In most Western countries, parents use medicinal pills to help their
[#permalink]
Updated on: 26 Jul 2019, 02:18
Main conclusion of the argument: In most Western countries, by giving children pills to handle simple viral diseases, parents are actually harming them, because the children will be unable to deal with lethal viral disease, i.e. Ebola, smallpox or the Dengue virus.
A. What the most common pills against viral illnesses such as the flu are.
Understanding what the most common pills against viral illness are would neither strengthen nor weaken the main conclusion.
Whether we know or not the information about which pills are most common, any kind of common pills will be likely to handle the viral illness themselves, preventing the immune system of children from fully developing. As an unintended consequence, the children will be unable to deal with deadly viral diseases.
B. Whether the infant mortality rates for children in the West are higher now relative to what they were in the past.
This information is not useful to evaluate the argument.
- If the answer is YES, we are still uncertain what causes such higher mortality rates: more cases on low birth weight ?? nutrition deficiencies ?? traffic accident ?? etc.
- If the answer is NO, we may think that the changes in some other factors (e.g. better nutritional intake, better hygiene, increased prosperity) than lethal viral disease significantly lower the infant mortality rates for children.
C. Whether the lethal viral diseases mentioned are found in Western countries.
CORRECT ANSWER This information would be most effective and useful to evaluate the argument above.
- If the answer is YES, then this information strengthens the argument. Giving the children pill to cure simple viral disease actually harms them, because they will be unable to survive the lethal viral diseases that are now found in Western countries.
- If the answer is NO, then this information weakens the argument. Giving the children pill to cure simple viral disease won't necessarily harm them anyway, since they are not going to be exposed to the lethal viral diseases, i.e. Ebola, smallpox or the Dengue virus.
D. What percentage of parents in Western countries actually give their children pills
Understanding the percentage of parents in Western countries who actually give their children pills would neither strengthen nor weaken the main conclusion.
Even if there are more than 90% or less than 10% of parents who actually give their children pills, the pills will likely cure the simple viral illness themselves, preventing the immune system of children from fully developing. As a result, the children's immunity will not develop sufficiently to deal with the lethal viral diseases.
E. Whether new pills will be developed that will both defeat simple illnesses and aid the development of the immune system.
This information would neither strengthen nor weaken the main conclusion.
- If the answer is YES, such new pills are not currently available. Even if they are currently available, it is still uncertain how effective the new pills will aid the development of the immune system against lethal viral disease.
- If the answer is NO, any available pills will likely address the simple viral illness themselves, preventing the immune system of children from fully developing. Thus, these children's immunity will not be able to deal with lethal viral diseases.
Answer is (C)
Originally posted by
freedom128 on 26 Jul 2019, 02:01.
Last edited by
freedom128 on 26 Jul 2019, 02:18, edited 3 times in total.