a derivation comparable to that of Smithsonian or Wagnerian. In Argentina, a Mendocino is a person from the city of Mendoza."
Since Mendoza was the name of the viceroys, the word Mendocino has a relation to it. Was the place named after the viceroys is irrelevant for this question.
"It is also not impossible that some European cartographer arbitrarily placed the name on the map."
This tells us that it is possible that the place was named so arbitrarily. Just the name Mendocino was put for the place but the passage doesn't say that the cartographer could have invented the word Mendocino. The cartographer could have used the name for the place.
Answer (D)